8 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Maybe Roos.

Dogs probably still a chance.

If Silvagni goes to the Dogs, even the Pies might have a nibble, with Howe now suspect and Moore needing help.

If not he plays his last year with us.

That's if he gets on the park Mr. Leg. In the last 2 years he has played a hand full of games. Seems to be having a lot of injuries to his feet. Next year I would be surprised if he got 10 games. In fact very surprised. That being the case now is the time to off load him while he has a small amount of currency left. Of course it is all speculation. He might be very happy getting paid a lot of money for a small number of games.

3 minutes ago, old dee said:

That's if he gets on the park Mr. Leg. In the last 2 years he has played a hand full of games. Seems to be having a lot of injuries to his feet. Next year I would be surprised if he got 10 games. In fact very surprised. That being the case now is the time to off load him while he has a small amount of currency left. Of course it is all speculation. He might be very happy getting paid a lot of money for a small number of games.

He played 16 this year and suspended for 3 though concussed for 1 of those, so not like he doesn’t play most games.

But 34 before next season and won’t kill our chances if he leaves.

Whatever he was a big part in our flag and that should never be forgotten.

20 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Maybe Roos.

Dogs probably still a chance.

If Silvagni goes to the Dogs, even the Pies might have a nibble, with Howe now suspect and Moore needing help.

If not he plays his last year with us.

Hypothetical...

No takers... or deals baulked.. etc..

May remains..

How does that play out as a schism seems to be/been developing.

Tbh.. there are elements of May I like... some... not so much.

Does time simply get called ?? 🤔

16 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Hypothetical...

No takers... or deals baulked.. etc..

May remains..

How does that play out as a schism seems to be/been developing.

Tbh.. there are elements of May I like... some... not so much.

Does time simply get called ?? 🤔

They won’t call time on May.

It will be trade or stay final year.

59 minutes ago, Tarax Club said:

Vote 1 Max Gruwezski

given the reoccurence of the injury to hogan, there's no way that they're letting him go

It needs to be said that WE uploaded the May vision. Another own goal ⚽.

The new CEO won't be happy with the comms team.

The best defender I've seen at Melbourne in my time and one of the most influential on-field players. Has single-handedly won matches for us with almost superhuman efforts.

With that said, there a bit of Akermanis about him; in that success covers up a lot of of problems. When the success dries up, people's tolerance of off field issues wears very thin, very quickly.

21 minutes ago, Redleg said:

They won’t call time on May.

It will be trade or stay final year.

Is May contracted fir 26 ?

6 minutes ago, SthSea22 said:

I would be happy with the players mentioned for our future

B - McVee, Petty, McDonald

HB - Turner, Derksen, Bowey

12 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Low hanging fruit. Also, seems like a pretty casual address; sitting at the back of the room speaking to the backs of the players. If this is what the ‘media’ are reporting on these days, then God [censored] help them.

agree

29 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Is May contracted fir 26 ?

Hit the one year extension this season, contracted for 2026.

Why keep mentioning Derkson, If he was such a wonderful player he would be getting games at his own club.

Dogs with zero interest in May according to Sammy Edmund

27 minutes ago, 640MD said:

Why keep mentioning Derkson, If he was such a wonderful player he would be getting games at his own club.

I'd rather we prioritise Jed Adams, who looks to me, to have decent 1v1 capabilities, a nice kick and a good ability to read the play.

2 hours ago, Redleg said:

He played 16 this year and suspended for 3 though concussed for 1 of those, so not like he doesn’t play most games.

But 34 before next season and won’t kill our chances if he leaves.

Whatever he was a big part in our flag and that should never be forgotten.

Sorry I was referring to Lever.

23 minutes ago, adonski said:

Dogs with zero interest in May according to Sammy Edmund

I wouldn't say no to paying 25% of his salary if that got them interested

6 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

I wouldn't say no to paying 25% of his salary if that got them interested

Surely the one year extension, the last of his career, wouldn't be on big bucks would it?

1 minute ago, roy11 said:

Surely the one year extension, the last of his career, wouldn't be on big bucks would it?

You would not think so but it would still be $450-600k is my guess

May will only get traded out if the return is too good to ignore. If its an early second rounder from the Dogs, North (Wonder if Filth or Dons would need a 1-2 year loan for young guys to develop in that time-span) then in my eyes it'll be a thank you for your service and goodbye.

1 minute ago, KoltTheRam said:

May will only get traded out if the return is too good to ignore. If its an early second rounder from the Dogs, North (Wonder if Filth or Dons would need a 1-2 year loan for young guys to develop in that time-span) then in my eyes it'll be a thank you for your service and goodbye.

Can't see any team paying up a second rounder for a 33 year old who was already slowing down this year.

1 minute ago, KozzyCan said:

Can't see any team paying up a second rounder for a 33 year old who was already slowing down this year.

Thats why I said only if the return is too good to ignore. I highly doubt we would get a second back in return, which is why i reckon he stays.

May is one of the few players on our list who has won games or turned games completely 100% off his own bat.

Whether his criticism and frustration is unwarranted at times, that is the best and truest form of leadership from a football perspective.

There seems no upside here. At 34 we will probably get almost nothing in return.

The trouble with our defense is that we have too many that are not physical. May and to a lesser extent TMac Salem and Turner engage with their opponents whereas McVee Howes Bowey and Adams are a lot softer. Lever is somewhere between the 2. I've left out Rivers as he spends more time midfield. We never replaced Hibberd in that role and AMW who is also physical was out for the year. When May is firing he plays well, but you can hardly blame him for being careful after all his suspensions. Age is now catching him and struggles against fast leading forwards like Gunston. He still has the year on his contract so I am sure he will continue on and unless we find a like for like, will probably play most games. Sestan has the body to be physical so will be interesting to see if they keep him on.

2 hours ago, 640MD said:

Why keep mentioning Derkson, If he was such a wonderful player he would be getting games at his own club.

He has a toe injury and is out for the season.

It was foolish to give him another year. He was solid this season, not great and exposed for speed. If the club wanted him, they could've lowballed based on his injuries and suspension. If another club wanted him then so be it. They take the risk. He won't be worth much in a trade and, unfortunately, I believe he'll see his great career at Casey.

Poor communication from Gawn, he should have stood up and addressed the team from the front of the group, demanded their attention.

May like Kozi play their best footy hot and nasty.

Both have mellowed after suspensions.