Derpsy me.

42 minutes ago, Webber said:

Has the AFL ever made the logical decision at the time it’s most indicated/needed/deserved? They always hang onto it for a while (season or two), before then making the blindly obvious change. Mind-numbingly frustrating. 

Their rules can be bent, stretched, and waived at any time. Adelaide just got permission to replace Strachan who easily could be back before the end of the year (not to undermine the difficultly of a navicular in to a heel stress fracture). And they got to hold the announcement from Friday to Monday for the vibes.

But their favourite certainly is reviewing rules over a painstaking period of time until they get a good result and then either overreacting or creating further grey areas.

We are going to be allowed to replace Andy. Fantastic news. Could it be Roy George?

9 minutes ago, Dannyz said:

We are going to be allowed to replace Andy. Fantastic news. Could it be Roy George?

What’s your vibe?

13 hours ago, Redleg said:

So the clubs are adopting my suggestion/proposal.

As I said, it is totally unfair for some clubs to be playing their match sims after the SSP period closed, while others played earlier.

All clubs should be treated the same and all play earlier or later.

I think all clubs have now played their match sims, so what is so bad with extending the SSP to say Tuesday, 4 days longer.

As I said.

8 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

What’s your vibe?

Heart wants George,

Gut says Culley,

Head says JT is known for plucking obscure targets he's previously wanted to draft. 

Edited February 24, 20251 yr by Dannyz

17 minutes ago, Dannyz said:

We are going to be allowed to replace Andy. Fantastic news. Could it be Roy George?

I have been pushing for Roy for a few months now, but feel it will be Culley ,with more versatility and the fact that Roy will hopefully be there in the msd at our pick.

I just think George has the most upside. For mine it comes down to his attitude and his desire to make it. Will he work to get the very best out of himself. If the answer is yes then I'd pick him. You know what you're getting with Culley.

Terrible news. These bloody practice matches!

Oh by the way does anyone know if Walking Civil War is still on our forum? I for one miss her informative contributions.

Edited February 24, 20251 yr by Bobby McKenzie

5 hours ago, Webber said:

If ever the AFL needed motivation to alter their list supplement policy, it’s now

As none of you have done so yet, I’ll take the credit. Thanks AFL. 

Oh this is interesting. Seemed like Culley was odds on until Henderson got home like Kingston Town. 

Do they see Culley as completely different - taller, more of a pure midfielder, not an ANB replacement - or do they class Henderson as a midfielder and lean towards a different kind of player entirely?

Be a bit of a sliding doors moment if we replace someone on a list who has unfortunately just done their ACL with someone coming back from an ACL. Will be an interesting list management decision. Or do we go Roy as a part of operation keep Kossie at Melbourne. 

35 minutes ago, Bobby McKenzie said:

Terrible news. These bloody practice matches!

Oh by the way does anyone know if Walking Civil War is still on our forum? I for one miss her informative contributions.

So last year!

Forget WalkingCivilWar have a look at Ghostwriter!

Thanks Redleg and DannyZ, this is a great decision based on fairness for all teams and common sense. What a terrible week we have had losing two players with season ending injuries when they were both on the verge of claiming a spot. I am happy with Jack Henderson and will trust JT to find the best option for Dees.👏👍😁

1 hour ago, Bobby McKenzie said:

Terrible news. These bloody practice matches!

Oh by the way does anyone know if Walking Civil War is still on our forum? I for one miss her informative contributions.

She has morphed into Ghostwriter.

PS: Sorry ManDee just saw your post.

Edited February 24, 20251 yr by Redleg

1 hour ago, Webber said:

As none of you have done so yet, I’ll take the credit. Thanks AFL. 

👆It's confirmed then. @Webber is an 'internet influencer'.

So Zero Hanger reporting we've signed Jai Culley.

So we get Jai Culley.  

With all respect and sympathy for Jagga Smith, thank god a Carton player was injured.

1 hour ago, TRIGON said:

👆It's confirmed then. @Webber is an 'internet influencer'.

I’m nominating myself, having stated that as Carlton was involved, it would work in our favour. 🤣

3 hours ago, Redleg said:

She has morphed into Ghostwriter.

PS: Sorry ManDee just saw your post.

Thanks Redleg for that. I was wondering whether it could be Ghost writer . Good news she is still with us. Im pleased.

4 hours ago, ManDee said:

So last year!

Forget WalkingCivilWar have a look at Ghostwriter!

Thanks ManDee much appreciated. Cheers.

4 hours ago, Bobby McKenzie said:

Thanks Redleg for that. I was wondering whether it could be Ghost writer . Good news she is still with us. Im pleased.

So is she.

18 hours ago, Dannyz said:

Heart wants George,

Gut says Culley,

Head says JT is known for plucking obscure targets he's previously wanted to draft. 

It will be interesting to see how Roy goes at Casey, as we may have a spot at msd time and he appears to be at the head of the line atm.

2 hours ago, Redleg said:

It will be interesting to see how Roy goes at Casey, as we may have a spot at msd time and he appears to be at the head of the line atm.

Do we only have a list spot at the MSD if someone gets moved to the long term injury list or retires?

3 hours ago, The Lobster Effect said:

Do we only have a list spot at the MSD if someone gets moved to the long term injury list or retires?

I believe that is the case.

Remembering that we need enough places at the end of the year, for any returning players to the active list, like AMW and McAdam and also at least 3 spots for new people on the list, being drafted or traded.

Edited February 25, 20251 yr by Redleg