20 and Petterd is rumoured, im ok with it. Petterd stank this year

think id want a lower round pick upgrade if this is offered

I don't know how this became another Sylvia thread but I'll just quickly make the point the Mark Neeld specifically commented on how much improved Col's work rate was in the second half of the year. Considering Neelds philosophies I'm very happy to hear that.

Back on Dawes, if the pies manage to squeeze out anything more from Melbourne they will have done very well. I do wonder whether Dawes's manager coming out and saying pick 20 should get it done played our hand too soon, it didn't really leave us with any middle ground to go to. I think most would agree that 20 is about right (if not a little over from us), but because that could have been our "compromising" offer that has now become our first offer. Thing is he's worth more to us than he is to collingwood, and they know it.

Worst part is that the Pies might make us sweat for a while just to [censored] us off.

20 and Petterd might be overs, but lets not kid ourselves; we need some more starting 22 forwards. Clark aside the forward line has been a revolving door. Green & Jurrah are gone, and Howe spends time in the midfield.

I'm happy to get Dawes for pick 20 and petterd, but hope we havent offerd him the same coin as Clark

Petterd will be delisted if he isn't traded...it doesn't make much difference to us whether we offer Pick 20 or Petterd + Pick 20

Where on fb is this info coming from about dawes and petterd?

Ricky

Petterd + 20 for Chris Dawes CONFIRMED !!

20 and Petterd is rumoured, im ok with it. Petterd stank this year

Do the deal

Ricky

Ricky

Ah, if only all the heated differences of opinion on this board could be handled like this.

Petterd + 20 for Chris Dawes CONFIRMED !!

where? who?

Ricky B)

Ricky (IWUAEHIIUE)

Ricky ( insert unused emoticon !! )

Is this just a case of those smartarse Pies wanting to gloat that they got something more than pick 20..or do they rate him?

He was once quite good.. but then.....

Petterd + 20 for Chris Dawes CONFIRMED !!

Where are you hearing this from Steamin Demon?

Its not confirmed.. just rumours

Ricky to live La vida COLLoca ??

Petterd + 20 for Chris Dawes CONFIRMED !!

Please don't say the source was the Facebook trades page.

Having said that, I wouldn't be unhappy with this. Petterd hasn't shown much in a while.

If Petterd kicks the winning goal against us on QB, I will have to do something reckless.

Edited October 15, 201213 yr by P_Man

Its not confirmed.. just rumours

It's confirmed to be a rumour.

So its official then,: it a genuine bonefide rumour !! Doesnt get better than that really does it ?

snap !! lol

Anyone who quotes a Facebook page as a confirmed source should have his or her account deleted.

on facebook now Trade Rumour: Chris Dawes to Melbourne. Pick 20 and Ricky Petterd to Collingwood.

Take that deal and run.

Would be highway robbery on our behalf.

Take that deal and run.

Would be highway robbery on our behalf.

Ssshhhh!