What would you give up

[Springfield Isotopes 0]

What is the most you would give for Judd? (2 player and 3 draft pick max)

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Probably Pick 4, one of Green/TJ and maybe another pick or a sweetener??

[Geddy Lee 582]

I would give up anyone but Rivers and Jones. Yes I would give up McLean, I want to see Judd in a Melbourne guernsey.

What is the most I would give up for Judd? Anymore than Pick 4 and another Top 10 pick or v. good player is too much to lose.

[dees_rule_4eva 22]

I honestly think that a deal like Pick 4, Johnstone and someone like Bate would be enough.

[Jerry Lundergard 382]

I honestly think that a deal like Pick 4, Johnstone and someone like Bate would be enough.

Swap Sylvia for Bate, and i'm happy with that.

[Guest unstable punt]

I honestly think that a deal like Pick 4, Johnstone and someone like Bate would be enough.

Robbo and Sylvia plus 4 & 21

[warren dean 193]

Swap Sylvia for Bate, and i'm happy with that.

It's not about what we are willing to give but what the Eagles might want. Would they want a midfield player - Kerr, Cousins, Embley, Priddis etc is still a very potent midfield and probably the best in the comp as a collective. Would they want a Johnstone? Their greatest need is a key forward - who do we have who could fit that bill? I think we might need to trade for another first round pick to add to pick 4 if we want to get over the line on this one.

[deestroy08 0]

A player has to agree to a trade, don't they?

So there could be a chance that the most perfect of trades could fall through all because a player doesn't want to go anywhere?

I'm up for trading Robbo, CJ, pick 4 and pick 20.

[Oxxx 0]

What is the most you would give for Judd? (2 player and 3 draft pick max)

I'd give up my house for him.

[Jaded No More 58,358]

No to Rivers, McLean and Jones (who we can't trade anyways as he just signed a new deal).

Everyone else is fair game.

[beelzebub 22,230]

Lets see Gazza has offered up his first born... My ex would kill me.. so anyone else.. Jaded?? can you match ?lol

( just kidding folks )

[deanox 8,676]

i heard jaded was gonna give judd HIS first born, not hers, because he has to get in line behind mclean, bell etc...

behind that little picture of stewie jaded might just be putting up a bit of competition for twigs if CJ decides to come over the the dark side.

[Jaded No More 58,358]

i heard jaded was gonna give judd HIS first born, not hers, because he has to get in line behind mclean, bell etc...

behind that little picture of stewie jaded might just be putting up a bit of competition for twigs if CJ decides to come over the the dark side.

Yeah, because me > Twiggly... it's a no-brainer for Juddy!

I haven't got money, properties or children to give away, but if Judd has a secret fetish for dressing up in women's clothing...

[Bruce Almighty 0]

Robbo and PJ to bulldogs for pick 5, Pick 4 and Chris Johnson and pick 5 for JUDD. Our second round pick for Maguire

[BrownlowBruce 1]

Robbo and PJ to bulldogs for pick 5, Pick 4 and Chris Johnson and pick 5 for JUDD. Our second round pick for Maguire

pj ey why dont we just send him back to the eagles for judd... haha

[Mojo 0]

It's been mentioned that we are in a good financial position to give Judd an offer. Exactly how much can we give him? Can we match $7 million over five years that Carlton can potentially offer? He states it's not about money but who in their right mind would give up a million or two? I think he will choose the club that benifets him financially.

[DeezMan 4]

I'd be willing to give up pick 4, Green/Bruce and Sylvia/Robbo.

Undecided which pair I'd give up, however.

[CARN THE DEES! 14]

Robbo and Sylvia plus 4 & 21

Too much we get robbed.. Judd is amazing but still only one player, I think Robbo and Sylvia alone would get Judd but i wouldn't trade them personally.

My trade (as i've stated b4) is:

Miller and Green/Bruce/TJ

That should buy Judd but if WCE still arent sold then they can have our third round pick.

I chose Miller because he is a young versitile KPP that can play very well in the west and is a leader. Tall, strong and can through his weight around. Saying that I still believe in Miller and if he doesn't get traded then I would still welcome him in the Red and Blue as i would like to see what he can do under a new coach.

Green/Bruce/TJ are obvious reason as they need something high quality class provided in these players and fill the spot (well half fill) of Judd. Although we lose a leader and quality midfielder we gain Judd and he fills both of those shoes.

[CURTIS 0]

I'd give up my house for him.

my left lung, knee my first born child!

Anything for the great man!

Imagine jumper presentation day garry lyon handing over the no 3 gurnsey to judd!

[The Fergburger 0]

Robbo + pick 37 for pick 5. Then Pick 5 + CJ +Miller for Judd

[Yze_Magic 3]

Robbo + pick 37 for pick 5.

Im our dreams

[Geddy Lee 582]

Why the hell would West Coast want Miller?

[Gouga 511]

Picks 4 and 21 plus Chris Johnson should be enough.

I hope the club is strong, remember West Coast don't want to lose him for nothing. They don't have us by the short and curlys like some of the trades above are suggesting.

[CARN THE DEES! 14]

Why the hell would West Coast want Miller?

I explained it... they need another forward and miller is young shows potential has heart shows leadership etc etc. He fits the cretria in almost every situation except that he struggles with confidence and this effects his performance.

Now you saw it last year and he was showing potential and he was doing it again this year. Sometimes I think people will label someone something and never change their views even if the evidence against us. But Miller definetly has potential you can't deny that the only problem is he has been showing it ever since joined the club and hasnt taken the step up.

[mikeod 21]

Pick 4, a player of West Coast's choice (except McLean, Jones, Rivers and Sylvia), and Pick 22 (or another player of Pick22 value)