Potential Trades [Warning: Reading this thread may self-destruct]

[Tyson_Viney_Toumpas 269]

Who was he intimidated by.... Roos.

What?

Wasn't that Petracca?

[Guest]

He's a mobile defender, looking to pursue a role in the midfield, "as that's the way the games going". His words, not mine.

Deleted the comment as I can't be bothered getting into a debate about it (you obviously quoted me before I did though). Just because he "wants to become a midfielder" doesn't mean he is one.

If you look at draft profiles of him, you'll see that his player comparisons are the likes of Dustin Fletcher and Tom Harley. Doesn't scream midfield to me, but hey, who knows I guess. But if we keep 2 + 3, and assume Petracca goes at 1, we should take the two best available players - McCartin and Brayshaw. If we want Lever, trade down to get him.

[Tyson_Viney_Toumpas 269]

Deleted the comment as I can't be bothered getting into a debate about it (you obviously quoted me before I did though). Just because he "wants to become a midfielder" doesn't mean he is one.

If you look at draft profiles of him, you'll see that his player comparisons are the likes of Dustin Fletcher and Tom Harley. Doesn't scream midfield to me, but hey, who knows I guess. But if we keep 2 + 3, and assume Petracca goes at 1, we should take the two best available players - McCartin and Brayshaw. If we want Lever, trade down to get him.

Yeah I don't want to argue either mate and I'm not disagreeing with you.

I'm pretty sure it was Roos who said the other day also that he sees Lever going straight into a midfield?

[Axis of Bob 11,875]

... we should take the two best available players - McCartin and Brayshaw. If we want Lever, trade down to get him.

And what if Lever is one of the two best players?

[Guest]

And what if Lever is one of the two best players?

At this stage, popular opinion says otherwise. But I guess it's all speculative until they actually pull on a jumper and play AFL football.

... As we've found out in the past.

[Cards13 9,117]

What?

Wasn't that Petracca?

Lever.

[Guest]

Yeah I don't want to argue either mate and I'm not disagreeing with you.

I'm pretty sure it was Roos who said the other day also that he sees Lever going straight into a midfield?

Ok fair enough is that's the case mate, I was unaware of that.

[beelzebub 23,387]

And what if Lever is one of the two best players?

especially given roles in mind

[Tyson_Viney_Toumpas 269]

Lever.

I'm fairly sure Petracca was intimidated by Roos and said he asked the hardest question which took him 2 minutes to answer.

[qarocks 107]

Boner!

His stats after coming back from suspension:

Round 17 v Fremantle: 15 Kicks, 20 Handballs, 7 Marks, 3 Tackles, Goal. 132 Supercoach/Champion Data points.

Round 18 v Geelong: 11 Kicks, 21 Handballs. 107 Supercoach/Champion Data points.

Round 19 v Richmond: 9 Kicks, 18 Handballs, 10 Tackles. 117 Supercoach/Champion Data points.

Round 20 v North: 10 Kicks, 25 Handballs, 9 Marks, 5 Tackles. 161 Supercoach/Champion Data points.

Round 21 v Melbourne: 16 Kicks, 13 Handballs, 9 Marks, 7 tackles. 111 Supercoach/Champion Data points.

Round 22 v Collingwood: 30 Kicks, 12 Handballs, 7 Marks, 5 Tackles, Goal. 141 Supercoach/Champion Data points.

Round 23 v Dogs: 20 Kicks, 12 Handballs, 8 Marks, 5 Tackles, Goal. 131 Supercoach/Champion Data points.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Toby greene is gettable. I am 100% of this.

Is he a grammar boy? If not, we couldn't possibly go for him. He wouldn't fit in with 'Tackles' Watts.

Cheers and chin-chin!

[Axis of Bob 11,875]

At this stage, popular opinion says otherwise. But I guess it's all speculative until they actually pull on a jumper and play AFL football.

... As we've found out in the past.

As we've found out in the past .....

.... popular opinion doesn't usually reflect recruiter opinion. There are countless examples, especially this far out from the draft. This especially so when the player has been out of sight out of mind all year.

[Demon Disciple 12,313]

Is he a grammar boy? If not, we couldn't possibly go for him. He wouldn't fit in with 'Tackles' Watts.

Cheers and chin-chin!

Was a Wesley College boy, not sure if that makes it better or worse!

Frost is also a Wesley boy.

Edited October 15, 2014 by Demon Disciple

[dee-luded 2,959]

Why would we want him.He gets the ball,doesnt hold back, kix goals etc but he got drunk once in off season.

your right Biff, or is that left... lets get him, but just play him around the outer side of the ground for home games.

that should do it.

[Cards13 9,117]

I'm fairly sure Petracca was intimidated by Roos and said he asked the hardest question which took him 2 minutes to answer.

The interview I heard was a young man who said he was coming off a knee injury and spent the year working with the midfield group as even though he was 194cms tall that is the way the game is going...

[Deecisive 1,709]

maybe propose swapping pick 2 and 23 to gws for Toby green and pick 7, obviously pick two would be on the understanding that they dont touch brayshaw. they might go for it cause they love having the top picks each year. use 7 for lever.

[Redleg 41,731]

maybe propose swapping pick 2 and 23 to gws for Toby green and pick 7, obviously pick two would be on the understanding that they dont touch brayshaw. they might go for it cause they love having the top picks each year. use 7 for lever.

It would be simpler on your scenario to do 3 and 23 for Greene and 4, guaranteeing both Brayshaw and Lever, as GWS would want Petracca and then a Boyd replacement, McCartin or Wright.

[Moneider96 1,045]

maybe propose swapping pick 2 and 23 to gws for Toby green and pick 7, obviously pick two would be on the understanding that they dont touch brayshaw. they might go for it cause they love having the top picks each year. use 7 for lever.

THIS

[Cards13 9,117]

maybe propose swapping pick 2 and 23 to gws for Toby green and pick 7, obviously pick two would be on the understanding that they dont touch brayshaw. they might go for it cause they love having the top picks each year. use 7 for lever.

Mahoney at home. .. hitting refresh in DL ever 38 seconds.. sees this.. jumps on the phone to GWS..

Hey so I was just having a thought, young Toby is defs going to jail how about we help you with that.

[Tyson_Viney_Toumpas 269]

Surely it's not true that GWS have offered Ess 4,6 & 20 for Ryder?

[Tyson_Viney_Toumpas 269]

Surely it's not true that GWS have offered Ess 4,6 & 20 for Ryder?

Source twitter

[Pennant St Dee 13,318]

Thank Christ the majority of you lot weren't around in the trenches in WW1 and fighting off the northern invasion in WW2. I have never seen such a group of weak lily livered defeatists.

Oh why me

Every cloud has a silver lining look at Brisbane last season when a large group of their players wanted out

[Robbie57 2,022]

Surely it's not true that GWS have offered Ess 4,6 & 20 for Ryder?

It's crazy time. ...

[Redleg 41,731]

Source twitter

From some twit.

[demoniac 1,336]

No special sauces just unsubstantiated speculation...

Howes' tweet this arvo had me thinking.."Fair bit going on today #tradeperiod"

From Talking Carlton...

"apparently GWS offered pick 6 for howe and then howes manager asked collingwood if they were interested for pick 5 cos howe doesnt really want to go to GWS

um

wtf?"