The Demons head into the Bye on 9 wins and 4 losses. Please post your questions and comments on the Demons season to date. We'll also be previewing the Demons upcoming match against the Cats so please post any questions or comments you have for that match.

The Demonland Podcast will air LIVE on Monday, 19th May @ 8:30pm. Join Binman, George & I as we analyse the Demons Season so far.

You questions and comments are a huge part of our podcast so please post anything you want to ask or say below and we'll give you a shout out on the show.

If you would like to leave us a voicemail please call 03 9016 3666 and don't worry no body answers so you don't have to talk to a human.

Listen & Chat LIVE: https://demonland.com/podcast

Call: 03 9016 3666

Skype: Demonland31

Thanks boys for all of your efforts on the Podcast so far this season. This is my favourite Demon's podcast and is a must listen each and every week. The longer the better. It is the highlight of my week. Yes I do have a life but I travel a lot for work and having you guys along for the ride makes the kms fly by.

I would love to get the panels thoughts on which player has been the surprise packet of the year and conversely which player has not lived up to expectation (doesn't have to be negative - can be as a result of injury etc)?

The podcast has gone to another level this year. My sincere thanks to all involved. Each of you bring something different to the table and it is very clear that a lot of time and effort goes into the format and analysis.

If you have time I would love to get your thoughts and opinions on our run home? What are the danger games and are you concerned that our potential lead in to the finals could be deemed as "soft" with games against Adelaide (if they still can't win out of SA), Richmond (if finals are out of their reach), North in Tassie (is our Tassie hoodoo over), Carlton (hopefully blind freddy will see they are tanking by then), Hawthorn (just lay down for us this time you've got nothing to prove) & the Swans (hopefully they are not playing for their coach's swansong)?

Keep up the great work. LOVE LOVE LOVE the podcast.

I'll echo these statements and say the podcast has gone to a new level this year. It's currently the only one I listen to.

I don't have anything to suggest out of the ordinary that you won't be doing already eg grading our performance thus far or grading forward, mid and back groups etc.

Maybe which player is the midyear B & F, which player is the mid year 'coaches award' or best improver so far and who  has been most underwhelming. 

hey DEMONLAND FAMILY i am relatively NEW to the podcast having been recommended to listen a few weeks back by a lovely lady near the DEMON ARMY cheersquad. this is my first message on this website and I want to relay my thanks and gratitude to you 3 for your considered analysis and the use of stats to paint the bigger picture that can sometimes be hazy in all the emotions of GAME DAY. the wins can be euphoric and the losses can be soul crushing but I have found that listening to your dissections of the matches in the past few weeks have given me a greater appreciation of the games and have made me realise that it's a long season and we're playing the long game. so thank you for your efforts to bring comfort after a loss and of course to celebrate all the wins along the way.

Edited June 15, 20232 yr by Skrull

oh I forgot to ask my question:

I have heard you speak about us adjusting our gameplan slightly this year but as I'm relatively new here and not very analytical when it comes to how I watch games I would like a little bit of an explainer about what you've noticed about our tweaks to the gameplan. correct me if I am wrong and apologies for any ignorance but I have seen a shift from us playing predictable down the line footy, which did work for us in 21, to us taking the game on more by taking risks in using the corridor. I know it's not as simple as that and there is probably a lot more that my untrained eye is missing so can please enlighten me so that the next time I'm at the footy or probably more accurately at the pub I can pretend that I know what I am waffling on about.

thank you for you time. keep up the stellar job guys.

-- keysborough jim

Edited June 15, 20232 yr by Skrull

16 minutes ago, Skrull said:

hey DEMONLAND FAMILY i am relatively NEW to the podcast having been recommended to listen a few weeks back by a lovely lady near the DEMON ARMY cheersquad. this is my first message on this website and I want to relay my thanks and gratitude to you 3 for your considered analysis and the use of stats to paint the bigger picture that can sometimes be hazy in all the emotions of GAME DAY. the wins can be euphoric and the losses can be soul crushing but I have found that listening to your dissections of the matches in the past few weeks have given me a greater appreciation of the games and have made me realise that it's a long season and we're playing the long game. so thank you for your efforts to bring comfort after a loss and of course to celebrate all the wins along the way.

Thank you and welcome to Demonland!!

Wondering who the panel thinks will be our biggest threats for the Flag this year? It's looking likely that the Pies, Port and Brisbane will be Top 4 given the Pies current record and Port and Brissy's home ground advantages.

Are any of the teams currently (at time of writing) in the bottom part of the 8 a threat for our Flag (yes OUR FLAG) currently Saints, Bombers, Adelaide and Dogs?

What about the Teams currently sitting outside the 8? Currently Cats, Dockers, Suns and perhaps the Tigers. Any concerns for those sides?

Excellent Podcasts as always fellas. Keep punching them out. Go Demons.

Edited June 15, 20232 yr by Singa

As promised, Andy, here is my question from the Collingwood Podcast thread, but relevant to the Geelong game. 

Do we think we'll allow +1 at contest against Geelong? In the Collingwood game, we evened this up in the final quarter.

@Lucifers Hero has pointed out before the +1 that we allowed last time against Geelong. 

Do we allow it for 3 quarters or even most of the match, and tweak it if necessary?

My question 

Are we loading this year. ?

were we loading last year ?

doesn’t every side do a similar loading pattern.   If they do doesn’t that make it all equall ?

does it work ?

three hours post-filth clash was glorrrious

bring on the three-part, nine-hour extravaganza of the midseason period

i expect at least an hour each dedicated to 'best 23' presuming all fully fit

Being 3rd on the ladder is a great start and the notion that we are building to playing our best football at the backend of the year is excellent.. what has to 'click' in order for us to play our best? And is our best the best?

something my mother (hello giddle! long time lurker) asked me - what is gus brayshaw's best position, and what position would you most like to see him deployed in, and why?

In the mid season review I would be interested in the perspective of the team on the broader competition.

Do you think the current top 4 are the teams in contention and will remain unchanged?  How important is a top 2 finish considering Port and Brisbane would be tough road trips in finals?  
 

Given it is related to our drafting position, what do the team think the likely finish will be for an improving Fremantle side?

 

With Clarry and Petty likely to return this week the big question is who will come in and who will be omitted?

With an eye on match ups for the game at the Cattery who will we see match up on Hawkins, Cameron & Rohan?

Who will take Stengle? Who will man Close. 

The Cats have a number of tall defenders but could that work in our favour with our smaller forward line? 

I'll second the Big Love for the podcast. All three of you offer a great insight into both our wins and losses. It's essential listening for me each week and a break from the so called experts in the media. Thanks for your hard work and dedication in preparing and producing the podcast each week.

We've had 3 debutants pull on the Red and Blue Guernsey this season and all three have had an impact. Love to get the panel's thoughts on Brodie Grundy, Lachie Hunter and the Juddster.

Are we likely to see another debutant before season's end and if so who will it be?

Maybe one for the end:

If Binman were stuck on a desert island with only a Record turntable/CD Player with power available and the choice of only 1 album to have with him, which album would that be? 🙂

Edited June 18, 20231 yr by layzie

Looking forward to the Pod.

Keen to hear the panels thoughts on which players might get a game in the run home that we haven't seen yet in 2023 (debuts or otherwise). 

If time permits, I'd also like to know what everyone considers to be their best 22 for finals. Are we resting BBBB in the VFL as per 2021? Does someone like Harmes get a gig if he's in form? Can all of Rivers, McVee, Bowey, Salem and Brayshaw play in the one side when its crunch time? 

We have attended all home games to date and although we have had some convincing wins others have been less so. The Pies win was exhilarating but we seem to be holding back at times, where are we going to find that extra improvement that will enable us to win the prize.?

Hi Andy

You asked  me to repost this for the mid season review so here we are with a couple of modifications, although it was answered to a certain extent last week.

Your thoughts on this as a potential forward line going into the future, not just next week but  beyond BBB and TMac.

JvR because he is a developing champion

Petty because Goodie has made it clear that’s where he wants him, pre knee Tomo may be back and gives us two solid talls up front

Fritsch because he is a goal machine

Kossie because he’s Kossie

Now it gets harder:

I love Chandler and think he is an intelligent player. I love Spargo’s delivery inside but given Smith can play fast and small as well as tall, one of them out for him. This also fits with our small forward roles as pressure first, goals second.

So I see it as possibly JVR, Petty, Fritsch, Smith, Kossie, Chandler. Spargo as first drop and Schache as tall backup. 

Alternatively Smith could be permanent sub given his flexibility.

Thoughts?

2 hours ago, layzie said:

Maybe one for the end:

If Binman were stuck on a desert island with only a Record turntable/CD Player with power available and the choice of only 1 album to have with him, which album would that be? 🙂

This could end up being a 4 hour show.

1 minute ago, DeeMee said:

Hi Andy

You asked  me to repost this for the mid season review so here we are with a couple of modifications, although it was answered to a certain extent last week.

 

Your thoughts on this as a potential forward line going into the future, not just next week but  beyond BBB and TMac.

JvR because he is a developing champion

Petty because Goodie has made it clear that’s where he wants him, pre knee Tomo may be back and gives us two solid talls up front

Fritsch because he is a goal machine

Kossie because he’s Kossie

Now it gets harder:

I love Chandler and think he is an intelligent player. I love Spargo’s delivery inside but given Smith can play fast and small as well as tall, one of them out for him. This also fits with our small forward roles as pressure first, goals second.

So I see it as possibly JVR, Petty, Fritsch, Smith, Kossie, Chandler. Spargo as first drop and Schache as tall backup. 

Alternatively Smith could be permanent sub given his flexibility.

Thoughts?

Probably still relevant for a Mid Season Review.

Thanks guys - the 3-hour loading podcast last week was great. I'm sure you guys will be delivering explosive podcasts from Round 20 onwards 😁 

We saw teams adopt specific strategies as a way to counter Melbourne's game plan. This included:

1. Stronger use of the corridor,
2. Short and quick 15-20 metre kicks to allow transition (by hand or foot) beyond Melbourne's defensive zone, and
3. When we kicked long to a contest, spoiling the ball long / well clear of the contest to circumvent our crumbers and contested ball winners. 

Geelong used all three to great success in our Round 17 game last year. Over the first 13 rounds we've seen what the Dees response to these strategies from 2022 has been, with particular success in our wins against the Swans in Round 3 and the Pies in Round 13. We seem to have developed a counterstrategy to how teams beat us in 2022. Go fast and we can beat you, go slow and we will definitely beat you.

Given this, have you seen anything in our losses this year that suggests we're susceptible to a new strategy or gameday tactic? Was there anything about how Essendon and Port moved the ball against us that causes you concern?

Sorry for the long question, and thanks for the continued high quality content you gents produce! 😊

 

 

Edited June 19, 20231 yr by Stu