Who I am? A guessing quiz.

[DeeVoted 583]

Thanks Jack

I went to a lot of trouble on that one, double checking Barass WAS wearing No2

You nailed it before it got off the ground.

[DeeVoted 583]

Ron Barassi.

CORRECT!!

Who am I ......... (1st Clue)

Wearing number 2. I played in a losing Grand Final.

I am .....?

Who am I ......... (2nd Clue)

My 1st game was in Round 4 against Footscray.I am a midfielder.

I am .....?

Who am I ......... (3rd Clue)

I grew up in a Victorian country town. I helped look after the galahs.

I had a fox that I admired, although my father never knew that.

I am .....?

Who am I ......... (4th Clue)

My playing career spanned 15 years. I played over 200 games for Melbourne.

I played in 8 Grand Finals. Won 6 lost 2. I also coached the MFC.

I am .....?

Ans = Ronald Dale Barassi

Edit: fixed his won tally.

Edited November 8, 2012 by Deevoted

[PaulRB 6,363]

Fantastic! Loving it!

[Whispering_Jack 30,140]

CORRECT!!

Who am I ......... (1st Clue)

Wearing number 2. I played in a losing Grand Final.

I am .....?

Who am I ......... (2nd Clue)

My 1st game was in Round 4 against Footscray.I am a midfielder.

I am .....?

Who am I ......... (3rd Clue)

I grew up in a Victorian country town. I helped look after the galahs.

I had a fox that I admired, although my father never knew that.

I am .....?

Who am I ......... (4th Clue)

My playing career spanned 15 years. I played over 200 games for Melbourne.

I played in 7 Grand Finals. Won 5 lost 2. I also coached the MFC.

I am .....?

Ans = Ronald Dale Barassi

Sorry to spoil things but I couldn't help it. He wore #2 because the VFL was upset about one of our newspapers publishing the players' numbers and were worried it would affect sales of the Footy Record so they changed all the players' numbers. I reckon it cost us the flag.

By the way, RDB played in six premierships not five - 1955, 1956, 1957, 1959, 1960 and 1964. Frank "Bluey" Adams was the other Melbourne player who played in all six flag winning matches. Please make sure RDB doesn't find out you tried to short change him a flag because he would never let you forget it.

[DeeVoted 583]

By the way, RDB played in six premierships not five - 1955, 1956, 1957, 1959, 1960 and 1964. Frank "Bluey" Adams was the other Melbourne player who played in all six flag winning matches. Please make sure RDB doesn't find out you tried to short change him a flag because he would never let you forget it.

I just spoke to him earlier, I rang the club, tried to contact his mum, trying to confirm his No in that GF. I didnt want to go from memory.

So what happens, you waltz in, nail it in one, then bugger off. Anyone think you run the place.

OH, you are supposed to holidaying and trying to sort out our experiments re game plans.

Gee I timed that wrong, might have stumped a few before you got here, Back to the drawing board for me.

I'll keep you in mind on the next one. Perhapsyou know what he had for breakfast that morning with Norm.

Seriously....

You might be right about costing us a flag i was thinking the same watching the game while confirming he wore No 2.

I deducted one off his tally for buggering off in '65. I had to change my jumper No. So stuff him. lol

Edited November 8, 2012 by Deevoted

[DeeVoted 583]

Sorry to spoil things but I couldn't help it. He wore #2 because the VFL was upset about one of our newspapers publishing the players' numbers and were worried it would affect sales of the Footy Record so they changed all the players' numbers. I reckon it cost us the flag.

PS: Did you also know a former Melbourne player was responsible or played a big part in the foundation of the Footy Record back in 1921? (5) somewhere thereabouts. He worked for the Argus. (George Cathie snr)

Thats my next Who I am. I am about to give up, I may well give the answers as well now. I'm getting creamed here.

A new one tomorrow *sigh* yes you can still have a shot at it.

Edited November 8, 2012 by Deevoted

[DeeVoted 583]

May I suggest you go back a little Deevoted, we had a few hundred Demons play between 1897 and 1950 - that may pull a few up short.

I'm trying to dig out the "Footy Record" teamsheet for the 1858 game V Geelong lol

Edited November 8, 2012 by Deevoted

[DeeVoted 583]

Deevoted, another forum i frequent (a history one) often have quizzes

The winning poster gets to pose the next quiz

If he declines the originator offers a new one

adds a bit of variety

just a thought if you get stumped coming up with new ones

I thought this over, and came up with an alternative.

If anyone wants the quiz chair for the week, and think they can stump the masses , send me a PM for details.

Posting randomly will only be confusing for all. You only need to put together min of 5 players with clues for each.

Next in the hot seat is "red and blue forever" he will be hosting, gives me a chance to recharge the batteries.

[DeeVoted 583]

Reminder - One guess/post per clue. (read the opening post if in doubt).

Who am I ......... (1st Clue)

The start of my career was delayed through no fault of my own.

I am .....?

[nutbean 8,838]

nutbean...

I keep sending the club my youtube highlights with my phone number but not a return call....nuttin

[Deeoldfart 8,033]

Reminder - One guess/post per clue. (read the opening post if in doubt).

Who am I ......... (1st Clue)

The start of my career was delayed through no fault of my own.

I am .....?

'Tassie' Johnson?

[H_T 3,047]

Reminder - One guess/post per clue. (read the opening post if in doubt).

Who am I ......... (1st Clue)

The start of my career was delayed through no fault of my own.

I am .....?

Sam Blease?

[Whispering_Jack 30,140]

Robbie Flower.

[PaulRB 6,363]

Ivor Warne-Smith.

[stingrays 24]

John Tilbrook

[DeeVoted 583]

That is a very broad / vague clue I gave (I had too)

Good to see some having a punt.

NO correct guess as yet.

If we get into round 2, the prize money doubles. I'll post the 2nd clue (if required) early mid Sat.

Edited November 9, 2012 by Deevoted

[Old Man Rivers 326]

Allen Jakovich

[Bobby McKenzie 2,385]

Sorry to spoil things but I couldn't help it. He wore #2 because the VFL was upset about one of our newspapers publishing the players' numbers and were worried it would affect sales of the Footy Record so they changed all the players' numbers. I reckon it cost us the flag.

By the way, RDB played in six premierships not five - 1955, 1956, 1957, 1959, 1960 and 1964. Frank "Bluey" Adams was the other Melbourne player who played in all six flag winning matches. Please make sure RDB doesn't find out you tried to short change him a flag because he would never let you forget it.

Jack, I looked at the match scores of the two GF that Barassi lost 1954 and 1958. According to their stats Barass wore his usual number #31 as did all the other players. I went to both GF in question and cannot remember the numbers being switched. Please enlighten me here. I am assuming (maybe wrongly) that it was a Melbourne GF loss.

[45HG 1,539]

Ivor Warne-Smith?

[Wilson7 2,670]

Sean Wight

[DeeVoted 583]

This could be a 1st, we might be moving into round 2.

None correct yet.

[DeeVoted 583]

Jack, I looked at the match scores of the two GF that Barassi lost 1954 and 1958. According to their stats Barass wore his usual number #31 as did all the other players. I went to both GF in question and cannot remember the numbers being switched. Please enlighten me here. I am assuming (maybe wrongly) that it was a Melbourne GF loss.

Bobby it is a fact, just as Jack explained. The 1958 GF the players wore different numbers. Before I did the clues for the Barassi quiz, I knew he wasnt wearing his usual 31. I would have put money on him wearing No2, only because I related that to Robbie,so it stuck.

I have been checking my facts,beforehand, for clues,made the odd slipup (only human). I checked various places to confirm what number he wore.

None I checked backed up the evidence. The youtube clip didnt show enough for me to use,if my clue was disputed,I had to drag out a video tape of

the game (1958 GF). He is there, for all to see, wearing number 2.

The only thing I was dark on I reckon I had you blokes on that, before Jack deflated my tyres.

Just on the subject that Jack touched on, the then VFL made us change numbers, the karma / awe of the team may have been effected.

(and the fact the filth went the knuckle tor the best part of a 1/2 of footy,to unsettle us)

So really reading between Jacks; lines, he is still dirty on it! 60+ years on,and they are still at it, trying to stitch us up.

edit: fixed a typo

Edited November 9, 2012 by Deevoted

[DeeVoted 583]

I'll post the 2nd clue in 4-5 hrs time (approx) . If required.

You can use phone a friend if you need too.

[stingrays 24]

1958 GF Record: Players list: NOTE Player Number 10

Sept. 20, 1958 THE FOOTBALL RECORD

V.F.L. REGISTERED PLAYERS

MELBOURNE (Red and Blue)

1—Beckwith, J

2—Barassi, R

3—Johnson, T

4—Fenion-Smith, R

5—Webb, A

6—Brenchley, P

7—Marquis, P

8—Johnson, R

9—Case, G

10—Wilson, C

11—Carroll, K

12—Williams, D

14—Gleeson, T

15—McLean, L

18—Dixon, B

17—Adams, F

18—Rowarth, A

19—Milhen, L

20—Thorogood, L

21—Jones, D

22—Lord, J

23—Ridley, L

24—Tunbridge G

25—Crompton, N

26—Laidlaw, C

MELBOURNE

Backs: Beckwith, Marquis, Wilson

H-Backs: Carroll, Williams* Thorogood

Centres: McLean, L. Mithen, Dixon

H-Forwards: Tunbridge, T. Johnson Brenchley.

Forwards: R. Johnson, Webb, Adams

Followers: Barassi, Fenton-Smith

Rover: Ridley

19 & 20: Crompton, Gleeson

Emerg.: Jones, Rowarth, Turner

COLLINGWOOO (Black and White)

1—Weideman, M

2—Lucas, P

3—Harrison, B

4—Henderson, J

5—Brewer, L

6—Smale, K

7—Beers, B

8—Fellowes, G

9—Dixon, D

10—Twomey, W

11—Benneli, K

12—Greve, R

13—Gabelich, R

14—Serong, W

15—Rose, K

16—Merrett, T

17—Reeves, R

18—Beckwilh, K

19—Turner, K

20—Sullivan, H

21—Waller, N

22—Gray, B

23—Twomey, M

24—Delaniy, M

25—Tuck, F

COLLINGWOOD

Backs: Reeves, Sullivan, Gabelich

H-Backs: Rose, Delanty, Lucas

Centres: Gray, Henderson, K. Turner

H-Forwards: Serong, Weideman, Beers

Forwards: M. Twomey, Brewer, Bennett

Followers: Fellowes, Harrison

Rover: Merrett

19 & 20: Smale, Greve

Emerg.: Waller, Powell, Dixon

[45HG 1,539]

Listing the playing numbers etc. is fine.

If someone lists the results for that day, there may be bans...