As I see it, Sparrow comes in for Woewodin.

The only other possible change that I can envisage is which of Smith, Tomlinson or Hibberd is in the starting 22 with one picked as the sub and the other missing out altogether. There are arguments for and against every option. Best guess: Tomlinson plays, Smith as sub, Hibberd unlucky and misses.

12 hours ago, picket fence said:

As iterated Spargo was shizzen last week and does NOT deserve a recall!

Maybe so, but I think Harmes is worse option and should not be in the 22. 

1 minute ago, MrFreeze said:

Maybe so, but I think Harmes is worse option and should not be in the 22. 

We dont need either

On 8/1/2023 at 5:50 PM, binman said:

Personally, i'm in the managing players camp.

As Demon Dynasty notes, any best 22 player managed won't be doing any resting. Like Smith doing laps after the Tigers game, they will still have to the ks they would have otherwise done in the match.

But the advantage is they don't have to be on and off a plane, or stay overnight in a hotel. And the risk of injury is much, much lower (ie no risk of impact injury).

And perhaps even more importantly they don't have to worry about post match recovery (eg from bumps, bruises and soreness) interfering with their prep and program heading into the challenging - and likely super critical (re chances of top 20 - Blues game. 

They also get a chance to freshen up mentally - which might benefit some players. 

Get the load without the risk.

There is another important element too i reckon - its give the club the opportunity to reward players at Casey for good form and/or give some young player some exposure at AFL level.

And given any player coming in will have a specific role in the system, they get chance to practice that role at AFL level, (which might useful in the even we cop some some injuries ahead of finals) and that mitigates some of the downside of new players coming in

And potentially a couple of fresh, motivated players who want to impress might actually help us put the Roos to the sword. 

Agreed. 
 

Any argument that resting players might mess with form is somewhat negated by the existence of an interchange bench. In any given match a team has to perform with several combinations of players on the ground. 
 

Resting players such as Gawn or Viney (or whoever could physically benefit from it) provides the team with the opportunity to sharpen their form when those players are ordinarily on the bench in a “normal” game. 

1 hour ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

As I see it, Sparrow comes in for Woewodin.

The only other possible change that I can envisage is which of Smith, Tomlinson or Hibberd is in the starting 22 with one picked as the sub and the other missing out altogether. There are arguments for and against every option. Best guess: Tomlinson plays, Smith as sub, Hibberd unlucky and misses.

I think that's right.  Adding Sparrow for Woewodin, and retaining JJ and Harmes, gives us a deeper midfield rotation and enables us to give Viney less load.  I like this if it happens.

As you say, the other is a choice among three for the 3rd tall back Tomlinson/Smith/Hibberd.

I: Petty, Sparrow, Harmes, Tomlinson/Smith/Hibberd

1 hour ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

Just because Smith has played well being used as the sub doesn’t mean he shouldn’t get an opportunity to play a whole game. If any player makes our team as little as 1% better they should be playing. Was Hibberd’s last game against the Cats? He didn’t play well that night, plus earlier in the year when we just went with May and Lever as the two talls they weren’t at their best, our system and players work better with two kpd plus Lever. For mine Hibberd to miss and we need to make a call on CHB, either persist with Thommo or give the last 4 games to Smith.

Tommo gets another shot.

7 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

Tommo gets another shot.

I’m happy with that, I just wouldn’t be bringing in Hibberd for a tall or McVee.

10 minutes ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

I’m happy with that, I just wouldn’t be bringing in Hibberd for a tall or McVee.

Who will North have as talls on sunday

3 minutes ago, Kent said:

Who will North have as talls on sunday

Goldstein, Xerri, Larkey 

1 minute ago, MrFreeze said:

Goldstein, Xerri, Larkey 

 I mean in the forward line

assuming resting ruck is one  Larkey 197cm is the only Tall

the rest named are Tucker Phillips Stephenson Taylor Curtis are all 187 cm or thereabouts

Do we need 3 talls ?

14 minutes ago, Kent said:

 I mean in the forward line

assuming resting ruck is one  Larkey 197cm is the only Tall

the rest named are Tucker Phillips Stephenson Taylor Curtis are all 187 cm or thereabouts

Do we need 3 talls ?

probably not

which is why i expect hibberd to come in for tomlinson

23 minutes ago, Kent said:

Who will North have as talls on sunday

Probably only Larkey and have a ruck rotate through. Regardless, we should keep our structures if we’re not looking to rest players. One of the keys of our teams is our players versatility.

1 hour ago, MrFreeze said:

Maybe so, but I think Harmes is worse option and should not be in the 22. 

You are speaking about 2021 Premiership players

45 minutes ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

I’m happy with that, I just wouldn’t be bringing in Hibberd for a tall or McVee.

Tommos been gettng some good opponents.

Anyone who’ll be in Hobart tomorrow and is interested… there’s a Captain’s Run scheduled at Blundstone. The North cheer squad has told us it’s at either 3pm or 3:30pm, depending on who you ask. 

49 minutes ago, radar said:

You are speaking about 2021 Premiership players

Spargo is also a 2021 premiership player. 

Do we have any clearer news about Oliver's return as of yet?

 

6 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

Do we have any clearer news about Oliver's return as of yet?

 

Next week v Blues

31 minutes ago, SFebes said:

Next week v Blues

Thanks very much SFebes. Looking forward to it.

1 hour ago, MrFreeze said:

Spargo is also a 2021 premiership player. 

I'll bet he'll be a 2023 premiership player as well.

2 hours ago, leave it to deever said:

Do we have any clearer news about Oliver's return as of yet?

 

As @SFebes has said, Clarrie’s due back vs the Blues. Tonight I’ll be at Casa De Frittata and should Fritta Jnr pop by I’ll ask him to confirm. Can’t guarantee that though, if he comes late in the evening there’s every chance I’ll be hammered and won’t remember a thing he’s said. 😜

Let's all try and enjoy a good weekend of footy and hopefully a good win. 

Tommo once again dropped...

Will we look back on this team selection and say it cost us our finals series a la 2022.

Time may tell