39 minutes ago, Ted Lasso said:

Pick 6, the Suns 2026 First round pick and Sam Flanders

for

Christian Petracca and pick 23

feels like a win-win, Trac helps the Suns win now, Dees add 3 good young players to the already exciting young core and strengthen our draft hand significantly

That's a much better deal than Trac for pick 6 and Flanders.

we had months of this BS last year

I’m going to ignore until something actually happens or is said

At the moment journos are quoting a Tom Morris nonsense vague tweet as a source for their articles!

A key factor, and i think likely a deal breaker, in any potential tracc trade is his salary.

The article posted above says it's currently 1.7 million a year and going forward doesn't drop below 1.2 million a year.

Tracc is still star and had a good season as evidenced by his bluey result and CD player rating.

But even the biggest tracc fan would concede that his 2025 form was still miles from his very best form and there were few, if any, examples of his ability to turn a game on his head and win it off his own boot.

And I don't think it's unfair to say his injury is still a factor psychologically, which is totally understandable by the way.

À club paying a player 1.2 million a season want AA level output. Tracc wasn't close to that this season.

Sure, he might get back to that level but does a club want to take 1.2 million a year punt on a bloke pushing 30?

Perhaps a gold coast might for the star factor, but even if one of the current top 4 clubs wanted to take that punt one of the reasons those teams are successful is they already have stars on big contracts. How is say the crows going to fit 1.2 million in their salary cap when they are shelling out big coin for Rankin et al.

I guess walker might retire and that would free up some salary cap space, but young guns like Philthorpe are gonna want a big pay rise at some point.

All a long way of saying that realistically if tracc wants to go to a team with a genuine chance of winning a premiership next season he is very likely going to have to take a sizable haircut salary wise.

At this point in his career does he really want to do that?

Edited September 16Sep 16 by binman

18 minutes ago, binman said:

A key factor, and i think likely a deal breaker, in any potential traac trade is his salary.

The article posted above says it's currently 1.7 million a year and going forward doesn't drop below 1.2 million a year.

Tracc is still star and had a good season as evidenced by his bluey result and CD player rating.

But even the biggest tracc fan would concede that his 2025 form was still miles from his very best form and there were few, if any, examples of his ability to turn a game on his head and win it off his own boot.

And I don't think it's unfair to say his injury is still a factor psychologically, which is total understandable by the way.

À club paying a player 1.2 million a season they want an AA level output. Tracc wasn't close to that this season.

Sure he might get back to that level but does a club want to take 1.2 million a year punt on a bloke pushing 30?

Perhaps a gold coast might forvthecsysr factor, but even if one of the current top 4 clubs wanted to take that punt one of the reasons those teams are successful is they have syars on big contracts. How is say the crows going to fit 1.2 million in their salary cap when they are shelling out big coin for rankin et al.

I guess walker might retire and thst would free up some salary cap space, but young guns like Philthorpe are gonna want a big pay rise at some point.

All a long way of saying that realistically if tracc wants t9 go to a team with genuine chanced of winning a premiership next season he is very likely going to have to take a sizable haircut salary wise.

At this point in his career does he really want to do that?

Lets just say GC offer up pick 6 and Sam Flanders. I've little doubt we'd be on the hook for upto $400K of his salary. I wouldn't expect Tracc would be taking a paycut. I'm actually ok with that as he clearly would prefer to move on or he and his manger could do would Clayton and his just did. To me he's a petulant man child who at his best can destroy a game of football but his bravery his been dented (totally understandably so) but his petulance remains. I'm now fully in the trade him out camp.

And yes I'm going to Boo him.......I always boo with a smile as it's quite ridiculous to boo a Champion but here we are!

Whilst my view is I want Christian to stay if he can't give a full commitment & wants a fresh start we could cash in with high end draft picks Gold Coast have picks 6 13 & 16 Sydney pick 9 & Adelaide pick 14 if he's open to a move interstate as has been reported definitely something to consider!

8 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

And yes I'm going to Boo him.......I always boo with a smile as it's quite ridiculous to boo a Champion but here we are!

Someone that leaves the club in this way over the past 2 years can 100% be Boo'd

“Pick 6, the Suns 2026 First round pick and Sam Flanders for Christian Petracca and pick 23”

Ummmm

Would the Suns have cap space ?

Would they effectively give up Flanders for “23”, and

Would Petracca be able take them to the promised land of a premiership?

Christian has to consider how to change his cooking style from modern Mediterranean to beachside chic … prawn cocktails and grilled barramundi!!!

1 hour ago, john delosa said:

Some blokes shout their love of the club, others just grind through pain and still finish 2nd in the B&F. Trac’s never been one for spin. If that’s not investment, I’m not sure what is!

And others trip over themselves....

We're yet to find out.

Would I like to to see a dynamic imposing Petracca as of old ? For sure

Getting excited about a 2nd in b/f is marvellous, unless you take a few steps back consider this is a team that overwhelmingly underachieved. Saying this has relevance as it puts perspective back into play. He went ok.. but there were games where applying a more generic AFL filter they were only so-so. He undoubtedly did well by the coach's metrics and thats what rules the b/f. The overseer of those criteria and assessment is out the door. Take from that what you may.

He's not the match winner he was. I get why that might be, but what is...IS.

In reality I'm pretty ambivalent towards his staying. Clarry for all his faults seems to genuinely want to be a Dee , play well and contribute. I don't see him getting sookilala.

Without doubt King needs to parlay with both and assess. If they stay/stay go/stay stay/go go/go I'm fine with that as I will be thinking discussion has lead to decision and we all move on.

I didn't attend the Bluey but am told appearances can be deceptive and... watch this space. Some eyebrows were raised... others just quietly nodded to selves

Sep29.. Brand new day...

What follows will be interesting.

Just want a competitive and successful team.

He can leave with a Colgate smile on his face idgaf anymore 😁

I’m Ok with whatever improves the prospects in 2026 of the Melbourne Footy Club.

If that’s means sayonara to Christian, all good.

This is the way, I have spoken.

Edited September 16Sep 16 by Superunknown

Feeling better that he is ‘open’ to quite the range of teams.

Wonder if this was the message from the FD to his mgmt: come back to us with a selection of clubs we could do a reasonable deal with this time around.

1 minute ago, The Jackson FIX said:

Feeling better that he is ‘open’ to quite the range of teams.

Wonder if this was the message from the FD to his mgmt: come back to us with a selection of clubs we could do a reasonable deal with this time around.

This ^^^^

2 hours ago, Mouseymoo said:

I only want players that want to be here. If he wants to leave and if it's to our benefit then that's fine. Kind of sick of the talk every year about him being uncommitted.

Agree totally, if a player wants out then the contract should be void and negotiate with the new club $$ .. we should not have to pay any part of the contract.. very disappointing if he does want out though as he should part of the solution going fwd not jump ship, hopefully King will galvanise the group

Adelaide are famously stingy at the trade table.

Keep Clarry, trade out Petracca.

3 minutes ago, KozzyCan said:

Adelaide are famously stingy at the trade table.

Good think Trac is contracted, pony up or F off i say

3 minutes ago, KozzyCan said:

Adelaide are famously stingy at the trade table.

Eh.. He can stay then

I hope they both stay, and despite Trac reportedly being open to a trade, I will in in no way doubt his commitment and investment in the MFC if he stays.

3 hours ago, Travy14 said:

Don't read into the Trac articles too much, been sitting on the "Journo's" desks for 8 months waiting to put out there. Let him sit down and talk with King first, get an idea of where his place is moving forward and if he is happy with that. If he is then not happy with the direction, we then look at a trade.

Morris also says in his article that there is less of an interest then last year for Trac to move, which screams it's a nothing article at this stage.

King believes we are a finals team, and if so, Petracca is a finals player! He will be a big part of King's plan and now he can sell that to Trac.

100% correct. There are more reasons for Trac to stay on than there were last year. Not saying that a trade is fantasy but definitely less impetus this year than 12 months ago.

As I said in a post a few weeks back... I never really got the love back for Trac after last season, so if he wants to go, then he can go.

Petracca + a bundle of 3rd/4th round picks to GC for Pick 6, Pick 13 and Flanders. It is honestly a win-win in my opinion.

• Gives us another solid look at the draft before the FIGJAMs enter the competition in 2028, plus a good young up-and-comer from them.

• Gives them the game-breaker they need to take them another level, and the bundled late rounders give them currency to get their 3x Top-20 academy picks (2x Top 5).

13 minutes ago, The Jackson FIX said:

Feeling better that he is ‘open’ to quite the range of teams.

Wonder if this was the message from the FD to his mgmt: come back to us with a selection of clubs we could do a reasonable deal with this time around.

I keep seeing this line about Trac being ‘open to a range of teams,’ but where has he actually said that? I’ve seen plenty of journos and trade gossip pages run with it, but not a single direct quote from Trac himself.

This is how the cycle works every year — vague leaks from managers or rival clubs get spun into ‘player X wants out,’ then it snowballs until fans start treating it as fact.

Until I hear it from Trac or his management on record, it’s just speculation. And given how the media works, half of this feels more like leverage than reality!

He should be a club leader, 30y.o being paid lots of lucre.

At the moment we are being short changed.