VOTES: SF vs Carlton

[red and blue forever 1,001]

6. Spargo

5. Lever

4. May

3. Gawn

2. Smith

1. Petracca

Edited September 15, 2023 by red and blue forever

[Nicko 1,378]

Ok this is self indulgent…

I’m giving myself 1 vote for travelling down from Brisbane for the game 

it’s nearly 2am and that’s all I’ve got left 😢

[58er 6,395]

2 hours ago, rolling fog said:

The no.22 (whoever that was) was a complete and utter spud. 

It's 23 by the way!

[58er 6,395]

1 hour ago, Nicko said:

Ok this is self indulgent…

I’m giving myself 1 vote for travelling down from Brisbane for the game 

it’s nearly 2am and that’s all I’ve got left 😢

Here here Nicko same here.

[Turner 1,507]

Lever

Sparrow

Hunter

JSmith

Oliver

Spargo

[Sydney Pennski 294]

6. Steven May 

5. Clayton Oliver 

4. Jack Viney 

3. Joel Smith 

2. Christian Petracca 

1. Tom Sparrow

[Roger Mellie 3,984]

4 hours ago, 58er said:

It's 23 by the way!

He's referring to umpire No. 22

[Fritta and Turner 4,345]

6. SMay

5. Smith

4. Spargo

3. Sparrow

2. Slever

1. STrac

[Dannyz 2,697]

9 hours ago, Maluski said:

6 May

5 Spargo

4 J Smith - Why does this guy get NO love on demonland? competed all night, 4 goals basically, given Kozzie stole one off him with his undisciplined selfish reversal free kick

3 McVee

2 Lever

1 Sparrow

 

You'll be able to find support for Smith from @binman and i back as 2019. 

6. May

5. Hunter

4. Smith

3. Sparrow 

2. Gawn 

1. Sparrow

[spirit of norm smith 16,292]

10 hours ago, GM11 said:

6 Spargo

5 Spargo

4 Spargo

3 Spargo

2 Spargo

1 Spargo

Ummm. That’s bizarre 

[IRW 1,387]

6 minutes ago, Dannyz said:

You'll be able to find support for Smith from @binman and i back as 2019. 

6. May

5. Hunter

4. Smith

3. Sparrow 

2. Gawn 

1. Sparrow

Smith is the " old" Melksham in disguise 

Group think rules the roost.

 

[waynewussell 5,369]

6 May

5 Lever

4 Sparrow

3 Smith

2 Nibbler

1 Kossie

[Rob Mac...... 638]

6. May. (Fabulous)
5. Lever
4. Smith  (Our best forward in the game) 
3. Spargo. (Wow, well done!)
2. ANB
1. Gawn. (Not one of his best, but we get used to him being so dominant)

 

game plan: -2  

[Demonland 71,622]

Congratulations to Christian Petracca on winning the 2023 Demonland Player of the Year

261. Christian Petracca 
200. Jack Viney 
150. Clayton Oliver 
112. Max Gawn 
106. Steven May
99. Angus Brayshaw
88. Steven May  
72. Jake Lever
68. Trent Rivers 
59. Lachie Hunter 
58. Kysaiah Pickett  
46. Christian Salem 
40. Brodie Grundy 
34. Jake Bowey Bayley Fritsch
31. Alex Neal-Bullen Tom Sparrow 
27. Ed Langdon 
24. Judd McVee 
19. Jake Melksham
18. Kade Chandler 
16. Harry Petty 
13. Jacob van Rooyen 
12. Charlie Spargo
9. Ben Brown  
5. Tom McDonald
4. Michael Hibberd 
3. James Jordon Joel Smith Adam Tomlinson

[Deeoldfart 8,005]

6.  May  

5.  Lever

4.  Smith

3.  Spargo

2.  Hunter

1.  Petracca

Well done to Tracc for taking out the DPOTY Award for 2023, and many thanks to Andy for all his hard work running the comp. 

Edited September 16, 2023 by Deeoldfart

[Spargonicus 539]

2 hours ago, Demonland said:

Congratulations to Christian Petracca on winning the 2023 Demonland Player of the Year

261. Christian Petracca /
200. Jack Viney +
150. Clayton Oliver -
112. Max Gawn /
106. Steven May +
99. Angus Brayshaw +
88. Steven May  
72. Jake Lever /
68. Trent Rivers +
59. Lachie Hunter /
58. Kysaiah Pickett /
46. Christian Salem -
40. Brodie Grundy /
34. Jake Bowey / Bayley Fritsch -
31. Alex Neal-Bullen + Tom Sparrow /
27. Ed Langdon -
24. Judd McVee +
19. Jake Melksham +
18. Kade Chandler /
16. Harry Petty +
13. Jacob van Rooyen /
12. Charlie Spargo -
9. Ben Brown  -
5. Tom McDonald -
4. Michael Hibberd -
3. James Jordon - Joel Smith + Adam Tomlinson /

I was thinking back to our premiership year, and how so many of our players had standout seasons.

A lot needs to go right to win a flag of course, and one of them is overall improvement in skill and output from the group and individual players. Thinking of 2021: Salem, Langdon, Spargo, Bowey etc.

as good as we were for the majority of the year, maybe we also just needed a few more individuals to have breakout years again.

As an exercise, I went though and rated all players for their 2023 season for impact above - using:

+ (greater impact)
- (less impact)

/ (similar impact to previous year)

This includes injury affected of course.

Not sure if you generally agree…