Scully Blast

[Its Miller time 6]

Has he bulked up yet? Far easier to set a time like that if he hasn't.

Im sure Trengove could run that no problems if he dropped 5kg of muscle. Wouldn't help him play football though.

[Demonsterative 3,019]

I dont see any reason for GWS to lie. $cully is their marquee player and they will milk any newsworthy item they can. They need the media attention to create the following for long term survival.

I see two big question marks on $cully's long term AFL capabilities. His injury and his ability to play with the big boys. Everyone knows his athletic abilities, and in an under age comp, he had AFL standard athletic abilities playing against boys. This made him the elite junior.

I doubt whether he can transfer this against men with the same athletic abilty as he lives in a boy's body. I believe he will be out-muscled and tagged out the game. His foot skills are average too. He will become a good AFL player but not elite.

So an average, young No 1 draft pick player left the club. So did Barassi, Healy, Wells and Alves. They left for $$$$ and/or success too. I think they were bigger loses than $cully in their time. Too much energy wasted on the boy i think. Regardless of the circumstances.

[Lutz 76]

Totally agree, but i think it is very strange that a chronic dodgy knee that missed half our season is now setting a seriously good time within months.

Don't you recall that he was burning up the track last preseason, then after the intraclub match didn't surface again for some time?

His knee issue means he can't handle high loads on it - he's destined to be pulled and held back for the rest of his career.

[Lutz 76]

I never liked this from the beginning. His latent knee problems resurfaced uncomfortably soon after the start of the GWS rumours despite reports he was training like a gun immediately beforehand. The rumours and his dicky knee tracked a parallel course for the remainder of the season. Despite the occasional bandage and icepack he never moved or looked like he carried an injury in his few games with us last season. Then he signs the biggest ever AFL contract despite having a season ruined by injury with associated poor form and diminished skills. All too much to believe unless I like to feel gullible.

Doesn't explain why he's been in rehab with GWS...

[old55 23,077]

What time did Phil do for the course?

I think the 3km run was around Phil.

[Sir Why You Little 36,761]

Don't you recall that he was burning up the track last preseason, then after the intraclub match didn't surface again for some time?

His knee issue means he can't handle high loads on it - he's destined to be pulled and held back for the rest of his career.

Yes i understand the load factor but it does not diminish that 9 m 37 is a very good time on a knee that kept him out for half a season. It just adds to the murky water...

[Guest Jackie]

Doesn't explain why he's been in rehab with GWS...

Rehab could mean anything and 2 bex every night and a Balinese massage once a week would qualify for rehab therapy. The devil is in the detail.

[bjDee 1,249]

I think the 3km run was around Phil.

Brilliant!.

For my part, I assumed there must have been a big bag of cash at the finish line for the first home.

[Guest Jackie]

Brilliant!.

For my part, I assumed there must have been a big bag of cash at the finish line for the first home.

even more brilliant.

[Biffen 12,937]

Scully will be chasing jumpers for the next three years .

Hope his father is healthy enough to witness it .

[Sir Why You Little 36,761]

The visuals to both are just gold. $$$ and fried foods...

[hardtack 10,441]

Totally agree, but i think it is very strange that a chronic dodgy knee that missed half our season is now setting a seriously good time within months.

Are you suggesting that the MFC didn't have his knee checked out by their own medicos... or that they simply took Scully on his word? I am more than happy to accept that he does have a dodgy knee. And to all those commenting that they wouldn't believe this time as Scully is a proven liar... similarly, I doubt the time would have been passed on to the journo by Scully himself based on what he noted on his wrist watch.

[Sir Why You Little 36,761]

Are you suggesting that the MFC didn't have his knee checked out by their own medicos... or that they simply took Scully on his word? I am more than happy to accept that he does have a dodgy knee. And to all those commenting that they wouldn't believe this time as Scully is a proven liar... similarly, I doubt the time would have been passed on to the journo by Scully himself based on what he noted on his wrist watch.

Oh i am sure the MFC medicos know Tom'$ knee better than anyone. That is not the point. If he signed a GW$ contract on his return from China which i think he did, i wonder whether there was also an insurance clause written in governing how much we could play him? $6 mill is a biggy particularly when the AFL are the underwriters.

How dodgy was/is that knee...?

[Lutz 76]

So now you think MFC were compliant in not playing Scully in 2011, so as not to void his GWS contract due to an insurance clause based on how many games he played??

If that's what you're getting at, it's mental.

[Demonsterative 3,019]

Rehab could mean anything and 2 bex every night and a Balinese massage once a week would qualify for rehab therapy. The devil is in the detail.

A balinese massage? Does that mean a massage plus? Lol, surely not for mr holylier than now. Maybe for $ully snr. He wouldnt need to work hard or move a muscle

[Sir Why You Little 36,761]

So now you think MFC were compliant in not playing Scully in 2011, so as not to void his GWS contract due to an insurance clause based on how many games he played??

If that's what you're getting at, it's mental.

So is getting a $6 mill contract with a "dodgy" knee

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

few thoughts...

- 'he went easy on his knee in 2011' this is an idiotic statement. If his knee requires caution what happens in R1 2012 or is he going to 'go easy on it' for his whole career?

-if there is in fact nothing wrong with his knee then WTF is Doc Larkins smoking writing that piece basically saying the kid is doomed to an injury-plagued career?

-does anyone care about the sport of football anymore or do we only care about how fast a bloke can run? I would like to see some sort of chart comparing the best 3km time-trial efforts in the comp with who the actual most effective players are, I suspect there would be little correlation.

-regardless of what happens now, we will have two mid-first round draft picks and the salary cap space to allow us to snag Mitch Clark and hang on to Trengove, Watts etc. There is still every chance that long-term we will end up being the winners of this GWS episode and that's just a fact

-be thankful he has gone to this pathetic mob who will cellar-dwell for years, possibly his whole career. What would really have hurt would have been if he had gone to the Bombers/Tigers or something, become a star in a side that ultimately cost us a premiership

way too much hand-wringing over this issue, move on people

[Sir Why You Little 36,761]

few thoughts...

- 'he went easy on his knee in 2011' this is an idiotic statement. If his knee requires caution what happens in R1 2012 or is he going to 'go easy on it' for his whole career?

thats the question we can all ask GWS in time. Do you really think Tom gave the MFC 100% last year? He certainly put in for that time trial.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Demon, Lime and Bitters.

[Guest Jackie]

A balinese massage? Does that mean a massage plus? Lol, surely not for mr holylier than now. Maybe for $ully snr. He wouldnt need to work hard or move a muscle

Well, it's on the record TS does need rehab for his dicky knee.

Edited January 12, 2012 by Jackie

[digby wolf 1]

It's well known that Rat's can run fast, so what ?

[Sydney Pennski 294]

The way I see it, Scully is GWS's marquee signing and he's basically being doing rehab since he came to Sydney. The Giants need publicity and when he runs a good time in their 3km time trial, that's the thing they need to highlight in their media. The time itself speaks to his aerobic capacity which is well known and he could possibly do a much better time if he was in full training.

[Guest Gotzy15]

I can't believe we're still going on about $cully. The Kid was deceitful, selfish and greedy with no concept of doing the right thing by his club and his mates.

He goes to GWS with the knee of a 80 year old, we get the same compo package Geelong got for Ablett (2 time premiership hero, brownlow medallist, MVP etc) and most importantly enough room in our salary cap to lure a potential star key position player in Mitch Clark to the club!

How was Scullys decision to take the money and run not a big win for the MFC?

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

I have no doubt that Scully's a supreme athlete. I also think it likely that he will be, at the very minimum, a very, very good AFL player.

It's his character that always concerned me. From a distance, he seems to be weirdly unemotional for a kid of his age.

And I think it's too convenient to say he's 'professional', because quite frankly I don't think his conduct and approach over the past two years was particularly professional. Perhaps you can lay that at the feet of his agent/advisers, but I would love to see how a psychiatrist would profile his personality type.

Jack Trengove on the other hand - he's got emotional intelligence in spades. And ability. And love of club. And about everything else we could possibly have hoped for ...

[biggestred 4,855]

I can't believe we're still going on about $cully. The Kid was deceitful, selfish and greedy with no concept of doing the right thing by his club and his mates.

He goes to GWS with the knee of a 80 year old, we get the same compo package Geelong got for Ablett (2 time premiership hero, brownlow medallist, MVP etc) and most importantly enough room in our salary cap to lure a potential star key position player in Mitch Clark to the club!

How was Scullys decision to take the money and run not a big win for the MFC?

decision - fine. money - fine.

lying to jim stynes, the club and the supporters - not fine.