Adzman

A brayshaw or Trengove in for Hannan would have given Goodwin some more flexibility. Against the tigers we will need this. In: Hogan, Hibberd, Trengove out: Weed, Melksham, Hannan

Too early to put in a request for a priority pick

If you both want to look at idiotic examples that's your choice. I was responding to the Thread instead of throwing shade. They will play similar game numbers, Lewis will be more decorated due to the flag. That will give him the edge. Both of your comparisons are ludicrous and a waste of time.

Lewis won a flag in 2012, so as far as his career goes he will be the most decorated of the 3. Love Nev, but if we can't get him a flag then Lewis has had the better career. Nev has also played less footy, and you would think Lewis will end up playing more games for his career when it is all said and done.

Love the local sporting globe. The only issue is you won't be catching any footy if the ufc is on. The sporting globe attracts every man and his dog for the ufc which is on nearly every screen. With Hogan and lewis' antics perhaps we are the most aggressive show in town anyway...

Interested to see how Maynard and Philipovic go. Our rookie list is loaded with projects, and it would be pleasing for another player to push for senior selection later in the year* *provided the club is in a position to elevate

I'm glad he will get a chance. I hope Spencer goes well, it could lead to a #1 ruck role at another club next season if he goes well.

I think Plugga Lockett was the king of takeaways when he was playing. Pizza, fish and chips, kebabs...

Sad to hear that. Seems to be a growing trend in the VFL for those standalone clubs. Hopefully they can be rescued

I'm glad we waited for his body to get right before cutting him. Looks like a star in the making. Toss up between Hunt and Clarry as to who will be the best player on the list in 2 years time,

If he was 24 with a ceiling then I would say yes. At 28 I think he has reached his potential and will not be the piece of the puzzle that takes us forward.

Hamish might struggle to get on a list unless he can tear the house down. Was overlooked last season.Andrew is supposed to be as good as Gus and should get drafted.

Oddly enough I think we will have a youngish list next season. If you look at the potential players who might not be on the list next season, and replace them again with kids then we might be in the bottom 3 for age and experience again. Trengove: 26 Spencer: 28 Pedersen: 30 Kennedy: 23 Jkh: 22 I'm not suggesting all won't be here, but some of those cuts could come from this list. Replace them with 18yo again and we are right back in the bottom 3 for age.

Pull the trade Lever!

Paddy could end up being an All Australian forward, but Petracca is next level. He has the same mystique about him that O'meara had before he had all of those injuries. Paddy will be a very good player, Petracca could be something very special.

I never get carried away with a win. We haven't won a flag during my entire life, until that happens I will remain pessimistic when it comes to our premiership chances.

If Frosty is fit does he come in for Smith? Our backline stocks have taken a hammering already.

Thanks for the reminder. I completely forgot Georgiou even existed!

Silver lining: Bernie will come into the side round 3 after some rest. His previous record cost him here. There was nothing in it, but once your card is marked there isn't anything you can do about it.

Not even Sean Charles himself would agree with that statement! Certainly not a serious statement.

I wish Clarry moved like shinkansen! I have him more in the "James" from Thomas the tank engine category. More of a solid worker than a jet.

Vince might cop one week and Smith will miss extended time. Dom Tyson might come in if Vince misses. Hopefully Wagner is good to go because we could use him.

His debut will make it harder on Dean Kent/Jkh/Harmes/Bugg to come into the side. I honestly didn't see that coming after round 1! He was fantastic!!

I'm sick of hearing about Rioli. He is a poor man's Sean Charles in my opinion.....

Jkh is hurt more often than he isn't. Poor guy just can't stay on the park.