Delistings 2024

[Dee-tonator 225]

Our trading policy over the past few seasons has unfortunately misfired badly, landing us with plenty of list cloggers such as Schache, Hunter, Billings, Fullarton and McAdam.

Now I fear we will probably cave in and accept being shafted yet again when ANB's move to South Australia is finalised.

And Casey's dismal performances this season suggest that the hopes being pinned on some of the younger brigade may not be well founded. (I would love to be proved wrong).

If Tim Lamb doesn't get it right this time around, his role must come under serious scrutiny.

Unless the Big Four (Gawn, Petracca, Oliver and May) all avoid serious injury and produce their best, our so-called premiership window may be firmly closed by the end of next season.

That's not being a pessimist, just a realist.

 

 

 

 

[spirit of norm smith 16,044]

2024 squad = 45. 😭ANB (crows) BBB (⏰)Gus (med ret) , Hunter (⏰) JS29, KFW, Schache. Tomlinson likely to go.  So now 37. 

??? Marty Hore??? Staying or delisted???

⭐️Gawn, Petracca, Viney, May, Oliver (tbc) ❤️kozzzy  (6)

soldiers: Rivers, McVee , Lever, Windsor, JVR, Bowey, Chandler,  Fritsch, Howes, Langdon, Petty, Salem, Sparrow, Tholstrup, Turner (15)

The one more year club… ANW,  Woey jnr, KBrown,… Verrall, Sestan,  Billings, Fullarton, Spargo, Kentfield, Tmcd*, Melksham* (could be high turnover at end of 2025)  (11) 

The two more years club …  Jefferson, Adams, Laurie, McAdam (contracted to 2026) (4)

[old55 23,292]

If GWS holds Derksen and Tomo gets to Collingwood, St.Kilda or elsewhere then retaining Hore seems likely to me.

Edited October 7 by old55

[Sydee 4,372]

30 minutes ago, old55 said:

If GWS holds Derksen and Tomo gets to Collingwood, St.Kilda or elsewhere then retaing Hore seems likely to me.

You mean unlikely right? 

[Neil Crompton 5,414]

10 minutes ago, Sydee said:

You mean unlikely right? 

No

[Sydee 4,372]

11 minutes ago, Neil Crompton said:

No

Yes sorry misunderstood what you said - I agree 

[roy11 3,812]

 

Thought he'd end up at the saints, not sure how much game time he'd get at the others

[BScotti 177]

interesting to see we we trade for him or if the view by clubs is that we will delist him anyway and someone can pick him up for nothing as a DFA.

 

[spirit of norm smith 16,044]

2024 squad = 45. 😭ANB (crows) BBB (⏰)Gus (med ret) , Hunter (⏰) JS29, KFW, Schache. Tomlinson likely to go.  
37
??? Marty Hore??? Staying or delisted???

⭐️Gawn, Petracca, Viney, May, Oliver (tbc) ❤️kozzzy  (6)

soldiers: Rivers, McVee , Lever, Windsor, JVR, Bowey, Chandler,  Fritsch, Howes, Langdon, Petty, Salem, Sparrow, Tholstrup, Turner (15)

The one more year club… ANW,  Woey jnr, KBrown,… Verrall, Sestan,  Billings, Fullarton, Spargo, Kentfield, Tmcd*, Melksham* (could be high turnover at end of 2025)  (11) 

The two more years club …  Jefferson, Adams, Laurie, McAdam (contracted to 2026) (4) and ??? Tom Campbell  - unsure of contract length 

 

[monoccular 17,399]

8 hours ago, BScotti said:

interesting to see we we trade for him or if the view by clubs is that we will delist him anyway and someone can pick him up for nothing as a DFA.

 

him - who?

[DeeZone 9,458]

I think it is Tomlinson.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,587]

Can't blame Lamb when we pickup no one. It was own goals that caused all that. 

[roy11 3,812]

 

Tomlinson from depth to depth? 

[DeeSpencer 25,321]

47 minutes ago, roy11 said:

 

Tomlinson from depth to depth? 

You don’t think anyone watched Tomlinson the last few years and thought he was a best 22 player right?

Moving from Steve May’s back up to competing with Billy Frampton would be a smart move for him though. 

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,655]

Collinwood must have remembered Tomlinson's career best game against them in Kings Bday 2023, the one where he got dropped the following week.

[roy11 3,812]

24 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

You don’t think anyone watched Tomlinson the last few years and thought he was a best 22 player right?

Moving from Steve May’s back up to competing with Billy Frampton would be a smart move for him though. 

Thought he'd be an ok Battle replacement FWIW

[DeeSpencer 25,321]

21 minutes ago, roy11 said:

Thought he'd be an ok Battle replacement FWIW

With Wilkie and Howard the Saints don’t need to play 3 experienced talls, depth would help but the smart long term play for them is to expose some kids.

[58er 6,301]

On 17/09/2024 at 16:54, leave it to deever said:

Tx for this 

Not much of a return from old Schacke.

Same with McAdam. I wish we could move him along.

Sad about Anb.

Definitely worth keeping Milk.

Hunter can go.

 

It’s AMW please. Beaver sorry Deever!!! 

[leave it to deever 17,506]

On 11/10/2024 at 14:35, 58er said:

It’s AMW please. Beaver sorry Deever!!! 

I was talking about Nibbler aka Anb.

[spirit of norm smith 16,044]

2024 squad = 45. 😭ANB (crows) BBB (⏰)Gus (med ret) , Hunter (⏰) JS29, KFW, Schache. Tomlinson likely to go.  
8 off the list. Down to 37
??? Marty Hore??? Staying or delisted???Likely to stay with Tomlinson going. 
 

Add in Campbell and Sharp*, plus potentially another DFA (Parfitt?). Add in 4 in the draft (and leave room for Mentha as a cat B rookie).  

[Turner 1,504]

On 14/10/2024 at 10:14, spirit of norm smith said:

2024 squad = 45. 😭ANB (crows) BBB (⏰)Gus (med ret) , Hunter (⏰) JS29, KFW, Schache. Tomlinson likely to go.  
8 off the list. Down to 37
??? Marty Hore??? Staying or delisted???Likely to stay with Tomlinson going. 
 

Add in Campbell and Sharp*, plus potentially another DFA (Parfitt?). Add in 4 in the draft (and leave room for Mentha as a cat B rookie).  

this is the current lay of the list (u can see where i adjsuted from numerical order to adding players as they get added. 

believe mcvee and AMW* need to be upgraded at the 3yr mark

*AMW can be delisted? or moved to the A list as he's under the 10 game threshold.

so two of the grey tiles would be filled therefore blocking out a 6th and 7th 'A' rookie#

#jsmith off the list would also make way for mcvee, tomlinson for amw and then we'd be in the position of having the two ND picks and 2 'A' spots which could be filled during the draft, or by yzes boy (unlikely) or by SSP or left for MSD

 

[spirit of norm smith 16,044]

Assume Tomlinson is departs.  
Asdume js29 departs. 
Assume Hore gets another year as a rookie. 
Assume McVee and AMW promoted to main list. 
37 listed. Add Campbell, Sharp, 5&9.  That’s only 41.  
Plenty of room for three further additions of DFA or draft or SSP additions (plus add Ricky Mentha as Cat B rookie). 

[spirit of norm smith 16,044]

Departures off the 2024 squad - traded: 😭ANB (crows) BBB (⏰)Gus (med ret) , Hunter (⏰) delisted: JS29, KFW, Schache & Tomlinson 

??? Marty Hore??? Staying or delisted???

[old55 23,292]

2 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

 

Departures off the 2024 squad - traded: 😭ANB (crows) BBB (⏰)Gus (med ret) , Hunter (⏰) delisted: JS29, KFW, Schache & Tomlinson 

??? Marty Hore??? Staying or delisted???

You should list KFW completely separately because he's a B Rookie (and can only be replaced by such) while all the others are primary list players.

By all means also list Hore separately as an A Rookie too.

[Redleg 40,740]

Bombers delisted Weid.