PREGAME: Rd 20 vs Richmond

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

15 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said:

The Petty experiment forward is only deemed an experiment still, as he has been injured. If that didn't occur, we'd be all pretty clear that its JVR and Petty as the preferred set up. This is the preferred set up, going forward.

Not long-term it isn’t.

I’d much prefer Grundy forward than Petty.

[Radar Detector 1,339]

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Can't believe Harmes is getting games.

I would have brought Hibberd in and assign Rivers to play a midfield role in place of Sparrow.

I suspect they are trying to develop consistency across the board. So one straight swap is less disruptive than shuffling two players into new positions. Especially with Riv playing his current role so well.

[Jaded No More 60,124]

8 minutes ago, picket fence said:

PETTY IS NOT AND NEVER WILL BE A FORWARD FFS

Why not? 

[Roost it far 6,447]

11 minutes ago, picket fence said:

PETTY IS NOT AND NEVER WILL BE A FORWARD FFS

Well not is Grundy

[Radar Detector 1,339]

17 minutes ago, OhMyDees said:

We talk a lot about needing players with elite kicks and Harmes ain’t one of them. He consistently butchers the ball and puts players under pressure.

Really would have preferred Dunstan.

Do people forget Dunstan’s disposal? He’s an A grade butcher. Just because he’s got the ball on a string in the VFL doesn’t mean he’ll translate to AFL. Harmes has been out of form but has much more to offer the team if he plays well.

[picket fence 15,785]

7 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

Why not? 

CHRIST he just doesn't move to the right positions OR is clever enough OR is an accurate enough kick! BBB Banged up  is better than a Banged up Petty as a forward ANYDAY

[Dee Zephyr 18,246]

All the best to Petty and Harmesy, i hope they do well.

[Diamond_Jim 12,104]

Like most I worry about the ever changing forward structure but understand that this is what 2023 has dealt us.

If you had told me at the start of the season that we would be sweating on the performance of Chandler and Melksham my eyes would have rolled.

Oliver out and now Sparrow adds to the concern.

Looking forward to a regulation 30 point win but...................

[At the break of Gawn 3,856]

Weather forecast has become worse. Looks like it will be a wet or slippery game once the ball is bounced. 

Petty is definitely a better option than Browb in wet conditions.

[binman 39,591]

35 minutes ago, Stiff Arm said:

Harmes? Seriously?

Nearly as big a momentum killer as Neal-Bullen

Gives away stupid frees, makes bad choices, average disposal, poor under pressure

Look forward to the day we can upgrade from JH and ANB

You're really gonna enjoy the hawks game.

Nibbler's 150th. 

And remarkably, for a player we apparently need an upgrade on, his 70th of the last 72 games the dees have played, inclusive of 5 finals and a premiership medallion.

Quick quiz. Do you think any other dees player can match that record?

Hell, is there another player in the AFL who can match that record?

Impressive for a momentum killer.

Goody must be trolling you.

Methinks you might have to wait a while for your upgrade.

[djr 1,093]

9 minutes ago, picket fence said:

CHRIST he just doesn't move to the right positions OR is clever enough OR is an accurate enough kick! BBB Banged up  is better than a Banged up Petty as a forward ANYDAY

PF does it make you feel more important by putting words in capitals? You have made your point that you don’t like Petty. You don’t have to labour it. 

[John Demonic 4,977]

Petty and Tomlinson together. Did we do this earlier in the year or is this a first time ever?

[Neil Crompton 4,972]

Petty to CHB, Tommo to FB and May to CHF/FF

[Binmans PA 26,728]

2 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Can't believe Harmes is getting games.

I would have brought Hibberd in and assign Rivers to play a midfield role in place of Sparrow.

And then you lose all your defensive drive and your chief interceptor.

Rivers need to stay half back, with very occasional CBAs IMO.

[Jaded No More 60,124]

28 minutes ago, picket fence said:

CHRIST he just doesn't move to the right positions OR is clever enough OR is an accurate enough kick! BBB Banged up  is better than a Banged up Petty as a forward ANYDAY

You’re going to have a heart attack. Calm down, it’s going to be ok. I promise. 

[Roost it far 6,447]

Didn’t Petty play his footy forward pre Melbourne 

[picket fence 15,785]

6 minutes ago, djr said:

PF does it make you feel more important by putting words in capitals? You have made your point that you don’t like Petty. You don’t have to labour it. 

Incorrect... I LIKE PETTY but a forward he is not and NEVER will be.

Satisfied ??

[Jaded No More 60,124]

You know your club is in a good spot that your biggest gripe is whether a premiership CHB can become a premiership CHF 

 

[djr 1,093]

5 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Incorrect... I LIKE PETTY but a forward he is not and NEVER will be.

Satisfied ??

Not really. Don’t say you like a player in one post and then say he is overrated in another. 

[dazzledavey36 49,794]

21 minutes ago, A F said:

And then you lose all your defensive drive and your chief interceptor.

Rivers need to stay half back, with very occasional CBAs IMO.

You were calling for Rivers ro be dropped only 3 weeks ago...

[Ouch! 2,138]

34 minutes ago, binman said:

You're really gonna enjoy the hawks game.

Nibbler's 150th. 

And remarkably, for a player we apparently need an upgrade on, his 70th of the last 72 games the dees have played, inclusive of 5 finals and a premiership medallion.

Quick quiz. Do you think any other dees player can match that record?

Hell, is there another player in the AFL who can match that record?

Impressive for a momentum killer.

Goody must be trolling you.

Methinks you might have to wait a while for your upgrade.

Might recall I was a bit hard on nibbler last season, but my criticism was more that his momentum killing was that he gut runs everywhere, created chances, gets on the end of it, but was butchering the ball when kicking for goal. I think he's been a lot better this season, Petracca is the same, they are doing so much running to create the play that when they get a chance to be the final link in the chain they are spent and can't convert.

[ANG13 1,655]

8 hours ago, Demon17 said:

I sit on the Lachie Hunter wing - as opposed to the southern stand Ed Langdon wing, so watch him close up.  Some sublime disposals last week,  always thinking steps ahead of oppo. Not afraid of approaching tacklers.  Great pick up. 

Hunters kicking efficiency in the last eight weeks is 47.4%. 

[Redleg 38,576]

58 minutes ago, picket fence said:

CHRIST he just doesn't move to the right positions OR is clever enough OR is an accurate enough kick! BBB Banged up  is better than a Banged up Petty as a forward ANYDAY

He is an accurate kick for goal.

Reckon he will give us more this week, than BBB did last week. 

[picket fence 15,785]

23 minutes ago, djr said:

Not really. Don’t say you like a player in one post and then say he is overrated in another. 

He is OVERATED as a Forward, and is starting to get Collision Injuries ! AND how he gets a starting 22 game over a rapidly imposing and improving JOEL SMITH is fantasyland stuff!

Edited July 28, 2023 by picket fence

[Redleg 38,576]

1 minute ago, ANG13 said:

Hunters kicking efficiency in the last eight weeks is 47.4%. 

Correct, he sprays it with dinky little kicks round the corner.