I'll stick my neck out and say that Joel Smith will be an out.

Oscar might be lucky because of Smith's injury and the fact that none of the others coming back from injury are likely to be ready.

Not sure who the next in line for Smith's spot might be but perhaps Jack Watts goes back into defence and Spencer or Pedo give Gawn a chop out in the ruck.

Wagner if right in for Smith. When hibbo is ready to go Wagner out. 

Frost for Oscar when fit.

Tyson in for Smith. Not a like for like exchange obviously but unless they plan on throwing Keilty to the wolves, we're fresh out of medium defenders.

No other change. Kent is the only player realistically under consideration I'd have thought, but I'm happy enough for Garlett, ANB and Hannan for the time being.

Oscar for anyone.

No Tyson until one of our mids have a poor game and Tyson has a belter in the VFL.

There is absolutely no need for him to come into our side right now. 

Edited March 25, 20178 yr by stevethemanjordan

Not everyone in the team (referring to win over saints) is going to have a good game so having said that we must keep on plating Oscar.

Oscar clearly had a nightmare of a game and we all saw it. However, he is better than that and having now watched the game live, but also later on TV, there were a lot of little things he did well, which I didn't notice at the game..

Frost is probably not ready, but to be honest we need 3 big guys down back anyway, so he will get another game this week and hopefully plays well.

Edited March 25, 20178 yr by Redleg

Oscar looked out of his depth but I don't think they'll drop him. He's a developing player with all of the potential of his brother. The more he plays, the better he'll become.

Similar thoughts on the Weid, doesn't look ready but needs game time.

I don't know about Melksham going forward. Would bring someone in for him but not sure who.

5 minutes ago, ENYAW said:

Not everyone in the team (referring to win over saints) is going to have a good game so having said that we must keep on plating Oscar.

I agree but at the same time they couldn't take out Oscar even if they wanted to. We have nobody left. I thought he steadied a little after a very ordinary start.

1 minute ago, Redleg said:

Oscar clearly had a nightmare of a game and we all saw it. However, he is better than that and having now watched the game live, but also later on TV, there were a lot of little things he did well, which I didn't notice at the game..

Frost is probably not ready, but to be honest we need 3 big guys down back anyway, so he will get another game this week and hopefully plays well.

I think after that inboard kick to Tracc in the second he got a bit of confidence and still made a couple of mistakes but looked better. He just needs to get rid of the confidence/hesitation errors that he had early, needs to play like he believes he should be there, right now he just looks too worried that he will make a mistake then does.

Omac wont be going anywhere. Carlton aren't tall forward so best performed at Casey should come in. 

Just now, ArtificialWisdom said:

I agree but at the same time they couldn't take out Oscar even if they wanted to. We have nobody left. I thought he steadied a little after a very ordinary start.

I think after that inboard kick to Tracc in the second he got a bit of confidence and still made a couple of mistakes but looked better. He just needs to get rid of the confidence/hesitation errors that he had early, needs to play like he believes he should be there, right now he just looks too worried that he will make a mistake then does.

That will come with another 20 games and some more muscle.

I thought of Pedo in for Smith, as can play multiple positions.

Not sure how far away Frost is as he would be the automatic replacement 

Cant think of who to drop for Kent and Tyson,good problem to have.

Edited March 25, 20178 yr by DeeZee

Flying down Saturday, can't wait.

2 & 0 to start the season.

Oscar and Tom are very different players.

My concern with Oscar is his lack of leg speed and agility which are strengths of his brother.

This limits him his ability to match up on most modern forwards.

But we must persist, we have invested heavily and we are low on options.

Edited March 25, 20178 yr by Guest

3 minutes ago, DeeZee said:

I thought no Pedo in for Smith, as can play multiple positions.

Not sure how far away Frost is as he would be the automatic replacement 

Cant think of who to drop for Kent and Tyson,good problem to have.

I still think if fit Kent should replace ANB. But it would be really harsh to drop him after the way he played yesterday, I think it was his second best game for us. Behind his blinder in Geelong. 

Is there a report anywhere regarding who played for Casey yesterday and how they went? Maybe I'm missing something.

17 minutes ago, big_red_fire_engine said:

Omac wont be going anywhere. Carlton aren't tall forward so best performed at Casey should come in. 

Agreed. Thought Omac improved the further the game went on. Despite some howlers, we need to continue to play him in seniors.

18 minutes ago, ArtificialWisdom said:

I still think if fit Kent should replace ANB. But it would be really harsh to drop him after the way he played yesterday, I think it was his second best game for us. Behind his blinder in Geelong. 

I don't recall the Geelong game being a blinder for ANB, but a game where he snagged a few.

P (W-D-L)	KI	MK	HB	DI	DA	GL	BH	HO	TK	RB	IF	CL	CG	FF	FA	BR	CP	UP	CM	MI	1%	BO	GA
Geelong	9		2	11		3				1		3	1	3	1	2		7	4			1

Edited March 25, 20178 yr by Redleg

Will Vince get weeks?

Just now, Clint Bizkit said:

Will Vince get weeks?

the saint's player certainly played it up. the vision of contact wasn't very good. would like to see more angles if available

Not sure if I watched the same game as the rest of you. Oscar had less howlers than Lewis, Vince and Jones. He's role is the spoil and he did that really well I thought. He's not the most polished player yet but there's no doubt he'll be best 22 every week if he plays like that

AFL game day on 7 is reporting Max Gawn (back) in its injuries. Anyone hear anything ? 

15 minutes ago, Redleg said:

I don't recall the Geelong game being a blinder for ANB, but a game where he snagged a few.

P (W-D-L)	KI	MK	HB	DI	DA	GL	BH	HO	TK	RB	IF	CL	CG	FF	FA	BR	CP	UP	CM	MI	1%	BO	GA
Geelong	9		2	11		3				1		3	1	3	1	2		7	4			1

haha damn, i remembered it better than that. although i think in my head our whole side played blinders XD

2 minutes ago, Leoncelli_36 said:

AFL game day on 7 is reporting Max Gawn (back) in its injuries. Anyone hear anything ? 

he went off in the second due to his back, Im not sure how serious it is. Goodwin mentioned it in his presser

 

The Max GAWN injury report probably isn't something to worry about. It as also reported in the AFL website match reports, as 'back tightness'.

He went off for a while in the second, even headed down to the rooms, but came back on pretty soon after and played out the rest of the game with no apparent discomfort from his back or Tom Hickey.