Best 18

[Trengove 0]

after we give everyone a chance to catch up with whats going on i think that'd be a good idea

[H_T 3,049]

Perfect! Do we set a time limit on picks to be taken otherwise it's a pass?

Cunning. I like it. But first all must be made aware. Oh, that is if it's ok with old55 anyway...

[old55 23,687]

Cunning. I like it. But first all must be made aware. Oh, that is if it's ok with old55 anyway...

Yeah I think once everyone is on board we could try a one day time limit, what do you think?

Make your selections in order in the thread so we can make sure they happen in the right order but keep a summary post up near the top with all your selections and players in position so so far - does this make sense?

It is going to take a while but we've got nothing better to do until the pre-season comp starts ...

[H_T 3,049]

Yeah I think once everyone is on board we could try a one day time limit, what do you think?

Make your selections in order in the thread so we can make sure they happen in the right order but keep a summary post up near the top with all your selections and players in position so so far - does this make sense?

It is going to take a while but we've got nothing better to do until the pre-season comp starts ...

Yes that makes sense.

[Deestroy All 14,266]

Sounds like a ridiculous waste of time to me.

Can't wait!

[ox_5 163]

Old I just realised you are not in the list of 10. I am happy to step aside if you want to have a crack. It was your idea after all!

[Carlos Danger 380]

Pick 2, impossible to look past the 3 time MVP. Gold Coast: Gary Ablett

B:

HB:

C: Ablett

HF:

F:

R:

[Eth 4]

To repeat my original post, does anyone want to make this full-scale?

I was thinking something like this. (BigFooty does have a lot of members but we only need 10-12 to kick it off, and I'm not sure how many teams they have.)

I reckon this would be really good, although considering there are 600+ players in the draft, we'd need very active members to kick it off before the season starts.

Anyone? I think it would be fun

[Range Rover 1,935]

I'm down for this!

Keeping my cards very close to my chest for my prized pick 6 ...

[e25 5]

Old I just realised you are not in the list of 10. I am happy to step aside if you want to have a crack. It was your idea after all!

I'm not opposed to a "last-in, first-out" policy.

Fair is fair.

[Roger Mellie 4,096]

Pick 3 - Geelong - Joel Selwood

R: Selwood,

Edited December 1, 2010 by High Tower

[Range Rover 1,935]

Pick 3 - Geelong - Joel Selwood

R: Sandilands, Selwood,

Hey Rog: Sandi or Joel - who's it going to be?

[Trengove 0]

Hey Rog: Sandi or Joel - who's it going to be?

I'll help him choose by taking Pick 4

Player number 31211... Fremantle Dockers... Aaron Sandilands

B:

HB:

C:

HF:

F:

Foll: Sandilands,

[Roger Mellie 4,096]

Apologies - I thought Sandilands was the first pick, but was just an example (from Old's earlier post) - read the thread now

Thanks Trengove

Edited November 30, 2010 by Roger Mellie

[Deestroy All 14,266]

Pick 5.

Player number v1$y - Carlton - Chris Judd

B:

HB:

C:

HF:

F:

R: - Judd

[Range Rover 1,935]

Round 1: Pick Number 6

Player Number 00069 - St Kilda - Brendan Goddard

B:

HB: Goddard

C:

HF:

F:

R:

[old55 23,687]

Old I just realised you are not in the list of 10. I am happy to step aside if you want to have a crack. It was your idea after all!

No worries, thanks - I'm happy to be independent administrator

[MrReims 322]

Damn, would have liked in on this.....

[H_T 3,049]

To repeat my original post, does anyone want to make this full-scale?

I was thinking something like this. (BigFooty does have a lot of members but we only need 10-12 to kick it off, and I'm not sure how many teams they have.)

I reckon this would be really good, although considering there are 600+ players in the draft, we'd need very active members to kick it off before the season starts.

Anyone? I think it would be fun

Full-scale ? Unsure eth38. Might be worth a try though. But for now I reckon we give old's best 18 a crack.

You can always try and start something before the 2011 season if you want.ie in off-season. Sent the master a PM, he might be the only one unaware.

[e25 5]

Is a whole 24 hours too long to wait?

Should we make it 12 hours from the last pick and if they miss that deadline they pass and take their pick at the end of the round?

(can you tell I'm getting impatient for my turn..?)

[H_T 3,049]

Is a whole 24 hours too long to wait?

Should we make it 12 hours from the last pick and if they miss that deadline they pass and take their pick at the end of the round?

(can you tell I'm getting impatient for my turn..?)

I think Round 1 was always going to take a little while. Thereafter once all are aware it could be quicker if everyone checks in now and then.

And you reckon you have a wait !

But I'm looking forward to the set of steak knives....

[Range Rover 1,935]

Is a whole 24 hours too long to wait?

Should we make it 12 hours from the last pick and if they miss that deadline they pass and take their pick at the end of the round?

(can you tell I'm getting impatient for my turn..?)

12 hours is better I agree. Perhaps if they miss then they pick 2 picks at their next turn? If they miss that chance then they forfeit?

[old55 23,687]

12 hours is better I agree. Perhaps if they miss then they pick 2 picks at their next turn? If they miss that chance then they forfeit?

Patience kids, after the first round, 24 hours it is, some people only have a certain window each day.

Agree with the idea of 2 picks next round and if they don't show at that pick it's out.

[titan_uranus 25,042]

Argh, I wish I was in on this...

Should be interesting to see what the teams end up looking like.

[e25 5]

I agree.

Only having a small window is understandable.

Maybe to preserve the integrity of the draft, if they miss the 2 picks then the position is offered up to other posters who aren't participating but wish to assume the role.

We're better off with those that are committed, otherwise everyone will get frustrated.