Did anyone receive a phone call tonight from a player

[dees189227 12,241]

We had Sam Blease ring my house to speak to my brother about re signing. The funny thing is he already had round 1 but it must have got lost between the mcg and the office.

Anyway just interested because I wonder if there was anyone who had the guts to say why should I buy a membership when you guys are getting paid heaps & not performing.

I also wanted to know if the youngsters called because supporters would be a little easier on them.

[Real Demon 232]

I don't think they need to cop that when all they are trying to do is make a friendly call to get a member to renew....... especially a kid like Blease. The players and coach have been beaten up enough by the media this week without having to cop it on the phone from supporters!

[ox_5 163]

All the players call, not just the kids.

[Guest Artie Bucco]

I'm embarrassed to say that I watched the footy show tonight, and I even saw footage of Bailey working the phones!

I think he would have copped a right earbashing.

[Trengove the Magnifique 9 23]

I'm embarrassed to say that I watched the footy show tonight, and I even saw footage of Bailey working the phones!

I think he would have copped a right earbashing.

May I ask why everyone has such great hatred towards the Footy Show? I know it's not top-line football reporting, but most AFL fans should reap some enjoyment from it.

[Fork 'em 6,943]

May I ask why everyone has such great hatred towards the Footy Show? I know it's not top-line football reporting, but most AFL fans should reap some enjoyment from it.

I find the humour juvenile and it's the only footy show that I won't watch .

Also hated the fact Maguire , and Newman would use it as their personal soapboxes .

Edited May 5, 2011 by Fork 'em

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,762]

May I ask why everyone has such great hatred towards the Footy Show? I know it's not top-line football reporting, but most AFL fans should reap some enjoyment from it.

It is horribly contrived and predictable comedy, executed poorly and has little to do with football. There are moments where they could be analysing a game or interviewing a player but we're still waiting for them to finish a joke we knew the punchline to a good hour and a half beforehand.

[Redleg 40,236]

I find the humour juvenile and it's the only footy show that I won't watch .

Also hated the fact Maguire , and Newman would use it as their personal soapboxes .

Agree 100%.

[Beetle 4,542]

It is horribly contrived and predictable comedy, executed poorly and has little to do with football. There are moments where they could be analysing a game or interviewing a player but we're still waiting for them to finish a joke we knew the punchline to a good hour and a half beforehand.

It's aimed at the bogan market.

[The Great One 99 125]

May I ask why everyone has such great hatred towards the Footy Show? I know it's not top-line football reporting, but most AFL fans should reap some enjoyment from it.

I agree that it has a fair bit of crap. I cant stand Craig Hutchinson, and oddly enough I think Gary Lyon is a [censored]. But I still find myself watching it most weeks. Basically because it is about football. However, I wont lose any sleep if I go to bed early or dont watch at all.

The show does seem to cop a lot of critisism. It seems that people that dont like it, need to tell others that they dont like it. Why? This is in general public, not just confined to this site.

[Supermercado 2,784]

Great urban legend about Brad Miller ringing a bloke up and him saying "You're the reason I didn't renew"

Presumably this was before Brad was with Pia or the comeback would have been obvious..

[Fork 'em 6,943]

I agree that it has a fair bit of crap. I cant stand Craig Hutchinson, and oddly enough I think Gary Lyon is a [censored].

Can't stand the parasite Hutchison either and also think Lyon is a [censored] . That hospital sketch he was involved with Crawford they did a few years ago was about the last straw . Lyons standing nose dived from there with me and for that reason shudder at the thought of him coaching (not that it will happen).

The show does seem to cop a lot of critisism. It seems that people that dont like it, need to tell others that they dont like it. Why?

Cause I was asked .

On the subject of receiving calls from players to renew membership . Geez , at times like these I'd love to receive 1 , ask them "What the F... is going on down there ?" I got 1 from a volunteer under danihers reign , after assuring him that I still intended to join I asked him if he saw the dribble we dished up the previous 2 games . "Your a Melbourne supporter" I told him , "You know how I feel." We ended up lamenting how disappointing we were together over the phone . Brothers in Arms .

Edited May 6, 2011 by Fork 'em

[diesel 420]

Anyway just interested because I wonder if there was anyone who had the guts to say why should I buy a membership when you guys are getting paid heaps & not performing.

I've done the phone thing for the club as a volunteer and it always amused me when people took that attitude. I alwys wanted to give them a critique of their support? I reckon they are the type of people who are happy to jump back on board in the good times whilst the supporters who stick fat keep the club going during lean times.

If I was doing it now I would just remind them that we are 20,000 members and about 3 million dollars behind Collingwood and of Ron's mantra, "if it is to be, it's up to me"

[Fork 'em 6,943]

I've done the phone thing for the club as a volunteer and it always amused me when people took that attitude. I alwys wanted to give them a critique of their support? I reckon they are the type of people who are happy to jump back on board in the good times whilst the supporters who stick fat keep the club going during lean times.

If I was doing it now I would just remind them that we are 20,000 members and about 3 million dollars behind Collingwood and of Ron's mantra, "if it is to be, it's up to me"

Let's face it . Collingwood fans get value for money , they've been up around it for years and I'm sure many of those extra 20,000 you speak have jumped on board during the last 2 . Do you think they're on the phones looking for lost members ?

Maybe they are , I don't know .

With our clubs record , I'm proud of the amount that do indeed stick fat .

We've put up with a hell of alot of mediocrity over the years and this year looks more of the same .

Jimmy wanted 40,000 members during the offseason , if they players had've produced some enthusiasm for the contest till now I'm sure he woulda got them but ..... No , momentum lost .