Judd to Melb

[Nasher 33,616]

You're not Michael Newton Magic over at 'ology are you?

He definitely isn't.

[Diablo 1]

He definitely isn't.

Inside Mod info?

Well thats good. It looks like we're getting this from two sources now.

[Choko 493]

You're not Michael Newton Magic over at 'ology are you? Because I think he is getting the same info as you (including the fact that the announcement was changed from Friday to Monday).

No, I am not. I'm just me, and it looks like I am puttin gmy life on the line here!!! If you have a look at the posts I made, I am not trying to big note myself. I have simply stated facts and tried to evaluate them.

Hutchie said it owuld be announced today, then later in the same function, he said Monday. Because he did say it, it wouldn't surpise me if MNM got the same mail from the same function.

[Diablo 1]

No, I am not. I'm just me, and it looks like I am puttin gmy life on the line here!!! If you have a look at the posts I made, I am not trying to big note myself. I have simply stated facts and tried to evaluate them.

Hutchie said it owuld be announced today, then later in the same function, he said Monday. Because he did say it, it wouldn't surpise me if MNM got the same mail from the same function.

Mate don't get me wrong, I'm not doubting you.

[Gorgoroth 12,950]

I just wish it would be announced so i can bloody well relax and be happy!

[QueenC 74]

Mate don't get me wrong, I'm not doubting you.

We don't want to doubt you :D !!!

[deestroy08 0]

I just wish it would be announced so i can bloody well relax and be happy!

Same here. :angry:

Can someone call SEN during the SoapBox session and just bring Judd up again?

I need to hear more news, or rumours or just something!

[mikeod 21]

Same here. :angry:

Can someone call SEN during the SoapBox session and just bring Judd up again?

I need to hear more news, or rumours or just something!

Good idea... off you go deestroy08!

[deestroy08 0]

Haha no!

Did anyone else hear "Matt's" message about the GF being a snoozefest and the real prize being Judd?

YzeMagic?!

[mikeod 21]

Haha no!

Did anyone else hear "Matt's" message about the GF being a snoozefest and the real prize being Judd?

YzeMagic?!

I thought exactly the same thing...!

[Gorgoroth 12,950]

Sounds like Y_M

[Deelicious9 0]

I was talking to my friend last night who is a current MFC player and we were talking about Judd to melbourne. I said he wouldn't go, he seemed to think he would so i said let's have a bet on it and he reluctantly declined.

Anyway, today at around 2ish i got a message from him saying "so how much do you want to bet on Judd coming to melbourne?"

Food for thought....

[Forest Demon 4,681]

Carlton fans on bigfooty are certain he has chosen us. They reckon it will hurt us to give up our picks more than them because apparently we have a weak forward line, defence and ruck and it will be a one man show. Pretty rich...

[Diablo 1]

Carlton fans on bigfooty are certain he has chosen us. They reckon it will hurt us to give up our picks more than them because apparently we have a weak forward line, defence and ruck and it will be a one man show. Pretty rich...

Bitterness. They all thought they were a lay-down misere when this thing started.

As you said, it's pretty rich coming from an outfit like Carlton, who have one extremely temperamental full forward, a couple of half-decent youngsters and one good midfielder to hang their hats on.

[Jaded No More 68,915]

Carlton fans on bigfooty are certain he has chosen us. They reckon it will hurt us to give up our picks more than them because apparently we have a weak forward line, defence and ruck and it will be a one man show. Pretty rich...

As opposed to Carlton, who even if they don't give up any of their players or picks, will still have a weak forward line, defense and ruck!

Carlton- trying to buy their way out of the gutter and failing miserably.

[Choko 493]

As opposed to Carlton, who even if they don't give up any of their players or picks, will still have a weak forward line, defense and ruck!

Carlton- trying to buy their way out of the gutter and failing miserably.

Ok. What Hutchie said is this:

Judd to Melb for picks 3, 9 and 21.

Pick 9 we will get for Frawley to St Kilda.

Now, not saying it's true. Simply saying that, as a matter of absolute fact, that is the word from Hutchie.

He said we want to get it done early in trade week.

[Diablo 1]

Ok. What Hutchie said is this:

Judd to Melb for picks 3, 9 and 21.

Pick 9 we will get for Frawley to St Kilda.

Now, not saying it's true. Simply saying that, as a matter of absolute fact, that is the word from Hutchie.

He said we want to get it done early in trade week.

You mean pick 4.

And lame. I don't want Spud Junior to go.

Assuming you meant pick 4 it's perfectly plausible though.

[demon me 0]

Same here. :angry:

Can someone call SEN during the SoapBox session and just bring Judd up again?

I need to hear more news, or rumours or just something!

I heard today that judd was impressed with Bailey and that were in the box seat!

I dont know what were offering but I heard Colin Silvias name

[Jaded No More 68,915]

Ok. What Hutchie said is this:

Judd to Melb for picks 3, 9 and 21.

Pick 9 we will get for Frawley to St Kilda.

Now, not saying it's true. Simply saying that, as a matter of absolute fact, that is the word from Hutchie.

He said we want to get it done early in trade week.

So we're losing pick 4, Frawley and pick 21?

That sounds ok to me. Hopefully we can try to get a top 10 pick without having to lose Frawley though. I would think that given West Coast's interest in Frawley last year, that they'd be happy with Frawley himself (rather than pick 9).

Did Hutchy say when the announcement will be made, or heaven forbid, his source? <_<

[Nasher 33,616]

If we can do the deal somehow without losing Frawley I'd be happier, but would do that deal.

[Forest Demon 4,681]

We will have to give up picks 4 and 21 and a player. Would u prefer a young player like Frawley or an established player like TJ. Personally, i would prefer give up TJ

[Diablo 1]

So we're losing pick 4, Frawley and pick 21?

That sounds ok to me. Hopefully we can try to get a top 10 pick without having to lose Frawley though. I would think that given West Coast's interest in Frawley last year, that they'd be happy with Frawley himself (rather than pick 9).

Did Hutchy say when the announcement will be made, or heaven forbid, his source? <_<

In fairness Jaded, Hutchie hasn't got to be the little sniffer dog he is by giving up his sources. What we do know is that he's usually on the money, especially when the announcement is not too far away.

Agreed about Frawley. I woulda thought Weagles would rather take him than Pick 9, and it would save us involving a third party. Perhaps there is some complication with Frawley not wanting to go to Perth though. That wouldn't surprise me. It would be kind of bastard of us to ship him off there after 1 year.

[Goodvibes 3,596]

I would have thought we'd need to offload a Johnstone or a Robbo or both to create enough salary cap relief.

[lucifer 119]

Just on Channel 9 - reported that we're the big movers, and that it's definetly down to Melbourne & The Filth. Seemed more positive about the dees though.

[occo 2]

Tony Jones announced that Judd is expected to go to melbourne. Apparently he was very impressed with Dean Baley and wants to play on the G as the home ground. In my opinion this is good and bad news. I would love him but will cost too much. Thoughts