My 3 word player analysis V Pt Adelaide

[joeboy 3,166]

N.Jones - disappeared when needed

Grimes - was rarely sighted

Salem - classy but raw

Watts - probably had sunstroke

Toumpas - made little impression

Viney - regularly lacked composure

Frawley - provided a target

Tyson - great until last

Dunn - outstanding all game

Cross - great stopping performance

Garland - reliable and safe

Pedersen - continued fine year

Vince - steady but limited

Kennedy- Harris - was disappointing today

McDonald - brave and steady

Gawn - had little impact

Howe - a few cameos

Jamar - lionhearted as always

Bail - great first half

M.Jones - great first half

Terlich - great first half

Jetta - played with passion

[deeflog 679]

I think you nailed that this week

[Buzzy 992]

Bit harsh on Kennedy-Harris.

Bit soft on Grimes.

The rest is spot on really!

[Dees 64 8]

Should read

Grimes - Turnover specialist

[Crackers 67]

Watts was good for first half

. Otherwise good

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Viney - regularly lacked composure

Cannot agree with this at all.

[Ungarieboy 443]

I really look forward to this analysis, and though limited to 3 words find it pretty accurate; but today I wanted to add a couple of things as it was (unusually) a little negative

N Jones - good but fumbled ( at the end - must have been fatigue)

Viney - team first player (really does so much of the hard stuff that goes unrewarded or unrecognised)

Tyson - Great, just great (a couple of errors when trying to push it and while the team are fatigued and not presenting shouldn't be judged harshly)

JKH - Good in patches (he played a role and when involved was influential)

M Jones - Keeps on going (is crucial to structure and though may not have the polish, getting the ball means they don't have it!)

Terlich - repels attacks well (regardless of decision making he stops his opponent and get the ball - they can't kick a goal without it!)

[KingDingAling 3,758]

Bit harsh on Kennedy-Harris.

Bit soft on Grimes.

The rest is spot on really!

I thought Kennedy-Harris was great today.

Spot on about Grimes, doesn't appear up to standard for mine.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,233]

Joeboy - didn't watch game

[dimmy 1,308]

Kennedy Haris was VG today. Presents all day

THEy just ran out of steam in the last 5 minutes.

N Jones : Terrific

Watts : Sensational first half. GOt sunstroke though. He is working harder.

Frawley : Mini Dawes Attacked the Ball

Petersen,Bail Jetta & Dunn : Gone from marginal AFL to Good. Like Jetta and Bails attack on the ball

In perspective : Decade of arrogance has begun !!

[KingDingAling 3,758]

Kennedy Haris was VG today. Presents all day

THEy just ran out of steam in the last 5 minutes.

N Jones : Terrific

Watts : Sensational first half. GOt sunstroke though. He is working harder.

Frawley : Mini Dawes Attacked the Ball

Petersen,Bail Jetta & Dunn : Gone from marginal AFL to Good. Like Jetta and Bails attack on the ball

In perspective : Decade of arrogance has begun !!

I agree mate, I was very impressed with Kennedy-Harris today.

Spot on about Bail, Pedo and Jetta. Paul Roos working miracles.

[Deecisive 1,709]

Kennedy-Harris was pretty good, he unfortunately tried to take on some of the port players a few times and either got caught or lost the ball, but all in all a good game from the young kid.

[Young Dee 1,303]

Should read

Grimes - Turnover specialist

I think that might defeat the purpose of doing a 3 word player analysis

[Bobby McKenzie 2,385]

Very negative comments this week Joeboy. If I didn't know the result I would have thought we lost by 110 points.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Joeboy - didn't watch game

Got something better to offer, including all the likers?

[What 18,810]

we must have lost by 80 reading Joeboys asessment

[Bobby McKenzie 2,385]

Kennedy Haris was VG today. Presents all day

THEy just ran out of steam in the last 5 minutes.

N Jones : Terrific

Watts : Sensational first half. GOt sunstroke though. He is working harder.

Frawley : Mini Dawes Attacked the Ball

Petersen,Bail Jetta & Dunn : Gone from marginal AFL to Good. Like Jetta and Bails attack on the ball

In perspective : Decade of arrogance has begun !!

I got the impression we were playing in a 28 degrees heat. Checked the official maximum temperature for Alice on Saturday and it was a mild and pleasant 20.7 degrees. Shouldn't cause sunstroke and shouldn't sap our energy for next week.

[Dees2014 2,377]

Kennedy-Harris was pretty good, he unfortunately tried to take on some of the port players a few times and either got caught or lost the ball, but all in all a good game from the young kid.

I think we can't always have it both ways. On the one hand we criticize when our players "don't take the game on" but on the other we complain when they get caught. My only criticism of JKH was a couple of times he could have given off a hand pass to other players streaming down field when he kicked it backwards into defence, but otherwise sound I thought. He was also asked to play down back on their smalls on occasions-rather strange I would have thought but no doubt Roos had his reasons.

[Satyriconhome 10,879]

I think we can't always have it both ways. On the one hand we criticize when our players "don't take the game on" but on the other we complain when they get caught. My only criticism of JKH was a couple of times he could have given off a hand pass to other players streaming down field when he kicked it backwards into defence, but otherwise sound I thought. He was also asked to play down back on their smalls on occasions-rather strange I would have thought but no doubt Roos had his reasons.

It's not strange it is Roos continuing his 'education', we have a little gem on our hands, he didn't look out of place

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,909]

I look forward to Joeboy's three word summaries. For mine he generally does a better job than the mainstream media in encapsulating the contest. Particularly when the media is obsessed with the "big story" of the week which means comment on no more than about 4 Melbourne players' performances a week so they can salivate over Gary Ablett, Travis Cloke and Patrick Dangerfield, week in, week out.

Having not being able to see or hear this game at all, I found this week's summary to be quite negative. My first thought was surprise but my second thought was that Joeboy has raised his own standards. He now expects more than noble losses - and I think that's great.

[nutbean 8,838]

Kennedy-Harris was pretty good, he unfortunately tried to take on some of the port players a few times and either got caught or lost the ball, but all in all a good game from the young kid.

He was caught - I prefer he continued this approach - you win games by taking it the game on on certain occasions and he will learn when to and when not to. But cudo's to him for backing his own ability.

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

Got something better to offer, including all the likers?

N.Jones - consistent all day

Grimes - errors but effort

Salem - next rising star

Watts - gaining some momentum

Toumpas - great footy smarts

Viney - always first in

Frawley - Provided a target

Tyson - scary 24 gamer

Dunn - outstanding all game

Cross - great stopping performance

Garland - reliable and safe

Pedersen - continued fine year

Vince - playing his role

Kennedy- Harris - tried too much

McDonald - brave and steady

Gawn - had little impact

Howe - a few cameos

Jamar - lionhearted as always

Bail - solid half forward

M.Jones - provided good run

Terlich - brave and solid

Jetta - most improved player?

[Satyriconhome 10,879]

N.Jones - consistent all day

Grimes - errors but effort

Salem - next rising star

Watts - gaining some momentum

Toumpas - great footy smarts

Viney - always first in

Frawley - Provided a target

Tyson - scary 24 gamer

Dunn - outstanding all game

Cross - great stopping performance

Garland - reliable and safe

Pedersen - continued fine year

Vince - playing his role

Kennedy- Harris - tried too much

McDonald - brave and steady

Gawn - had little impact

Howe - a few cameos

Jamar - lionhearted as always

Bail - solid half forward

M.Jones - provided good run

Terlich - brave and solid

Jetta - most improved player?

Now that's better, I was another that used to 'like' Joeboy's efforts, it is not that he has raised his standards, I think jaundice has set in, either that or he didn't watch the game

[nutbean 8,838]

Now that's better, I was another that used to 'like' Joeboy's efforts, it is not that he has raised his standards, I think jaundice has set in, either that or he didn't watch the game

Hey Saty,

I was (respectfully) critical of Nev Jetta, not because he wasn't doing a good shutdown job but because we needed a small defender to offer more. He needed to attack the contest rather than wait for his opponent to and then try and shut him down ( which I also said he had some success with).

On the weekend he mixed his game up - defended and shutdown when required, attacked the contest first and with confidence when he felt in position to do so and peeled off to present a loose option when we had the ball in hand.

This was what I think we all wanted to see and I am sure that Roos would have been delighted with his game.

[Satyriconhome 10,879]

Hey Saty,

I was (respectfully) critical of Nev Jetta, not because he wasn't doing a good shutdown job but because we needed a small defender to offer more. He needed to attack the contest rather than wait for his opponent to and then try and shut him down ( which I also said he had some success with).

On the weekend he mixed his game up - defended and shutdown when required, attacked the contest first and with confidence when he felt in position to do so and peeled off to present a loose option when we had the ball in hand.

This was what I think we all wanted to see and I am sure that Roos would have been delighted with his game.

Chap it's what I told you about Jetta and Roos, Roos wanted Nev to get the shutdown role to become second nature first, then when he was comfortable with that, to use his natural ability to take the game on, I spoke to him at training on the Thursday before, he was excited about playing in the Indigenous Round and was confident he could shut down Wingard and others and then start create and take the game on, but Roos rule is defend first

I was a bit doubtful about how quickly Roos and his coaches could unlock the potential that has been below the surface in a few of our mid tier players, but I was wrong.

Nev also owes Jade Rawlings, it was Jade who went in to bat for him to keep him on the rookie list.

The good thing with Nev, he is still not confident that he will be retained, so he is going out each week to make them keep him