Scorpions v Zebras Schizophrenia Match

[DeeM 42]

Nathan Carroll reported for charging in the third quarter.

Thoughts?

[w00dy 146]

gee that was a painful quarter.. how about we try not kicking it to the defender in q3?

Shane Valenti just ran all the way from full forward to the wing to chase a tackle... just shows how much this bloke works...

i saw him take off, casey were away... heading down the wing, i don't know why he even bothered in the first place, most footballers wouldn't even think about it... but he sprinted 80 metres, the casey player fumbled, he got to the ball, made a contest and won the ball for sandy...

Carroll just charged straight into a blokes back as he was taking a mark... stupid!

[w00dy 146]

Nathan Carroll reported for charging in the third quarter.

Thoughts?

I reckon he'll get 2 weeks for charging ... video looked quite bad ... wasn't anywhere near the marking contest, so decided just to cannon straight into his back.

Having said that I don't think it should be a reportable incident ... no real chance of injuring the player, 50 metres should be sufficient...

[jabberwocky 2,301]

No Whelan.

which might mean no Davey tomorrow.

[beelzebub 22,271]

Thoughts?

I think someone has read the writing on the wall.. but its taken him this long to understand it. Not doing himself any favours... but might be doing us one !!

[w00dy 146]

russian just took a big mark over some poor blokes back...

7 kicks, 10 handballs and 10 marks for the big fella... i doubt any of his kicks have been effective though...

[beelzebub 22,271]

I used to think Jamar might have a littel somethign going for him. I dont anymore. He is a liability on your side. No awareness whatso ever..and has no idea of how or where to kick a ball.. great skills for a player huh !!

[themasta 0]

Carroll wouldn't have gotten a chance in the seniors next week the way he's played anyway...

[Kiss of Death 708]

Valenti = gun

and what on earth was Crowe supposed to do in that situation before? anybody have a silver platter?

[beelzebub 22,271]

Valenti = gun

and what on earth was Crowe supposed to do in that situation before? anybody have a silver platter?

that ump wins tool of the week for sure.. same one I think gave the 50 against Meeson.. how many millisecs too slow was he..ffs !! a clown

[beelzebub 22,271]

Carrol.. and im not trying to find things. but its something ive been pondering for a while...he really cant handball for [censored] canhe.. always a looping one..always putting the recipient under the pump. ..Hardly what you want.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Shane Valenti just ran all the way from full forward to the wing to chase a tackle... just shows how much this bloke works...

i saw him take off, casey were away... heading down the wing, i don't know why he even bothered in the first place, most footballers wouldn't even think about it... but he sprinted 80 metres, the casey player fumbled, he got to the ball, made a contest and won the ball for sandy...

Carroll just charged straight into a blokes back as he was taking a mark... stupid!

the more i see of valenti the more i like him. he is very creative, esp with his handball in close. reminds me of Sam Mitchell. Given some chances I think he will cut it. I like the look of Martin, looks pretty athletic for a big man, coughs it up a bit but I think he'll be OK.

[Mono 454]

Valenti = gun

Very disappointed he isn't in the MFC team tomorrow. A perfect replacement for Moloney. :angry: :angry:

[Bay Riffin 1,426]

the more i see of valenti the more i like him. he is very creative, esp with his handball in close. reminds me of Sam Mitchell. Given some chances I think he will cut it. I like the look of Martin, looks pretty athletic for a big man, coughs it up a bit but I think he'll be OK.

Thought Martin was very good today down back. Like the look of him and always seemed in control of the one on one contests. I think I swa him outmarked once but beat blokes like top 10 pick Ben McEvoy easily.

[Yze_Magic 3]

Will we see Carroll in the Red and Blue again?

he will get 2 or 3 weeks for the charge, then he will have to fight his way back into the side vis Sandy. By then there will only be a few weeks left in the season.

I am sure a lot of people want Carroll on the scrap heap, but in my mind he has always been a guy that should be a 3rd tall defender, not the main man. With the develiopment of Garland and Warnock, I would like to see Carroll reatined next season as a 3rd back than will not ahve to take on the main big forwards of the opposition.

i think he could ve very good in that role.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Will we see Carroll in the Red and Blue again?

he will get 2 or 3 weeks for the charge, then he will have to fight his way back into the side vis Sandy. By then there will only be a few weeks left in the season.

I am sure a lot of people want Carroll on the scrap heap, but in my mind he has always been a guy that should be a 3rd tall defender, not the main man. With the develiopment of Garland and Warnock, I would like to see Carroll reatined next season as a 3rd back than will not ahve to take on the main big forwards of the opposition.

i think he could ve very good in that role.

I reckon it all depends on how much the other guys begin to rebound. It is great to have pure stoppers in your side but you need guys capable of being attacking as well.

[titan_uranus 22,724]

which might mean no Davey tomorrow.

Yeah I reckon you're right. Davey mustn't be fully fit so they've left out one emergency in case.

I watched most of the match today: Sandy were shocking. They turned it over repeatedly by foot and there was no real focal target up forward.

Daniel Bell looked alright, but I'm no expert.

[titan_uranus 22,724]

Looks like he'll be missing for a couple of weeks. Was quite stupid.

[beelzebub 22,271]

went beyond "quite" !!

[Jaded No More 58,821]

Final scores for those of us who spent the whole day studying for exams....??

[whelan45 202]

Seniors

Casey Scorpions 2.2 5.3 8.5 14.7 (91)

Sandringham 3.2 4.4 6.11 8.11 (59)

I have been studying all day but the little I saw I liked what Cheney did.

Reserves

Sandringham 1.2 7.8 9.10 19.14 (128)

Casey Scorpions 3.2 4.4 8.8 9.10 (64)

Petterd best on in ressies good to see. Also good news Newton is back. Mcnamara in best as well

[Beach Road Bazza 0]

A very much undermanned Sandringham side started well but was outgunned by the Casey Scorpions out at Casey Fields to lose by 32 points in what ended as a disappointing afternoon for the club. Daniel Bell and Shane Valenti were the best performers from the Demon pojnt of view and Kyle Cheney put in a very encouraging effort. As stated elsewhere, Nathan Carroll was booked for charging his opponent in the third quarter.

Sandringham 3.2.20 4.4.28 6.11.47 8.11.59

Casey Scorpions 2.2.14 5.3.33 8.5.53 14.7.91

Goals

Sandringham Biddlecombe Valenti 2 Buckley Crowe Dean Zomer

Casey Scorpions Allen 4 Armitage Rix 2 Fisher Howard Matthews Panozza Parker Waite

Best

Sandringham Biddlecombe Bell Valenti Summers Cheney Crowe

Casey Scorpions Armitage Silvagni Rix Matthews Panozza Allen

The Reserves had a comfortable victory after a 10 goal final quarter in a game that saw Michael Newton come back from a string of injuries that have hampered his season to date. He booted four goals. Ricky Petterd, also on the comeback trail, was best on the ground in his second game at this level - both against the Scorpions in consecutive weeks.

Sandringham 1.2.8 7.8.50 9.10.64 19.14.128

Casey Scorpions 3.2.20 4.4.28 8.8.56 9.10.64

Goals

Sandringham Lockwood 5 Newton 4 Cleeve Monaghan 2 Kondarovskis B Liddell Petterd Sargent Summons Weetra

Casey Scorpions Mercoulia 3 Galvin 2 Fridman Leung Mohr Williams

Best

Sandringham Petterd Monaghan McNamara Newton Lockwood Hardiman

Casey Scorpions Galvin Mercoulia Youle Terry Fridman Crespin

[Jaded No More 58,821]

Thanks!

Newton with 4 on return and Petterd in the best. Excellent news.

Hope to see them both in Sandy seniors next week.

For people who watched the game, can we get a review of that list of 'best' players, as usually reality varies greatly from the match report.

Cheers.

[Beach Road Bazza 0]

For people who watched the game, can we get a review of that list of 'best' players, as usually reality varies greatly from the match report.

I think they have the best players right this time Jaded but it should be noted that the team played well below its usual standards so getting in the best players today doesn't mean a great deal. I'll have more to say in my report which I'll try to get written up tomorrow.

[sylvinator 96]

Will we see Carroll in the Red and Blue again?

I am sure a lot of people want Carroll on the scrap heap, but in my mind he has always been a guy that should be a 3rd tall defender,

Y.M, obviously u didn't watch the sandy game today. Carrol was S.H.I.T.E. he consistently turned it over, and had goals kicked regularly on him. he gave away 2 fifty metre penalties which cost goals. 4 times he tried to spoil, missed it, and that led to goals.

He is PATHETIC and i thank our lucky stars that finally we have some good young KPP so that he can be delisted at years end. he's sooo bad.

Also, his report was soft and he 100% will be cleared for it. he hardly touched the guy tho it was a bit late into his back. worth a free kick n no more.

I love Valenti. gets the number 1 tag each week. he's too good for vfl. Buckley ok also. Zomer took 3 really strong marks i liked. Cheney also looks Very promising. i like the look of him. neat skills and good tackling.

all in all, the game was pathetic quality and it was 3rd v 4th on the ladder. crap skills and crap game. anyone who thinks the best vfl team would have a chance against the worst afl team has NO IDEA