6. Sylvia

5. Jamar

4. McKenzie

3. Watts

2. Garland

1. Scully

6- Sylvia

5- Jamar

4- McKenzie

3- Garland

2- Scully

1- Watts

6. Sylvia

5. McKenzie

4. Bartram

3. Garland

2. Jamar

1. Frawley

Apologies to Bruce as his footskills were great today and was an excellent runner.

Amazing to see Jordie didn't get in the HUN best players, you have to ask the question; do these Journos actually watch the game?

I listened to it and they callers on SEN thought he was excellent.

Amazing to see Jordie didn't get in the HUN best players, you have to ask the question; do these Journos actually watch the game?

I listened to it and they callers on SEN thought he was excellent.

6 - Garland

5 - Sylvia

4 - Jamar

3 - McKenzie

2 - Bartram

1 - Frawley

When the game got close I found myself saying on a number of occasions "thank God for Garland". It wasn't just him beating Fev early, it was his ability to get it and use it when the Lions were all attack in the second half.

Based on SEN (surprisingly average call):

6 - Sylvia

5 - McKenzie

4 - Frawley

3 - MacDonald

2 - Jamar

1 - Watts

Hard to know after the first two based only on the radio. But I'll definitely get around to watching the replay on the Game Analyser some time this week.

6. Colin Sylvia

5. Colin Garland

4. Jordie McKenzie

3. Jared Rivers

2. Joel Macdonald

1. Mark Jamar

6 - Sylvia

5 - Scully

4 - Davey

3 - Garland

2 - Watts

1 - Dunn

6. Syliva (clear standout..also his goal busting through the pack was a thing of beauty)

5. Garland (MONSTER effort, who stands a chance at getting a clean pair of hands on the pill when this guy is on song?)

4. McKenzie (handled the slippery conditions as good as anyone out there)

3. Jamar (usual candidate)

2. Frawley (ditto)

1. Dunn (showed great composure when needed)

Apolgoies to Bartram. He's moulded himself into a key part of our defence and once again produced some great head over the footy stuff but his poor disposal was a bit more noticeable than last week.

6. Sylvia

5. Dunn

4. Garland

3. Bartram

2. Mckenzie

1. Watts

I'd give everyone a vote if I could.

seriously Watts did not deserve the votes he is getting

Most frustrating thing with Watts is his reluctance to kick it through the big sticks! But with time will come confidence. He's still doing some great things.

6. Sylvia

5. McKenzie

4. Garland

3. Watts

2. Scully

1. Davey

1. Sylvia

2. Garland

3. MacDonald

4. Scully

5. Frawley

6. Watts

1. Sylvia
   
2. Frawley
   
3. MacDonald
   
4. Garland
   
5. McKenzie
   
6. Bartram
   

A game for the backmen to earn votes. Afraid we got smashed in clearances and up forward, so Sylvia & Jordie were stand outs for us in the middle. Geez we missed Beamer. Good to see Watts up there in the possessions. Dunn & Ossie were also good to see. Loved PJ's confident goal from a tap.

seriously Watts did not deserve the votes he is getting

He was by far our hardest working forward. His second efforts were excellent and he covered a hell of a lot of ground.

For a 196cm player to get 27 disposals in the rain, is an excellent showing and deserves recognition.

6. Sylvia

5. Frawley

4. McKenzie

3. Rivers

2. Macdonald

1. Bail

6. Sylvia

5. MacKenzie

4. Garland

3. Bartram

2. Jamar

1. Watts

6. Sylvia - got on him for 1st goal scorer - nice odds too!

5. McKenzie - GUN. When he adds more muscle, he will be downright scary.

4. Garland - great suffocating game. Copped a headlock from Fev early, and drew the ire of the Lions fans.

3. Jamar - Must be AA if they pick 2 ruckmen.

2. Dunn - finally allowed to play in his natural position.

1. Frawley - Kept Brown very quiet, also provided some good rebound.

Apologies to Scully, Watts, Bartram, MacDonald and Bail.

EDIT: Forgot Joel MacDonald.

Edited August 2, 201015 yr by Dr. Mubutu

6. Sylvia

5. McKenzie

4. Garland

3. Jamar

2. MacDonald

1. Frawley

Edit: wrong Mc /Mac .......

Edited August 2, 201015 yr by Deeoldfart

6. Sylvia

5. Macdonald

4. Garland

3. Jamar

2. Mckenzie

1. Watts

Anyone who did not have J MAC are seriosuly kidding, surely??

6 Sylvia

5 Mckenzie

4 Garland

3 Jamar

2 Bartram

1 Davey

6 Sylvia

5 Macdonald

4 Garland

3 Jamar

2 Frawley (Killed Brown again. Who'd have thought, in the last couple of years, we would have the answer to J Brown twice in a year in 2010. Has to be in AA consideration.)

1 Bartram

I found the coaches' votes pretty interesting.

Brisbane Lions v Melbourne

10 Colin Sylvia (Melb)

7 Michael Rischitelli (Bris)

4 James Frawley (Melb)

3 Mark Jamar (Melb)

2 Jordie McKenzie (Melb)

2 Albert Proud (Bris)

1 Tom Scully (Melb)

1 Clint Bartram (Melb)

Now I'm never very good with this, but as far as I can gather it seems that one coach gave Rischitelli 4 and the other 3, with the person who gave him 3 giving Frawley 4, but the coach who gave him 4 gave 3 to Jamar.

Perhaps Voss knows that Brown is no where near his best and therefore didn't include him?

WTF no Garland? Judy was awesome on Sat. Weird.