The Dismissal of 2013 not unlike that of 1976

[thaipantsman 180]

TPM posted very early in Neeld's tenure that his appointment was Dennis Jones all over again. Jones was a similar mistake some 36 years ago. After this Big Carl took the reins and immediately looked fearsome.

Neeld for all his big talk was certainly no Big Carl. Lots of talk about the hardest team to play against but sadly we quickly became the opposite.

I was nailed to the cross by most in Demonland for simply pointing out obvious selection blunders, recruiting blunders and various strategic blunders. Blunder after blunder. Why couldn't anyone here(apart from Tonatopia) see this? Just interested? What were you guy's thinking?

Does anyone concede this very same problem has existed in the Melbourne FC hierarchy since 1965? Failure to see the bl oody obvious?

After Brisbane round one last year, the stagnant game pattern, hit the boundary at all costs mimicking Collingwood's Style. IMO most in this forum just couldn't bring themselves to believe it.The great white hope! Mark Neeld. Some 75% here even demanded Neeld was the man to revive MFC similar to many whites in Jack Johnson's era who tried to invent someone to topple the Galveston Giant. "Neeld is the man to revive Melbourne back to it's glory years." The Posts defending Neeld just kept coming. Melbourne kept on losing and the margins became larger. Melbourne not only kept losing by large margins but it was the lack of any method, strategies heart that made us appear somewhat soulless. Neeld had no punch or zip. After match conferences were senseless. Pre game addresses lacked fire. They seemed scripted, boring and school teacher like. To the contrary players ran out onto the ground revved down not up.

Tonatopia and TPM stood firm and waded through the various topics heaping praise on Neeld for doing what "needed to be done".

Sellar, Gillies, Pederson, Rodan, Byrnes will all make way for future Melbourne stars next year. Sylvia, Hogan, Clark/Dawes, Toumpass, Viney, Watts, Blease, Gawn, taggert, Clisby, Frawley, Howe, Terlich, the Jones boys, Trengrove,Mac donald Grimes and Garland will form a potent force as early as next year with the right Coach and Administration.

Neeld had to go just like Dennis. Dennis at least won 5 games in his first and only season.

Good luck to Neil Craig instilling some confidence back into boys. Am tipping to fire up V Bullies and pull off un upset.

[Little Richard 6,265]

Going by this post a congratulations is in order. Huzzah to thaipantsman! But it's Trengove, not Trengrove!

[Generation dee 1,336]

"YAAAAAAAWWWWWWNNNNNN"

Did you need to start a thread for something that had been repeated quite frequently here? Or you just wanted to heap praise on yourself in a forum spotlight? Congratulations TPM, you've started another "good riddance neeld" thread 10 days AFTER his sacking and you've made no real contribution to anything new or previously untapped. The worst thing about this back patting post, is I can't get the time I wasted spent reading this back on my life. So thanks, thanks for wasting my time reading the same old dribble, and thanks for heaping more kudos on yourself that your posts are usually full of!

[Johnny Karate 559]

Allow me to retort. Posters of your ilk were slammed for posting hysterical nonsense in the opening stanza of Neeld's tenure. It was an untenable scenario to sack a first year coach 5 minutes into his reign. Who was going to replace him in 2012 anyway? Malthouse? I'm not going to bother pointing out the obvious reasons why that wouldn't have happened.

I had no problems with posters such as Rhino Richards being skeptical of Neeld because usually it was backed up with more in depth analysis than: "We're crap. It's all Neeld's fault. We should sack him now. Mick is waiting. Herp de derp tee tiddly derp."

I often railed against those who were hijacking every thread with their pointless sack Neeld agenda in 2012.

Just because some wanted to give Neeld more time than half a season to prove himself didn't make them naive idiots who thought he was a lay down misere to take us to a flag. Just because some were calling for his head 5 minutes in to his tenure and he was subsequently gone 18 months later doesn't make them footballing Nostradamuses whom everybody should bow down to.

The Neeld era was a tragedy and a travesty but if headkicking your fellow supporters whose greatest crime was optimism about a new coach while giving yourself the title of football prophet floats your dinghy - carry on!

[DemonFrog 1,354]

I miss poor old NM. DM and CW.

I have noone to blame for the teams perforance now.

Oh well I will get over it!

Long Live PJ, hes the man.

:wub: :wub: :wub:

Edited June 28, 2013 by TheBigFrog

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,765]

Am I misreading this or are you talking about yourself in the third person? Awesome.

[DemonFrog 1,354]

Am I misreading this or are you talking about yourself in the third person? Awesome.

Its Lunch time and I was bored LOL

[Guest]

Allow me to retort. Posters of your ilk were slammed for posting hysterical nonsense in the opening stanza of Neeld's tenure. It was an untenable scenario to sack a first year coach 5 minutes into his reign. Who was going to replace him in 2012 anyway? Malthouse? I'm not going to bother pointing out the obvious reasons why that wouldn't have happened.

I had no problems with posters such as Rhino Richards being skeptical of Neeld because usually it was backed up with more in depth analysis than: "We're crap. It's all Neeld's fault. We should sack him now. Mick is waiting. Herp de derp tee tiddly derp."

I often railed against those who were hijacking every thread with their pointless sack Neeld agenda in 2012.

Just because some wanted to give Neeld more time than half a season to prove himself didn't make them naive idiots who thought he was a lay down misere to take us to a flag. Just because some were calling for his head 5 minutes in to his tenure and he was subsequently gone 18 months later doesn't make them footballing Nostradamuses whom everybody should bow down to.

The Neeld era was a tragedy and a travesty but if headkicking your fellow supporters whose greatest crime was optimism about a new coach while giving yourself the title of football prophet floats your dinghy - carry on!

Pretty much on the money there Jimmi. While I have had a go at people on this board who howled others down for being 'negative', what annoys me now is this revisionist history now being spouted about how 'we knew!!!'. Sacking a coach 8 weeks in would have been ridiculous. Clearly after 148 points, the horse had bolted but to say you knew from week 1, 2012 is just you stumbling over your d*** and getting one right.

[Mickey 4,690]

A quick summary for those who don't want to read the whole OP... 'I told you so'

[Satyriconhome 10,879]

"Some 75% here even demanded Neeld was the man to revive MFC similar to many whites in Jack Johnson's era who tried to invent someone to topple the Galveston Giant"

Black and white (invented or not) were not allowed to 'topple' each other during the majority of the Galveston Gians's era

You have expressed yourself, but obviously didn't or don't allow others to express themselves if it is at odds with your view, is this correct?

Hindsight is a wonderful thing isn't it

Pity most of us were aboard the Blunder-bus

[LegsLeoncelli 162]

A quick summary for those who don't want to read the whole OP... 'I told you so'

Or more accurately:

"Thaipantsman told you so", said thaipantsman.

[Nasher 33,616]

Is it unethical for a mod to call a poster a self-indulgent knob, close the thread and give him no right of reply? Oops.

[Whispering_Jack 30,260]

Just for the record, Dennis Jones coached Melbourne in 1978, not 1976 but what difference does a year or two make in the history of a club like ours?