The Price of Chris Judd

[mo64 5,505]

It's fair to say that we would have had to give up picks 4, 14(TJ) and 21 for Chris Judd, given that Carlton gave up 3, Kennedy and 22.

We now know that Cale Morton, Jack Grimes and Addam Maric were the price that we would have paid for Judd, and only time will tell how good they will be.

Of course there are immediate financial benefits of picking up Judd, but the downside is salary cap pressure over the years of his contract.

But purely from a list perspective, i'm not unhappy that we didn't get Judd.

[Yze_Magic 3]

Morton, Grimes and Maric > the entire Carlton list including Chris Dudd

[occo 2]

concidering WCE wanted Frawley or pettard and pick 4,21 and someone else i was never happy to get judd. I say again 1 PLAYER WILL NEVER WIN U GAMES

[old55 22,853]

The real price is what the Eagles got - Kennedy, Masten, Notte - give it 3-5 years.

[Yencks 8]

Morton, Grimes and Maric > the entire Carlton list including Chris Dudd

dont leave out cheney and mcnamara...CAC's little secrets

[Little Goffy 14,058]

The real price is what the Eagles got - Kennedy, Masten, Notte - give it 3-5 years.

Well, now we get into economic semantics!

Kennedy, Masten and Notte are what Eagles got for Judd.

Pick 3, 22 and Kennedy we're the price that Carlton paid for him.

Pick 4, 14 (or a player, eg Petterd) and 21 would have been the price we would have had to pay for him.

But it's a fair call that if we get more out of Morton, Grimes and Maric combined than Carlton get out of Judd, then we've come out winners in the end!

I'd argue that the extra funds off the field will be balanced by the on-field tension as the salary cap constricts around the futures of Carlton's young guns.

Also, if the Golden Groin doesn't hold up, or any other serious injury leaves Judd omitted or unale to play at full capacity, then the Judd trade will have done almost as much damage to Carlton as the salary cap breaches.

And if, by some cosmic intervention, the arrivial of Judd doesn't suddenly make everyone on Carlton's list 20% faster, 20% fitter, 20% more skilled and 100% better at working as a team, then they'll still be rooted anyway.

[sylvinator 96]

dont leave out cheney and mcnamara...CAC's little secrets

it seemed that CAC always had his heart set on Cheney so he must be something in him.

McNamara may be a very good get, but he was actually rated by most clubs pre-draft, so its quite surprising he slipped so far. mid year, alot of people considered him a first rounder

[the fork 357]

it seemed that CAC always had his heart set on Cheney so he must be something in him.

McNamara may be a very good get, but he was actually rated by most clubs pre-draft, so its quite surprising he slipped so far. mid year, alot of people considered him a first rounder

Named by afl insider as one of the Top 8 steals of the draft.

66 Melbourne - Tom McNamara

The back line for Melbourne in 2007 was in disarray, but with this draft and a few players returning from injury it could turn into a strength. McNamara went very late, but he could be playing AFL a lot quicker than some of the high picks.

[Hannabal 4]

dont leave out cheney and mcnamara...CAC's little secrets

They were far from secrets.

[Little Goffy 14,058]

They were far from secrets.

McNamara was a little, I get the impression he was overlooked a bit because he skipped the Draft Camp.

It's hard to see how an under16 & under 18 All-Australian got missed until pick 66.

Nothing to do with Judd, though!

[Luck Lucy 0]

McNamara was a little, I get the impression he was overlooked a bit because he skipped the Draft Camp.

It's hard to see how an under16 & under 18 All-Australian got missed until pick 66.

Nothing to do with Judd, though!

The real price of Judd was the $7.5m that we would have had to fork over to get his services plus we would have had to find a benefactor to employ him as our environmental spokesperson while one of our sponsors flogs petrol guzzling cars that emit gasses into the atmosphere that will ultimately destroy the ozone layer. It's OK for Carlton to pay that sort of money when Mr. Cartel can write out a cheque for a record law breaking fine of $38m but could we afford to do it given how our list is made up?

[Demon Head 266]

The real price of Judd was the $7.5m that we would have had to fork over to get his services plus we would have had to find a benefactor to employ him as our environmental spokesperson while one of our sponsors flogs petrol guzzling cars that emit gasses into the atmosphere that will ultimately destroy the ozone layer. It's OK for Carlton to pay that sort of money when Mr. Cartel can write out a cheque for a record law breaking fine of $38m but could we afford to do it given how our list is made up?

Point well made. We should all get over Judd anyway. He plays for an opposition club and that's that!

[Redleg 40,228]

The real price is what the Eagles got - Kennedy, Masten, Notte - give it 3-5 years.

That is not the price, that is what they spent "their" money on. The price is what "we" would have paid.

Given that it probably would have been picks 4, 14 and 21, then it it would have been too much for me, way too much.

[Redleg 40,228]

And if, by some cosmic intervention, the arrivial of Judd doesn't suddenly make everyone on Carlton's list 20% faster, 20% fitter, 20% more skilled and 100% better at working as a team, then they'll still be rooted anyway.

Nor does his arrival give them a backline.

[Little Goffy 14,058]

Nor does his arrival give them a backline.

Heh heh.

Three years ago Carlton supporters were talking about how they had this great spine and it would set them up for years. Even then they had Whitnall as a full-time CHF and CHB. And their midfield was a wreck with zero depth.

Now they'll tell you they have the greatest midfield ever assembled... it's just a shame they have zero depth in their key positions.

They haven't even come full circle - they've just stood on one spot and faced the other way.