Changes v Carlton - Round 4

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,397]

Changes? Change the effing lot.

B. Steam'n Demon, Biffen, WYL.

HB. Stuie, BBO, TSFKAs

C. Django, Redlegs, SteveTMJordan.

HF. Cudi420, JumboR, Nasher.

F. BobbyMc, WhisperingJack, Old Dee

R. Deespicable, JVineyFan.

R. Maggot77 (of course)

INT. 45HG, Steam'nDemon, IvaWarneSmith.

Sub. Gorgoroth.

If ya not picked, tuff luck, I didn't even give myself a game....

Sorry but I'm at a point were I can only laugh at our lot, Im way past all the crap my beloved Dee's have dished up SINCE '64', an interstate member I remain an will continue ta b until "WHATEVER"..........

It'd be even better if the Melbourne players took over Demonland and published their thoughts on these players. Who would be Pederson's favourite whipping boy? And who would Jack Watts criticise for not having enough mongrel? And I'd fully expect Lynden Dunn to bemoan the fact, over and over repetitively and ad nauseum that Olisik is not in the team.

[Mono 454]

Have a look at Roos' presser today. He explained his spray to Terlich but spoke very highly of his performances as a whole so far. He almost certainly won't be dropped, in fact he seems to have a fan in Roos.

He also mentioned Bail and M Jones as "cusp" players who showed a bit on Sunday.

Make of that what you will, but you wouldn't think they will be out this week.

Roos also draws a big distinction between those that don't do the non-negotiables and those that make mistakes. Mistakes are OK (up to a point I guess), but the former won't get a game.

'Landers might need to look at changes in that light.

[DeeZee 6,732]

In Dawes, Gawn, Garland, Trengove.

Out Fitzpatrick,byrnes,kent, bail

[old dee 22,852]

In Dawes, Gawn, Garland, Trengove.

Out Fitzpatrick,byrnes,kent, bail

Deezee surely you jest Dawes and Gawn have not played so much as a practise match for six weeks, Garland has not been in serious match play since the new year and Trengove did little on sunday to suggest to me it should come straight back in.

[DeeZee 6,732]

Deezee surely you jest Dawes and Gawn have not played so much as a practise match for six weeks, Garland has not been in serious match play since the new year and Trengove did little on sunday to suggest to me it should come straight back in.

Were desperate though.

[Dwight Schrute 16,751]

Sounds like Dawes is a decent chance, no idea on Garland or Gawn, and Trenners needs to be dominating at casey before i'd consider him, let him find his spark again

[old dee 22,852]

Were desperate though.

A week at Casey might mean these guys get back into the seniors in reasonable condition.

Gawn and Dawes have fairy floss legs that need to be eased into things slowly.

WE want all three for the last 15 games not in too early and out again at half time.

[Deez 298]

unfortunately dawes + garland are not likely to play.

mckenzie tags murphy.

tom mac or frawley runs with Waite - we shut him out we can just about shut down the fwd line.

Waite is a loping fwd, tommy mac can out run him.

put dunne, howe and fitz fwd.

jkh as a sub, still adjusting to work load.

as much as i don't like it, byrnes is prob the only legitimate small fwd we can play for the whole game - can't believe i want him to come to the club, useless.

bring in blease for some pace.

leave trenners out for another week.

bail stays in, he's got great running ability

Basically with those little notes, theres two areas that we can really expose them on if we hit our straps.

We have quite a number of players that can run, carlton are quite slow, we can out run them. Nicholson is another who could assist in this, despite a poor disposal.

The other area we can expose them in is hard contact.

Spencer has his flaws right now, but he can rough up their ruckmen, he's aggressive, and he can tackle as well.

If we run hard, hit hard and play disposal footy, we should get plenty of opportunities to enter the forward line.

I mentioned it in another thread, theres no reason why vince, cross, jones and tyson can't match carltons key four mids.

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,880]

Sounds like Dawes is a decent chance, no idea on Garland or Gawn, and Trenners needs to be dominating at casey before i'd consider him, let him find his spark again

I agree but having said that can't justify leaving him out if it means were bringing in McKenzie.

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,159]

On a side note, Gerard Healey on 3aw tonight basically revealed that Byrnes wanted to retire last summer but we talked him out of it.

He should be dropped this week and spend the remainder of the year at Casey.

[jumbo returns 6,488]

you can be depth then

I'm not signing anything until I see the direction that the Club is heading.

I'll be farming offers of 800k up....

[thedirtydog24 18]

On a side note, Gerard Healey on 3aw tonight basically revealed that Byrnes wanted to retire last summer but we talked him out of it.

He should be dropped this week and spend the remainder of the year at Casey.

We tried to talk Kosi into coming across and playing a year as well instead of retiring. This is fact.

Edited April 8, 2014 by thedirtydog24

[jumbo returns 6,488]

We tried to talk Kosi into coming across and playing a year as well instead of retiring. This is fact.

Really?

Fmd.

[mrtwister 650]

Out: Byrnes, Kent & Pederson

In: Garland, Dawes & Clisby

Bail - Garlett

McDonald - Henderson

Georgiou - Waite

Frawley - Rowe

Vince - Robinson

Terlich - Ellard

Grimes - Simpson

Viney - Murphy

M.Jones - Yarran

Forward line of Dawes, Dunn, Fitzpatrick, Howe with M Jones and Clisby at their feet.

Edited April 8, 2014 by mrtwister

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,089]

Sounds like Dawes is a decent chance, no idea on Garland or Gawn, and Trenners needs to be dominating at casey before i'd consider him, let him find his spark again

I saw Big Maxy doing 20m sprints today. He looked a long way off playing in my opinion.

[jumbo returns 6,488]

Out: Byrnes, Kent & Pederson

In: Garland, Dawes & Clisby

Bail - Garlett

McDonald - Henderson

Georgiou - Waite

Frawley - Rowe

Vince - Robinson

Terlich - Ellard

Grimes - Simpson

Viney - Murphy

M.Jones - Yarran

Forward line of Dawes, Dunn, Fitzpatrick, Howe with M Jones and Clisby at their feet.

Kent and Pedo won't be dropped.

Byrne, yes.

[Demon Jack 6,278]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/injury-news/injury-list

Injury update on the AFL website says that Garland is avaliable. Personally I'd love to see him back in the team, I'm sure he would increase the morale of the playing group. However, a week or two in the VFL wouldn't hurt and would help him reach a good match fitness for wither round 5 or 6. Same might go for Dawes but considering our lack of decent talls, he should be an immediate in this weekend. Mckenzie and Blease should also be considered. Trengove can have another week in the VFL to get find some form and to enjoy a couple wins.

In Dawes, Blease, Mckenzie

Out: Fitzy, Byrnes, maybe Bail

Also, hopefully JKH has a full run this weekend and isn't stuck in the vest.

[Jaded No More 57,824]

Worth throwing Garland at FF, given he lacks a bit of conditioning?

I'm sure the last memory I have of us winning is him playing out of the square.

We can't afford to ease these mature talls in. We desperately need a win!

[mrtwister 650]

Kent and Pedo won't be dropped.

Byrne, yes.

If that's the case then surely he would be put onto Rowe.

Would you then leave Frawley in the forwards?

I think Kent and Clisby are quite similar but Kent's tackle count was low last week. Get 10 tackles at Casey this week and put your hand back up for Gold Coast.

[jumbo returns 6,488]

Worth throwing Garland at FF, given he lacks a bit of conditioning?

I'm sure the last memory I have of us winning is him playing out of the square.

We can't afford to ease these mature talls in. We desperately need a win!

I agree....let's get these players in asap.

[Brayshaw Self 847]

Clisby must come in. One of our biggest problems has been bringing the ball safely out of defence and he does it well.

Kent will not be dropped, as many people have suggested. He has pace, pressures opposition backs, knows where the goals are and is an absolute mongrel. Why drop him after one game??

Edited April 8, 2014 by Evans Above

[jumbo returns 6,488]

If that's the case then surely he would be put onto Rowe.

Would you then leave Frawley in the forwards?

I think Kent and Clisby are quite similar but Kent's tackle count was low last week. Get 10 tackles at Casey this week and put your hand back up for Gold Coast.

Kent has the X factor and he's quick.

Clisby comes in for Bail.

[mrtwister 650]

Kent has the X factor and he's quick.

Clisby comes in for Bail.

Frawley?

[jumbo returns 6,488]

Frawley?

Stays forward.

Leave Pedo in the backline....he looked okay against GWS.

[Grapeviney 8,815]

On a side note, Gerard Healey on 3aw tonight basically revealed that Byrnes wanted to retire last summer but we talked him out of it.

Heard that too. Then they had a good chuckle at the fact that Byrnes and Pedo were commanding $$ way in excess of anything they'd get elsewhere, if indeed other clubs would have them..