POST MATCH DISCUSSION

[DeeSpencer 25,497]

Some signs for next year today.

Get Mitch Clark back and throw Hogan in even just for a supporting role with the likes of Kent and Howe and we will have a forward line. Apart from some horrible goal kicking/last kicks into the forwardline we really should've put up some kind of score from limited forward 50's. Jamar showed some more spirit. We know our key defenders can play and we also know that Terlich can play even though he had a tough day at the office today. Strauss was poor defensively, he's not used to playing on guys like Puopolo who are all intensity. But he found the ball early and wasn't afraid to use it well. He's the type of player you have to continue with and coach. He's undoubtedly got more athletic ability and skill than Cheney who's getting a game for the top team in the comp and Duryea.

But once again between the arcs is just a massive issue. Not only does Jones look like the only guy capable of winning a clearance but on the wings Matt Jones and Evans got torched today. Evans battled on and they rightly subbed Matt Jones. McKenzie I'd persist with because he restricted Hodge early and Burgoyne late and started to work out how to play to his limitations as the game went on. Trengove though is a huge concern. Rodan I'd stop the in one week out the next despite his horrible first half I'd play him now. But really it's Viney, Toumpas and the draft/free agency that's our only hope with this midfield.

[Soidee 1,496]

That is a wonderful idea...

Jack is looking real shaky! If everybody was totally honest he does not deserve his place in the team. That's where it's at!

[Return to Glory 8,412]

Didn't like Pedersons game.

[Toorak 108]

I liked what I saw today. I think Neeldy is starting to turn things around.

I'm looking forward to traveling more than 1000kms to see next Mondays game. Bring it on.

[glimpse 7]

If ANY of our players were suddenly put into the Geelong team, I am sure their skills etc would be AFL standard. No we don't need a total change in players, we just need a coach and support staff who know what they are doing!

[rjay 24,889]

Kent really showed a bit and has a lot of kent in him, with Taggert, Blease, Viney, Toumpas and Hogan to come in plus a bit of Clark experience a couple of early picks in the draft, maybe a good free agent mid and we could be ok.

Dawes showed a bit, I was not convinced but if he keeps working like that he will be a real bonus. Plus a lot of his marks stuck today, the pies are actually missing him at the moment.

[Return to Glory 8,412]

Jack is looking real shaky! If everybody was totally honest he does not deserve his place in the team. That's where it's at!

I felt they exploited his lack of pace today big time

[DeeSpencer 25,497]

Liked Evans game. It's our 5 - 7 fringe players that are no good.

He came into it but he was getting torched early and not finding the ball to get it our way. He's certainly not the cause of our problems but the fact he's assumed the role of one our better and more physically adept midfielders sums up where we are at.

[ThreeOneSix 954]

Potential coaches watching from the outside, surely we will get some quality candidates.

We have massive scope for improvement in our list.

*Jones is a quality midfielder, he is elite, just needs a supporting cast.

*Dawes has shown over the past couple of weeks that he is a leader and more than capable of being a dominate forward.

* Mitch Clark is in the stands and is one of the best forwards in that competition, hasn't played a game with Dawes as yet.

* Jack Viney has shown that he is the future, currently in the stands, screams elite and will benefit going around this year, be twice as good next year, one would think.

* Jesse Hogan, on face value is a Wayne Carey clone, at worst Michael Hurley, will add to the side straight away next year.

* Jack Watts, flat track bully in the juniors will only get better as he gets older - as flat track bullies like him and Tom Hawkins do, Watts will be some player in the future.

* Dean Kent and Jeremy Howe will only get better, they are freakish players.

I could go on, but the gist of it is, we have scope to improve, all the above, along with improvement in decent young players on our list, we are aren't a basket case.

We have a great backline, decent forward line - at least we will when Clarks back... We have no midfield, if a new coach comes in and brings an elite midfielder.

We will see rapid results.

[skills32 229]

Jack Watts put in hard a few times and learnt that if you go in hard you don't get hurt.

This could be his come out game.

[ThreeOneSix 954]

Kent really showed a bit and has a lot of kent in him, with Taggert, Blease, Viney, Toumpas and Hogan to come in plus a bit of Clark experience a couple of early picks in the draft, maybe a good free agent mid and we could be ok.

Dawes showed a bit, I was not convinced but if he keeps working like that he will be a real bonus. Plus a lot of his marks stuck today, the pies are actually missing him at the moment.

I agree.

[Deestroy All 14,262]

If you added Sylvia, Ablett's Snr and Jnr, Judd, Jobe Watson, Lewis Jetta and Peter Matera, I reckon we could've won today.

Jones, Dawes, Garland and Frawley can all hold their heads up.

Howe was good again.

Kent is promising.

Beyond that, a bunch of triers and hasbeens.

It's just so painful.

[Return to Glory 8,412]

Agree. Put a couple of break the lines midfielders into this team and the transformation would be remarkable IMO 316

[The heart beats true 18,110]

Dawes, Clark, Howe, Hogan forward.

Frawley, Garland, Tom Mac back.

Watts versatile.

We have the bones. We really do. If we can get 2 class midfield in and under types and keep Sylvia we would see a massive improvement next year.

Terlich, Kent and Matt Jones gave showed they could develop. Evans the same.

Concerned about those in the system 3-4 years - Strauss, Bail, Trengove, Tapscott, Blease etc. Just not seeing much future for them.

[Undeeterred 3,123]

Hate to call you on this, but this is complete garbage.

If ANY of our players were suddenly put into the Geelong team, I am sure their skills etc would be AFL standard. No we don't need a total change in players, we just need a coach and support staff who know what they are doing!

[Return to Glory 8,412]

Trengove is not a number 2 draft pick though. We blew that one.

[Generation dee 1,336]

If ANY of our players were suddenly put into the Geelong team, I am sure their skills etc would be AFL standard. No we don't need a total change in players, we just need a coach and support staff who know what they are doing!

I don't normally do this, but you have no idea and you would be right at home on Sesame Street.

[Deemotivated 550]

They clearly try BUT...

Tackling efficiency was still ordinary

Skills and decision making are pathetic

We stand flat footed with zero spread

We refuse to take the game on

[Redleg 40,856]

Kent really showed a bit and has a lot of kent in him, with Taggert, Blease, Viney, Toumpas and Hogan to come in plus a bit of Clark experience a couple of early picks in the draft, maybe a good free agent mid and we could be ok.

Dawes showed a bit, I was not convinced but if he keeps working like that he will be a real bonus. Plus a lot of his marks stuck today, the pies are actually missing him at the moment.

Plus Sylvia, Grimes and Tom Mc if he gets back to 2012 form. .

[RalphiusMaximus 6,026]

Honestly, I don't think I've ever been more encouraged by a 95 point loss. We matched them for periods, but they kept it up constantly and whenever we slipped off them they scored in bursts. Had our usual problems getting good forward 50 entries which translates as a low score, but you would expect a loss of that magnitude to be far worse than it actually was in terms of the play.

Of note:

Dawes really stepped up. He worked hard and gave us that vital link between HF and wing. 21 disposals and 12 marks is a huge effort.

Nathan Jones continues to be the man carrying our midfield. 28 Disposals, 16 contested and 11 clearances. So good they used Sam Mitchell to tag him in the last quarter.

Col Garland and James Frawley can both take a bow. They were awesome on the best forward tag-team in the competition. Not only did they hold the twin towers, but they got involved the other way as well.

Dean Kent showed a bit today. He is going to do very well for us in the next decade. Love his confidence to step around some of the stars of the game and take them on. This is his third game people.

I wish Fitzy hadn't looked so nervous. Had a chance to take a few telling marks and fumbled them. Could have had a few goals if his hands had been better, but he did enough to keep for another week.

David Rodan had his best game in our colours and probably his best in a few years. Burnt his teammates a couple of times, but he was heavily involved and had an impact.

[Return to Glory 8,412]

I don't normally do this, but you have no idea and you would be right at home on Sesame Street.

You're being generous. Some unusual posts in the spirit of Enyaw

[Undeeterred 3,123]

I'd say today we took the game on more than in any match I've seen since the Bailey years.

Quite seriously.

They clearly try BUT...

Tackling efficiency was still ordinary
Skills and decision making are pathetic
We stand flat footed with zero spread
We refuse to take the game on

[Nasher 33,607]

Thanks for trying Mark.

[Craig Drinker 179]

Okay so I've had a couple at the local whilst watching the game but I'm trying to remain positive. Firstly, this may be the thrashing that needed to be had. Board meeting Monday, maybe some changes to follow.

I actually think we have some decent players emerging. I am liking Terlich, Evans, M.Jones, Fitzpatrick and others. Some good boys at Casey also! Howie is a very impressive player.N. Jones, make up your own mind and I would be devastated if we lost Watts. I'm a big Watts fan under the correct environment.

I would think a propective experienced coach from the outside looking in would find the melbourne coaching gig reasonably attractive. The big concern for a prospective coach would be the administration.

Unfortunately for Mark Neeld it just isn't working or likely to ever work. He needs to be cut loose and at least he won't be financially disadvantaged.He had a crack, stood by his principles/visions and was his own man. Credit to you Mark!

I believe the MFC need to act quickly and make some important decisions for the future in a very short space of time! My opinion.

[Undeeterred 3,123]

And won't we all love it when Dawes takes 11 marks in a lead up CHF role, and when he bangs it 60 m to the top of the square, it will be Clark standing under it rather than Davey and Fitzpatrick.