Seriously how can the Dockers get more for Neale that we do for Hogan FFS

Official: Neale + 30 for 6, 19 and 55

Just now, The Chazz said:

I realise that, but he's got an extensive history of breaking down.

Jesse could go on for the rest of his career injury free, and good luck to him (personally) if he does.  But I have my doubts.

Wouldn't say it's extensive history... but he plays a style of game that is high intensity and high impact, but he will play a different game at the dockers than with us I think. Freo will not want him to roam as far from goal, so maybe that changes!

1 minute ago, McQueen said:

6 or 11 is relevant given the possibility of the earlier pick being traded into more picks or players than 11 could. Whether that happens is another thing. 

I think discussion is between 11 or 23. 6 is a given.

Neale and pick 30 to brissy for 6 19 and 55

 

so we ask 6 and 19 + ?

Edited October 17, 20187 yr by red and blue forever

We are a few minutes away from 10k posts in this thread.

GREAT EFFORT EVERYONE

1 minute ago, Demonland said:

 

well there goes, 6, 23 & 30.. 

The first hurdle has finally fell

1 minute ago, Demonland said:

 

So how many of the media experts actually got the specifics of that trade correct?

Cmonnnn 6+ next years first.

Just now, FireInTheBelly said:

So how many of the media experts actually got the specifics of that trade correct?

To be fair, they did get the bones right.... They never get the all the facts, they only get tid bits

1 minute ago, Ouch! said:

Freo will not want him to roam as far from goal, so maybe tha

So his goal returns will fall - as he has to go upfield to get the ball.

1 minute ago, Ouch! said:

Wouldn't say it's extensive history... but he plays a style of game that is high intensity and high impact, but he will play a different game at the dockers than with us I think. Freo will not want him to roam as far from goal, so maybe that changes!

If he wants to get a kick at Fremantle he'll have to play at full back.

Just now, Deemania since 56 said:

So his goal returns will fall - as he has to go upfield to get the ball.

has to get within 40 to have a shot though!

Just now, Unleash Hell said:

To be fair, they did get the bones right.... They never get the all the facts, they only get tid bits

Yep, they get bits and pieces only, similar to the Hogan trade. We still are no closer to knowing the full deal.

If it's Hogan for 6 and 19 then that's two 1st round picks.  That's what we asked for.  Hard to mount an argument that we have taken significant unders.

Just now, FireInTheBelly said:

Yep, they get bits and pieces only, similar to the Hogan trade. We still are no closer to knowing the full deal.

It's these bits and pieces that will determine if the Hogan deal is fair or not however!

4 minutes ago, TheoX said:

Seriously how can the Dockers get more for Neale that we do for Hogan FFS

Depends how their picks work out.  What if they want in two years time, or turn into average players?  What is May and KK are part of a premiership side in the next few seasons?

I'll hold off before saying Freo got 'more' for Neale than we did for Hogan.  Too subjective.  

1 minute ago, S_T said:

If it's Hogan for 6 and 19 then that's two 1st round picks.  That's what we asked for.  Hard to mount an argument that we have taken significant unders.

They no longer have 19. It has to be 6 and 23 now.

It's official. Let the domino falling begin.

freo now saying they'll take jesse for nothing if we pay 50% of his salary for 2 years

1 minute ago, Lord Travis said:

They no longer have 19. It has to be 6 and 23 now.

How didnt they just get it? Lobb hasnt been done yet. 

7 minutes ago, demon191919 said:

Official: Neale + 30 for 6, 19 and 55

Neale + 30 for 6 + 19 + 55

values Neale at 6 + 35

According to the AFL trade tracker, Freo got 6 and 19.

Nearly there.