Comings and Goings.

[grazman 6,636]

At this Stage we have:

IN: Dean Bailey

Retired: Pickett, Brown and Bizzell

Picks: 4, 21, 37, 53, 69, 85. PSD pick 3 & 19

[WonnaJurah 5]

how many more players have to go from our side before draft?

[Yze_Magic 3]

Pick 4 - Brad Ebert

[grazman 6,636]

how many more players have to go from our side before draft?

You only have to draft three, so technically no one else... but you'd have to think Bode is a monty to be promoted. I'd expect at least another four or five delistings/trades.

[grazman 6,636]

Pick 4 - Brad Ebert

or Henderson or McEvoy or Morton, or Palmer, or .... it'll be a very good player.

[WonnaJurah 5]

You only have to draft three, so technically no one else... but you'd have to think Bode is a monty to be promoted. I'd expect at least another four or five delistings/trades.

warnock,jamar,neville, ferguson

[grazman 6,636]

warnock,jamar,neville, ferguson

Warnock's still contracted for another year I think.... Danny Ward might be under the pump.

[Jerry Lundergard 392]

Ward........Gaaawwwwwnnnnnnnn!!!!! Surely.

[WonnaJurah 5]

think he stay only missed 4 this year

cj borderline as well

[deestroy08 0]

Just throwing this one in there but what about trading Bate?

[grazman 6,636]

Ward........Gaaawwwwwnnnnnnnn!!!!! Surely.

Betts kicking five won't have helped his claims.

[grazman 6,636]

Just throwing this one in there but what about trading Bate?

NO!

[WonnaJurah 5]

Just throwing this one in there but what about trading Bate?

arghhh

[Yze_Magic 3]

Just throwing this one in there but what about trading Bate?

ROFL

[deestroy08 0]

Haha ok!

.. just putting it out there.

[sylvinator 96]

NO!

what is the point of trading bate. he is one of 3 youngsters on our list who has the potential to be an A-grader (along with mclean and sylvia). if we trade him, for say pick 15ish, we simply pick up a kid who might also have the potential to be an A-grader, or could be a miss and turn out shite.

just makes no sense to trade one of your most talented youngsters with a huge upside who is only 20 yrs old.

pick 4 pick hopefully be Cale Morton is he slips through (he could be pick 1).

if not Morton, then we could go Palmer, Ebert, Masten (i.e. a highly rated midfielder) or we could go for the best key position prospect in the draft in Henderson.

[Jaded No More 59,067]

pick 4 pick hopefully be Cale Morton is he slips through (he could be pick 1).

if not Morton, then we could go Palmer, Ebert, Masten (i.e. a highly rated midfielder) or we could go for the best key position prospect in the draft in Henderson.

PACE... we are desperate for some pace both through the middle, and out of the backline. Especially if when they give Ward the boot.

Bartram's return will help us a lot, but that's still not enough.

[mo64 5,245]

Surely Godfrey has to be axed.

[grazman 6,636]

what is the point of trading bate. he is one of 3 youngsters on our list who has the potential to be an A-grader (along with mclean and sylvia). if we trade him, for say pick 15ish, we simply pick up a kid who might also have the potential to be an A-grader, or could be a miss and turn out shite.

just makes no sense to trade one of your most talented youngsters with a huge upside who is only 20 yrs old.

pick 4 pick hopefully be Cale Morton is he slips through (he could be pick 1).

if not Morton, then we could go Palmer, Ebert, Masten (i.e. a highly rated midfielder) or we could go for the best key position prospect in the draft in Henderson.

I have no idea who we will pick, Kreuser and Cotchin will be the top 2, who Carlton grabs at three will be interesting...but I've heard some good things about Henderson.... I'd also like to trade to get at least one more top ten pick to get another midfielder, but that obviously means giving up some quality.

[demoniac 1,243]

! - Initial Delistings/Retirements

Already Retired (3)

Brown, Bizzell, Pickett

Should retire (2)

We've just finished 3rd last, Ward and Holland are both 30. For mine they shouldn't be kept.

Holland - Slow,2 grab mark and an average kick.

Ward - Quick and runs hard but disposal and decision making let him down.

Delist (3)

Ferguson - 26, 5 years on the list, courageous but not AFL standard.

Godfrey - 26, 8 years on the list, has got the best out of his talents but disposal and decision making not AFL standard.

Warnock - 23, 3 years (?) on list, a good VFL player but not AFL standard.

Neville - 20 in February 08, has had injuries, maybe a candidate for delisting and rookie listing.

List After Initial Retirements/Delistings

25 and under in 2008

Bartram, Bate, Bell, Bode, Buckley, Davey, Dunn, Frawley, Garland, Jamar, C Johnson, P Johnson, Jones, Maclean, Miller, Moloney, Newton, Petterd, Rivers, Sylvia, Weetra,

26 and older in 2008 ( - 2008 Birthday)

Bruce - 29 in Sept, Carroll - 28 in October, Green - 27 in March, Johnstone - 28 in July, McDonald - 32 in October, Neitz - 33 in January, Robertson - 30 in November, Wheatley - 27 in April, Whelan - 29 in November, White - 31 in February, Yze - 31 in September.

Trade Bait.

We've just finished 3rd last. We have some good talent under 25. If we want to get extra picks in the Top 10 or Top 20 to add to that under 25 talent base then the players on our list who may unlock that are Bruce, Green and Johnstone. All have talent but have not displayed it consistently. If we have to wait for a spine consisting of Frawley, Dunn, Newton, maybe Garland to mature before we can have a serious crack at a flag are those 3 going to be part if it. If not then are we not better of seeing if they can unlock a Top 10/20 pick?

[occo 2]

U got most of that right. I love Godfrey but enough is enough and MFC need to look forward. This means that we must get rid of him.

Holland has shown some accuracy infront of goals this year but again too slow. Same as ward. I think its time to flood that defence with younger players. I disagree with your comment over Warnock...i think he has shown some glimpses and next year is still rebuilding in my opinion so lets replace Holland or Ward with Warnock.

I wont comment on Neville cause i havnt really watched any of him so ill leave it up to others.

As for trades: this will sound harsh but it needs to be done:

Robbo- Late 3rd rounder, early 4th

Bruce - Late 2nd early 3rd rounder

TJ - Late 2nd early 3rd rounder

Hopeful team lineup 2009: Bartram

B: Carroll ? Bell

HB: Rivers Frawley Pettard

C: Green Jones Dunn

HF: Bate ? Sylvia

F: Davey Newton ?

R: ? McLean Moloney

I.C: Bartram, P.Johnson, ?, ?

[Pates 9,537]

Surely Godfrey has to be axed.

I'd keep him on as depth, Batram's injury run this year shows that it's handy to have a backup and Godfrey has done pretty well this year.

The people i think should be on the move are:

Miller (Trade/Delist)

Ward (Delist)

Fergs (Trade/Delist)

CJ (Trade)

Jamar (Trade)

[Demon Disciple 11,132]

or Henderson or McEvoy or Morton, or Palmer, or .... it'll be a very good player.

We have to get another pick in the top 10, pick 6-10 and hopefully closer to 6. We need to get a quick midfielder and a tall forward or back. We need to aim for Henderson and Ebert (Cotchin won't be around at pick 4).

of the teams behind us on picks:

#5 Bulldogs

#6 The Scum

#7 Freo

#8 Lions

Freo will be the one more willing to give away the pick, given they believe there time is now.

The dogs, Bombers and Lions will all go for the youth option.

With this in mind, i reckon we should target Henderson with the #4 pick (as the Dogs will get him if he's there), then if we get another top 10 pick, go after our quick midfielder (hopefully Ebert). We'd then have pick 21, where we could draft a ruckman or maybe get Selwood if he's still around (but i doubt it).

[Geddy Lee 582]

Ward and CJ are gone. Keep Godders and Ferg.

[Demon Disciple 11,132]

I'd also like to trade to get at least one more top ten pick to get another midfielder, but that obviously means giving up some quality.

Yes that's the downside, you gotta trade quality to get quality. But lets be realistic, i don't think we will be a serious contender until 2009, or even later

The likes of Johnstone (great game today), Bruce, Green could provide us that first round pick we need to chase.