Final changes

[dazzledavey36 49,162]

Yze in and brown dropped! buckley named emergency along with brown and holland

[BrownlowBruce 1]

Yze in and brown dropped! buckley named emergency along with brown and holland

good.. i am very happy with that....

buckley unlucky, but he will get his chance

[demonsflag555657 3]

Backs: D.Ward, N.Carroll, C.Bruce

Half backs: P.Wheatley, C.Bizzell, D.Bell

Centreline: T.Johnstone, J.McDonald, A.Davey

Half forwards: B.Green, R.Robertson, S.Godfrey

Forwards: C.Sylvia, D.Neitz, M.Bate

Followers: J.White, B.McLean, N.Jones

I/C From: P.Johnson, R.Petterd, J.Frawley, A.Yze

Emg: S.Buckley, N Brown, B.Holland

[Yze_Magic 3]

Carroll vs Rocca?

[demonsflag555657 3]

Carroll vs Rocca?

Carroll will kill him

[Little Goffy 12,764]

Yze in and brown dropped! buckley named emergency along with brown and holland

I must admit I kinda thought it would be Ward who'd be dropped, even though he got twice the possessions of Brown.

Brown did a job on Mcleod, and did it well.

Ward has just been too loose, and his, uhhh... overexcitement... in the last quarter was one of the reasons Adelaide was let back in the game.

I love em both, I really do, but I like Ward better as a BOG player at Sandy.

[Jaded No More 58,832]

Melbourne probably know that Rocca won't play.

Carroll on Holland makes me nervous, but am very happy that they didn't drop Frawley!

Glad Yze is back for his annual demolition of the Pies. Also leaves Davey to roam up the ground.

[Demon Head 250]

Melbourne probably know that Rocca won't play.

Carroll on Holland makes me nervous, but am very happy that they didn't drop Frawley!

Glad Yze is back for his annual demolition of the Pies. Also leaves Davey to roam up the ground.

Why?

Was he under an injury cloud?

[Jaded No More 58,832]

Why?

Was he under an injury cloud?

Yep, didn't train yesterday and Malthouse said he's struggling but should get up.

Melbourne probably know better, or they'll make a late change if Rocca does get up (probably Dutchy in, Frawley out).

[demon_fanatic 4]

Great team, possible our best all season?? who we got missing now from our best 22 i can think of Rivers, Whelan, Moloney, Pickett off the top of my head....

go dees...

[maximum bob 462]

Great to see the Bizz rewarded for some good form. I for one had doubted his value and whether he'd make it back at all but good on him for persevering.

Let's hope he plays as well as he did last week. It'll go a long way to helping us win on Monday.

[Jaded No More 58,832]

Great team, possible our best all season?? who we got missing now from our best 22 i can think of Rivers, Whelan, Moloney, Pickett off the top of my head....

go dees...

Bartram.

The kid is so underrated. He is easily in our best 22!

[dazzledavey36 49,162]

Mark Jamar :D <_<

[deanox 8,762]

rivers, wheelen, moloney, pickett and bartram are in our best 23 or 24.

ward, bizzel, godfrey and yze are the players playing for melbourne this week who would struggle to get a game if the above 5 were also available. (i have left frawley in for now but if his form tapers off either holland or bizzel could be the replacement, depedning on the opposition.

its interesting because imo bizzel for rivers is a straight swap, ward for wheelan is a straight swap, leaving 5 to fight it our for 2 places.

do you agree with my assessment of the best 22?

of godfrey, yze, moloney, pickett and bartram, which 2 would you pick for the last two spots?

[Adzman 2,085]

yze always slays collingwood.

The seem to have trouble matching up on the ooooze.

We are underdogs, but i dont know too many people who would back their house on the pies.

Should be a cracker

[WonnaJurah 5]

Miller

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

rivers, wheelen, moloney, pickett and bartram are in our best 23 or 24.

ward, bizzel, godfrey and yze are the players playing for melbourne this week who would struggle to get a game if the above 5 were also available. (i have left frawley in for now but if his form tapers off either holland or bizzel could be the replacement, depedning on the opposition.

its interesting because imo bizzel for rivers is a straight swap, ward for wheelan is a straight swap, leaving 5 to fight it our for 2 places.

do you agree with my assessment of the best 22?

of godfrey, yze, moloney, pickett and bartram, which 2 would you pick for the last two spots?

The strongest back line IMO.

FB: Whelan Carroll Bell

HB: Bizzell Rivers Petterd / Bartram

Players missing from the best 22:

Pickett, Whelan, Moloney, Rivers, Bartram

[Gorgoroth 12,351]

not that big a fan of brown but he was 1,000 times better than ward, i watched the replay and ward massacred the ball 3 times in a row in the last quater alone!

[deanox 8,762]

The strongest back line IMO.

FB: Whelan Carroll Bell

HB: Bizzell Rivers Petterd / Bartram

Players missing from the best 22:

Pickett, Whelan, Moloney, Rivers, Bartram

no woz with biz for frawley (when compared to my best 22). frawley is yet unprovven but im not sure if bizz will be around next year and frawley does have the height advantage...these two plus holland might be the toss up for the 3rd tall spot horses for courses style, but i cant help but think bizz and rivers are competing for the same spot atm...

clint you listed the same 5 players that i did as being out of the best 22. that means we need to drop 5 players from the current 22 to get them in. which 5 are gone for you? ward, frawley? godfrey or yze? and we need another. when i did the best 22 scenario i found we had 1 extra midfielder meaning moloney or jones missed out. jmac is on his way out, and chances are we will always have an injury or two so this scenario will be covered, but im just wondering what you have...

[Jaded No More 58,832]

of godfrey, yze, moloney, pickett and bartram, which 2 would you pick for the last two spots?

Moloney and Bartram.

The more time goes by, the more Godfrey and Yze become depth (well Godfrey has always been depth).

Pickett will be lucky to get a contract extension.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

no woz with biz for frawley (when compared to my best 22). frawley is yet unprovven but im not sure if bizz will be around next year and frawley does have the height advantage...these two plus holland might be the toss up for the 3rd tall spot horses for courses style, but i cant help but think bizz and rivers are competing for the same spot atm...

clint you listed the same 5 players that i did as being out of the best 22. that means we need to drop 5 players from the current 22 to get them in. which 5 are gone for you? ward, frawley? godfrey or yze? and we need another. when i did the best 22 scenario i found we had 1 extra midfielder meaning moloney or jones missed out. jmac is on his way out, and chances are we will always have an injury or two so this scenario will be covered, but im just wondering what you have...

ATM I'd take out Ward, Godfrey, Wheatley, Frawley and Yze.

Pickett in for Yze, Whelan in for Ward, Moloney in for Godfrey, Rivers in for Frawley, Bartram in for Wheatley.

Having said that, on form I do think that the likes of Yze and Wheatley do have a spot in the side.

Frawley will have his time later on.

[deanox 8,762]

good call on wheatley. one swallow doesnt make a summer. but i think if he is in form and played in the right position he can be very valuable.

i think this goes to show that our top say 24 are pretty good. we may lack a player of absolute star quality but overall our top list is good. its our depth that really struggles. ward, brown, godfrey, holland, ferguson, jamar, warnock, and then the developing: CJ, miller and dunn, arent quite up to it yet. although i think thats a bit harsh on dunn.

actually whats interesting about that list. apart from godfrey we bearly have a depth midfielder so we? we have spare tall defenders, tall forwards, running back flankers, a winger or two, and a ruck but no spare midfielders.

any ideas?

actually i think this might even deserve a thread of its own, because it is off topic...

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

...

I forgot about Dunn to be honest, but he would be close.

[deeangel 2]

Miller

Indeed I agree as well but let's not go there - I don't need another long debate on that.

Dunn as well.

We are going to have some depth when they all get up.

[Madness 44]

Great team, possible our best all season?? who we got missing now from our best 22 i can think of Rivers, Whelan, Moloney, Pickett off the top of my head....

go dees...

Barts, can't forget Barts...