Can Sylvia play as a forward ?

[Rogue 585]

It's not as if playing him out of the square is the only option either. A rangy HF flanker would be good too, floating in drifting in from the flanks... He can have variety if he's coached properly.

He's played that role for the majority of his time. He seems to get lost a fair bit though.

[titan_uranus 22,351]

Once you're on the list you take up as much space as anyone else, and I imagine the coaching staff pick players on merit.

You make a valid point regarding fans though - Sylvia's got far more praise than he's deserved through deeds on the field.

Now I just wish he would actually live up to some of those lofty expectations so that we can continue to heap praise on him.

[The Emblem 1]

Speaking of Morton, why the hell was he left out of the side V St Kilda with the flu - 3 days before the match. Surely that was the MFC way of saying the kid needs a rest.

3 days rest is enough if its a "man-cold", but in the modern game you'd barely last 10 minutes if you had a flu virus.

[two sheds jackson 3]

Great point Jerry, he's in the team because fans and the coaching staff are striving to see him deliver on the potential we all want him to have, rather than because he's delivering and deserves a spot. His high selection in the draft means people like Yze Magic believe he's going to be a star without him actually showing anything to suggest that.

I basically agree, but I think sometimes this can work the other way as well; as in, people had such high expectations when we picked him up that when he doesn't turn out to be the star we all hoped he would be, people start saying he's done nothing and shouldnt even get a game, which isnt really true. He seems to be a pretty divisive player on here; some people think he'll be a superstar and some think he's a dud. They're both probably wrong.

He had a reasonable year last year, and has been mostly solid in the backline this year- not fantastic but definitely a best 22-type. Forgetting where we picked him up in the draft and looking at him objectively just as a player, he looks like he'll be a handy footballer but no superstar. Its a shame we didn't do better with pick 3, but theres been plenty of much, much worse top ten picks.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 10,171]

I don't get it - he marks well, he kicks well, he's tough, a good tackler, makes good decisions, etc. but there is just something lacking. He simply is not involved in the action for long periods of games.

The thing he lacks is football smarts. He has excellent skills and makes good decisions it is his ability to know where to go to get the ball that is the issue.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 10,171]

If we had picked up Sylvia with pick 53 and not No.3, would he still be getting a game?

He would still be getting a game we just would not be writing threads about him as our expectations would be on the player himself and not what position someone chose to draft him.

[Guest redandbluethruandthru]

Sylvia may kick 5 goals total between now and the end of round 22. Hack of the highest order. But then that is what turns you on huh Yze-Magic??

[Mono 454]

I agree with you Yze Magic, put him in the square and say kick us some goals. He's got a huge vertical leap, strong hands and a thumping accurate kick. Why we haven't experimented with Col at FF during a NAB cup series at least is beyond me.

You are Y_M's twin. Not the same surely?

[Yze_Magic 3]

Well the jury is in.

Colin CAN play as a forward (which I knew all along)

6 scoring shots, for a return of 3.2 is a good days work.

Should have booted 5.0 as he missed two easy set shots.

Only a matter of time before 'The Kid' kicks a bag of 8.

[The Fergburger 0]

Well the jury is in.

Colin CAN play as a forward (which I knew all along)

6 scoring shots, for a return of 3.2 is a good days work.

Should have booted 5.0 as he missed two easy set shots.

Only a matter of time before 'The Kid' kicks a bag of 8.

Mate, don't get too excited yet. He played ok today, His defensive pressure was terrible. when he had the ball he was exciting.I don't think Colin will dominate in the near future, give him 12 months

[mfcrox 143]

Well the jury is in.

Colin CAN play as a forward (which I knew all along)

6 scoring shots, for a return of 3.2 is a good days work.

Should have booted 5.0 as he missed two easy set shots.

Only a matter of time before 'The Kid' kicks a bag of 8.

Yeah, the jury is in on two points:

- Sylvia IS a viable option up forward... I agree with you on that point

- You failed maths... how does 3 goals, 2 behinds add up to 6 scoring shots? LoL

Keep up the good work mate

[Yze_Magic 3]

Yeah, the jury is in on two points:

- Sylvia IS a viable option up forward... I agree with you on that point

- You failed maths... how does 3 goals, 2 behinds add up to 6 scoring shots? LoL

Keep up the good work mate

because he had a direct shot from a mark that didnt make the distance!

[mfcrox 143]

because he had a direct shot from a mark that didnt make the distance!

Yeah, it didn't score though... so just a 'shot' not a 'scoring shot'. Meh, who cares!!!

[Yze_Magic 3]

Yeah, it didn't score though... so just a 'shot' not a 'scoring shot'. Meh, who cares!!!

Ok, poor use of words by me.

Sylvia had SIX SHOTS ON GOAL. One failed to make the distance.

[dreamin' man 0]

wonder if anyone saw the ch 10 coverage of the game. in the last 6-10 minutes when the opposition was chipping it around but there was still a faint hope for us blight was v. critical of sylvia for being the only one who didn't man up. they put the camera on him running around, doing his own thing.

[Dannyz 2,313]

His played in a range of positions this year.

Back, Forward, Midfield, Wing.

What do we do with him now. Hes been given enough time to develop, is he going to be the classy midfielder we all hoped?

[Tolstoys Nudge 1,238]

Look 2 trade him...

Look, I was so excited when we drafted him, it just hasnt happened, for alot of reasons..

But, I think he's best as an attacking Midfielder, and he was drafted as one, so keep him there and see what happens, I really would love him to stick it up my ass, because id wanna see him reach his potential, which is MASSIVE!..and he might, is getting 5 % better each week..

He can save himself, but time is NOW!!

[Jerry Lundergard 382]

Look 2 trade him...

Look, I was so excited when we drafted him, it just hasnt happened, for alot of reasons..

But, I think he's best as an attacking Midfielder, and he was drafted as one, so keep him there and see what happens, I really would love him to stick it up my ass, because id wanna see him reach his potential, which is MASSIVE!..and he might, is getting 5 % better each week..

He can save himself, but time is NOW!!

Nudge, easy on there big fella.

[Hazyshadeofgrinter 80]

Nudge, easy on there big fella.

Oh man, It's just too much isn't it?

hahahahahahah

[H_T 2,941]

Agree. Sylvia's challenge is the same as Bartram and Millers. They need to justify their selection.

After 5 years on the list Sylvia has shown he could be a steady capable player for MFC. However, I have seen little to suggest that he would be the "star" we crave for.

Agree totally, and with Neitz and Robbo out of the side, Bailey should throw him the challenge. Still don't think he has matured yet. His body is ready, just not sure if his footy brain is at the level required. It needs to come from within him. He has been nurtured enough. Come on Hi Ho Sylvia lets see those competitive juices "really flow"! he's played 60-odd games now....hopefully it is time to blossom.