43 minutes ago, Colin B. Flaubert said:

Melksham said prior to the game that the North boys sledged a lot when they played Melbourne (and it wasn't like we didn't give them insufficient ammunition).

I think this time at least we hit hard but we didn't go overboard. There were more Nev Jetta on Brown style hits and less Bernie Vince on Ben Cunnington hits (who responded beautifully).

 

It was a definite tactic of theirs to throw us to the ground and impose themselves physically wherever possible. This time we answered pretty well I thought.

18 hours ago, jako13 said:

why the [censored] does a professional footballer, in todays age, with all the coaches and strength and conditioning guys at there disposal need to hire a [censored] personal trainer to do things outside of the scope that their own conditioning staff have pencilled in for them. 

To me it screams either

a. incompetence of our staff to put blokes on the right pathway with the right fitness plans

or

b. complete lack of faith of our staff to deliver whats in a.

or

c. a massive lack of personal drive to accomplish whats been set.

 

either way i wouldn't be promoting this as a football club to the outside world

Some people just can’t see positives in anything.

To me Salem wanted to achieve his very best .... maybe at a time when the club was required NOT to be involved with player training programs, or just to come back to official club activities ahead of the game.  

Nothing wrong with wanting to achieve an edge (not the EssUndone way) through extra personal effort. 

All kudos to him. 

On 09/04/2018 at 2:44 PM, poita said:

Good on Christian for turning things around, but it is a little disappointing that he had to be told these things at year end. It should have been apparent to him throughout the year that he wasn't fit enough and, if not, the coaches should have been all over him about it.

Couldn't agree more. Every time I read an article like this about the penny only dropping now, or the stories from the end of last year about players not understanding what 24/7 professionalism means, I ask myself - what the heck was Roos getting paid $1.5m a year for?

Yeah, he rebuilt the list but it is staggering the players had to miss the finals by 2 goals to understand professionalism. I thought the mental side of the game was Roos' bread and butter and I'm staggered the players still didn't understand professionalism until the pre-season just gone. 

14 minutes ago, Watts Jurrah Dunn? said:

Couldn't agree more. Every time I read an article like this about the penny only dropping now, or the stories from the end of last year about players not understanding what 24/7 professionalism means, I ask myself - what the heck was Roos getting paid $1.5m a year for?

Yeah, he rebuilt the list but it is staggering the players had to miss the finals by 2 goals to understand professionalism. I thought the mental side of the game was Roos' bread and butter and I'm staggered the players still didn't understand professionalism until the pre-season just gone. 

Salem's first couple of years have been blighted by injury or illness,so his base wasn't where it was supposed to be, not his fault

He wanted to play midfield this year and was told what he had to do to achieve this, he went away and did it, professionalism

Young, younger players who completed full pre season without a hiccup, for first time or in a while

Gawn

Hogan

Petracca

Salem

Wagner

Omac

All in form and playing well

On 09/04/2018 at 2:15 PM, jnrmac said:

Probably easier to train over summer when you aren't dropping bricks on your head.......

Salem, at times, appears scared, hesitant, nervous and/or worried about tackling and 'going in for the ball' when there is congestion or a few opponents very nearby. He often goes to ground, as well. When these factors do not impinge on him, he can be very good at the ball, passing by both hand and foot, and quick to make yards. He is small relative to most other players and this alone should identify his skills needing to be shepherded more often - almost automatically - for the positive effects that his terrific disposal can achieve. It would also assist him to stay upright on his feet. 

9 minutes ago, Deemania since 56 said:

Salem, at times, appears scared, hesitant, nervous and/or worried about tackling and 'going in for the ball' when there is congestion or a few opponents very nearby. He often goes to ground, as well. When these factors do not impinge on him, he can be very good at the ball, passing by both hand and foot, and quick to make yards. He is small relative to most other players and this alone should identify his skills needing to be shepherded more often - almost automatically - for the positive effects that his terrific disposal can achieve. It would also assist him to stay upright on his feet. 

he hasn't torn free from the apron strings or similar, just yet; at least looks that on appearance. Like he's running around on one of those elastic leashes parents sometimes use for kids, instead of dogs.

He appears like he wants to let himself go but doesn't dare break that mind restraint.  a conservative type trait.

Edited April 11, 20187 yr by DV8

59 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

Salem's first couple of years have been blighted by injury or illness,so his base wasn't where it was supposed to be, not his fault

 

So because he was injured he wasn't part of the club while Roos was there and didn't attend any of the meetings or get any insight from the coaches into what professionalism and standards are?

It was obvious the second Salem rocked up to the club that he had to go easy on his mum's cooking, strip a lot of puppy fat off and get serious.

It shouldn't have taken years to get that message.

15 minutes ago, Watts Jurrah Dunn? said:

So because he was injured he wasn't part of the club while Roos was there and didn't attend any of the meetings or get any insight from the coaches into what professionalism and standards are?

It was obvious the second Salem rocked up to the club that he had to go easy on his mum's cooking, strip a lot of puppy fat off and get serious.

It shouldn't have taken years to get that message.

its not the words wjd,,,, do as I say, its do as is being done around you. 

It Is the actions of your peers; that's is the culture the club stands buy.  And you cannot buy it, a great culture.

You have to grow your own, because its organic in nature.

We (Mfc) are starting to learn.

59 minutes ago, DV8 said:

he hasn't torn free from the apron strings or similar, just yet; at least looks that on appearance. Like he's running around on one of those elastic leashes parents sometimes use for kids, instead of dogs.

He appears like he wants to let himself go but doesn't dare break that mind restraint.  a conservative type trait.

 

1 hour ago, Deemania since 56 said:

Salem, at times, appears scared, hesitant, nervous and/or worried about tackling and 'going in for the ball' when there is congestion or a few opponents very nearby. He often goes to ground, as well. When these factors do not impinge on him, he can be very good at the ball, passing by both hand and foot, and quick to make yards. He is small relative to most other players and this alone should identify his skills needing to be shepherded more often - almost automatically - for the positive effects that his terrific disposal can achieve. It would also assist him to stay upright on his feet. 

Wow.

Some tangential shiite going on here....

3 hours ago, Watts Jurrah Dunn? said:

So because he was injured he wasn't part of the club while Roos was there and didn't attend any of the meetings or get any insight from the coaches into what professionalism and standards are?

It was obvious the second Salem rocked up to the club that he had to go easy on his mum's cooking, strip a lot of puppy fat off and get serious.

It shouldn't have taken years to get that message.

I suggest, instead of being a smartarse,  do a bit of research on thyroid issues and see the impact it can have in the body

2 hours ago, jnrmac said:

 

Wow.

Some tangential shiite going on here....

Double wow, maybe last week they thought the guy in Nr 3 was someone else

47 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

I suggest, instead of being a smartarse,  do a bit of research on thyroid issues and see the impact it can have in the body

Thyroid issues can have a very serious effect on the body. Last year I was concerned that young Salem may not make it. That he appears to have overcome this serious medical problem is excellent news. 

4 hours ago, jnrmac said:

 

Wow.

Some tangential shiite going on here....

It's like Deeeluded met Deeeluded. And had two baby Deeludeds.

Edited April 11, 20187 yr by binman

34 minutes ago, binman said:

It's like Deeeluded met Deeeluded. And had two baby Deeludeds.

??? wouldn't that then have to be tangenital.  Its just a bit too hard to imagine, bm'r.

Edited April 11, 20187 yr by DV8

11 hours ago, Cards13 said:

Is there CBA involved as well? Ie the players have a mandatory rest period, are clubs unable to have to much contact in offseason? 

Yeah that was my thought too

Some absolute garbage written in this thread. I don’t know what people are watching. 

 

Kid who has struggled to string blocks of footy together, for numerous reasons, hasn’t found consistency yet, isn’t that shocking?

 

Anyway, his hit on Majak after Majak nearly knocked Lewis’ wig off made me smile. Onwards and upwards for Salem  

 

 

14 minutes ago, Deestroy All said:

Some absolute garbage written in this thread. I don’t know what people are watching. 

 

Kid who has struggled to string blocks of footy together, for numerous reasons, hasn’t found consistency yet, isn’t that shocking?

 

Anyway, his hit on Majak after Majak nearly knocked Lewis’ wig off made me smile. Onwards and upwards for Salem  

 

 

Great to see a positive and optimistic comment on this board.

Too many glass half empty folk here (though many decayed decades may account for at least some of this)

was super impressed with salem on the weekend. loved him smashing majak and looking out for his teammate (something i just haven't seen in the last few years by any dee). it's something we need to focus on. being hard and making opposition accountable. 

I’m a fan. It’s his 50th game this week.

Congratulations Christian?❤️

He also shoved MacMillian over when he was limping: nasty, we need more of it!

On 11/04/2018 at 10:31 PM, Deestroy All said:

Anyway, his hit on Majak after Majak nearly knocked Lewis’ wig off made me smile. Onwards and upwards for Salem  

Just what I was thinking, while Eddie was creaming his pants over literally everything the Majak Daw did I was so pleased with how hard he tackled a guy twice his size and made him feel it. He's got a bit of mongrel in him, if channelled properly I think he'll be around around for a long time yet. 

At the end of the 2016 season Christian did not go overseas for a holiday, but did extra training to get fitter.He knows he has to fight for his place in the side. He is determined to be a Melbourne player.I spoke to a family member after one of his concussions and C. was not allowed to to watch tv or use a computer/ iPad for 2 weeks as part of his recovery.His father Alex was a Bombers supporter_ not now!He is 100% A Demons supporter and goes to the games as well as training.I hope he leads the team out on Sunday-50 Games played.