Was trying to be rhetorical.

Wrong thread for that ...

sorry...tis monday...havent had 3rd coffee yet , my bad

Presumably no banana cake either ...

Presumably no banana cake either ...

That is for the other thread as well.

Robbo reporting Heath Shaw has decided to play for GWS at about $700,000 a year for 5 years. Silly money from GWS but they have to spend it on someone.

There goes Clark Kents rumour of either us or Geelong - ended up being GWS. More proof of his rubbish.

Beat me to it!

But hey dont say his rumour is rubbish otherwise you will get crucified by his followers..

700k x 5 years. That will sort out Shaws attitude problem...

I was told tonight that Viv wanted to play under roos so was keen to become a Dee.

If people wanna get some good inside sourced rumour this bloke is the one to listen. I remember he inboxed me telling about the mid year deal we offered to Hogan which he turned down politely before it was reported in the media a month ago.

Keep them coming SMC.

Wouldn't have thought anyone needed confirmation that Clark Kent's rumours were complete rubbish...

If he gets one right it'll be due to pure dumb luck.

My strike rate has been ordinary post Neeld.

700k x 5 years. That will sort out Shaws attitude problem...

It's also good to see them erode cap so it knocks a little bit more off the war chest available to them to go after Frawley next year.

And with Adams coming back the other way, that's settled that.

I've said it multiple times over the last few months - Buckley loves Adams and was going to do what it took to get him.

In the end, that dominoes all fell into place fairly simply for that deal to go ahead.

It's also good to see them erode cap so it knocks a little bit more off the war chest available to them to go after Frawley next year.

Got to say Ron, I honestly think GWS don't have a cap. The AFL lets them go for whoever they want and funds them to do so. When it comes to the new franchise success, they use Messendon's motto, 'whatever it takes'.

That is for the other thread as well.

Good point. So let's take it there!

Wouldn't have thought anyone needed confirmation that Clark Kent's rumours were complete rubbish...

If he gets one right it'll be due to pure dumb luck.

Duck your head..

Got to say Ron, I honestly think GWS don't have a cap. The AFL lets them go for whoever they want and funds them to do so. When it comes to the new franchise success, they use Messendon's motto, 'whatever it takes'.

If they go over the cap to pay Scully, Davis, Mumford and Heath Shaw I wont complain too much. It's more when they have to pay big bucks to keep their young players in a few years when they are winning that i'll be concerned.

Beat me to it!

But hey dont say his rumour is rubbish otherwise you will get crucified by his followers..

how do you know? as of last night it may have been geelong & us?

maybe GWS just decided to up their ante`. or maybe we jumped off?

Duck your head..

Stop being such a tosspot.

No-one with half a brain would get excited by what CK posts, which is what your constant attacks on him such a bore.

And with Adams coming back the other way, that's settled that.

I've said it multiple times over the last few months - Buckley loves Adams and was going to do what it took to get him.

In the end, that dominoes all fell into place fairly simply for that deal to go ahead.

did the pies come to some HShaw salary sacrifice or something? in order to help lubricate the adams trade?

trades

2 for Shiel

22 for Vince

36 for Lyons

54 for Michie

delisted FA . Cross

add #21 Zac Jones #70 Joel Tippett #78 Clisby (rookie upgrade)

trades

2 for Shiel

22 for Vince

36 for Lyons

54 for Michie

delisted FA . Cross

add #21 Zac Jones #70 Joel Tippett #78 Clisby (rookie upgrade)

I would sign that off right now, would be as good as we will get imo

how do you know? as of last night it may have been geelong & us?

maybe GWS just decided to up their ante`. or maybe we jumped off?

Or maybe it was out of Geelong, Collingwood and GWS as reported.

They never up the anit.. that deal was reported about 4 weeks ago.

how do you know? as of last night it may have been geelong & us?

maybe GWS just decided to up their ante`. or maybe we jumped off?

Or maybe it was BS?

Mahoney had said on 2 or 3 occasions Shaw was not high on our radar, something he himself indicated. It was always between Geelong and GWS and that's been proven to be correct. Apparently Essendon were also trying hard to land him but missed out. No mention of us. We were never in it in any way.

Or maybe it was out of Geelong, Collingwood and GWS as reported.

They never up the anit.. that deal was reported about 4 weeks ago.

so he's just made his call then, on the $$$$$, looked over all the offers in the file & gone westsydney... has to be $$$$$, to go over the Cats, unless the cats withdrew? or unless the pies reached further, so they could win Adams away from the Cats.

Or maybe it was BS?

Mahoney had said on 2 or 3 occasions Shaw was not high on our radar, something he himself indicated. It was always between Geelong and GWS and that's been proven to be correct. Apparently Essendon were also trying hard to land him but missed out. No mention of us. We were never in it in any way.

so your saying you don't know.

trades

2 for Shiel

22 for Vince

36 for Lyons

54 for Michie

delisted FA . Cross

add #21 Zac Jones #70 Joel Tippett #78 Clisby (rookie upgrade)

Perfecto.

so your saying you don't know.

And you do?

Stop going around in circles you pill.