2 minutes ago, DistrACTION Jackson said:

Gotta love these anonymous sources…

See training reports from beloved @WalkingCivilWar who may or may not be the secret source!

1 hour ago, Ferghus31 said:

Christian has a lot of guts he has fronted players and officials and let it all off his chest he has given us so much joy and is the idol of many but if he is not happy well let him go .

IF he decides on Collingwood their first pick #32 is not enough however  I would take that with Beau Mc Creey and a late  3rd rounder Mc Creey has a huge upside Pace and strength plus he will save us $

 

 

This would make Jeremy Howe for Ben Kennedy look like inspired list management on our part.

5 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

Surely he told some players he was going to Noosa.

That doesn't bother me he went to Noosa. I get why he wanted to get away & it's not like he could train.

I mean Bailey smith went overseas. 

This is the part of the story that doesn’t make any sense to me. Basically everyone knew of the seriousness of his injuries, so all the players must have known. 
 

He can be in recovery and doing nothing here, or up there. 
 

What is the difference and why would anybody (including players that found out late that he went there) care? 
 

 

1 hour ago, Ferghus31 said:

Christian has a lot of guts he has fronted players and officials and let it all off his chest he has given us so much joy and is the idol of many but if he is not happy well let him go .

IF he decides on Collingwood their first pick #32 is not enough however  I would take that with Beau Mc Creey and a late  3rd rounder Mc Creey has a huge upside Pace and strength plus he will save us $

 

 

You win. 

1 hour ago, Ferghus31 said:

Christian has a lot of guts he has fronted players and officials and let it all off his chest he has given us so much joy and is the idol of many but if he is not happy well let him go .

IF he decides on Collingwood their first pick #32 is not enough however  I would take that with Beau Mc Creey and a late  3rd rounder Mc Creey has a huge upside Pace and strength plus he will save us $

 

 

I’m not trying to join in on the pile on and am genuinely asking:

If Josh Daicos wanted to leave the pies, do you reckon they would accept pick 32, Jake Bowey or Tom Sparrow and a late 3rd rounder? 
 

2 minutes ago, BoBo said:

I’m not trying to join in on the pile on and am genuinely asking:

If Josh Daicos wanted to leave the pies, do you reckon they would accept pick 32, Jake Bowey or Tom Sparrow and a late 3rd rounder? 
 

They wouldn’t even accept that for Josh, let alone Nick. 
Did you mean Nick? 

5 minutes ago, BoBo said:

I’m not trying to join in on the pile on and am genuinely asking:

If Josh Daicos wanted to leave the pies, do you reckon they would accept pick 32, Jake Bowey or Tom Sparrow and a late 3rd rounder? 
 

They might accept it for Peter.

1 minute ago, Jaded No More said:

They wouldn’t even accept that for Josh, let alone Nick. 
Did you mean Nick? 

You’re saying the quiet part out loud there Jaded, that’s my point, haha

Tracc and Nick are superstars.

Josh Daicos is a VERY good player. But not in their league. 
 

So if they wouldn’t accept that for Josh Daicos…

AFL journos are total nuffies. Pies fan Jay Clark says it will be the Pies.  Get your hand off it Daryl.

2 minutes ago, Clintosaurus said:

AFL journos are total nuffies. Pies fan Jay Clark says it will be the Pies.  Get your hand off it Daryl.

Waiting for Mr Justice Served McGuire to join the party 🤢

1 hour ago, BoBo said:

What is the difference and why would anybody (including players that found out late that he went there) care? 
 

 

Maybe the players did care, maybe they didn’t, but it also sounds like Tracc may not have got too many RU OKs.

I don’t think anybody has really tweaked how serious his injuries were or close to death he was, including players.

Below is a lot of hypotheticals, but firstly, Tracc’s injuries were horrific.  I’ve known someone who has had a ruptured spleen, and they were really bad, but even they had enough blood circulating around to have transfusions and surgery while they were asleep.  And they were back in full exercise in 12 weeks.  It must have been really [censored] up for Tracc to have surgery while awake and still not allowed to get his heart rate up 10 weeks after the injury.

Since I heard that, my first thought was wondering if Tracc will ever play again.  The second thought was his family would try and talk him into retiring.  No job is worth risking your life for and no doubt they would be worried about another accidental knee.

I have no idea which players and officials have been in touch with Tracc through this entire 12 weeks, and how often.  But if the Noosa situation is even 50% true, then right when Tracc is still processing his football future, it sounds like there may not have been too many RU OKs sent his way and perhaps he may have even had to process getting the cold shoulder.  I don’t know.  On top of it, ignorant supporters are piling on.

And this all follows having to deal with a spray from Max about Traccs lack of effort when he came back on. So we have Pies players concerned about Traccs welfare when he came back on, while at the same time our Captain is spraying him.  That’s [censored] up.

Goody, Max and the entire club have to get rid of their “faux tough play while injured” attitude.  It’s [censored] up and has derailed way too many of our players and way too many of the last 8 seasons.

And the pile onto Tracc continues to be shameful.  This is a player who has played finals with a broken leg. Not to mention the only Norm Smith medalist we have ever had. Show some respect and empathy.

End rant.  Not aimed at you @BoBo

 

Guess we now know where Trac was on the weekend.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Christian Petracca (@christianpetracca)

1 minute ago, pingu said:

Guess we now know where Trac was on the weekend.

https://www.instagram.com/reel/C-2Cz8IvkxI/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link

Building his brand.. 

2 minutes ago, pingu said:

Guess we now know where Trac was on the weekend.

 

Wearing Black and White too 😱

12 minutes ago, Clintosaurus said:

AFL journos are total nuffies. Pies fan Jay Clark says it will be the Pies.  Get your hand off it Daryl.

Is Jay Clark also proposing Beau McCreery and pick 32 as the trade?

2 hours ago, Norm Smith's Curse said:

It really sounds like that preseason had a bit more spice than gawnie having a spew on Scully. 

All the little stories over the last 12 months all make me really wonder why the big story here has never broken when everyone says it's common knowledge yet none of us phlebs have a clue. 

Maybe it’s all rubbish 

Two days ago, Tom Morris reported that Bolton has requested a trade. Now Morris posts the below on X. Morris is quickly becoming the new purple.

Edited August 19, 2024Aug 19 by Ethan Tremblay

12 minutes ago, SPC said:

Building his brand.. 

A lot of this stuff was filmed early in the year and scheduled well in advance.

12 minutes ago, Watson11 said:

Maybe the players did care, maybe they didn’t, but it also sounds like Tracc may not have got too many RU OKs.

I don’t think anybody has really tweaked how serious his injuries were or close to death he was, including players.

Below is a lot of hypotheticals, but firstly, Tracc’s injuries were horrific.  I’ve known someone who has had a ruptured spleen, and they were really bad, but even they had enough blood circulating around to have transfusions and surgery while they were asleep.  And they were back in full exercise in 12 weeks.  It must have been really [censored] up for Tracc to have surgery while awake and still not allowed to get his heart rate up 10 weeks after the injury.

Since I heard that, my first thought was wondering if Tracc will ever play again.  The second thought was his family would try and talk him into retiring.  No job is worth risking your life for and no doubt they would be worried about another accidental knee.

I have no idea which players and officials have been in touch with Tracc through this entire 12 weeks, and how often.  But if the Noosa situation is even 50% true, then right when Tracc is still processing his football future, it sounds like there may not have been too many RU OKs sent his way and perhaps he may have even had to process getting the cold shoulder.  I don’t know.  On top of it, ignorant supporters are piling on.

And this all follows having to deal with a spray from Max about Traccs lack of effort when he came back on. So we have Pies players concerned about Traccs welfare when he came back on, while at the same time our Captain is spraying him.  That’s [censored] up.

Goody, Max and the entire club have to get rid of their “faux tough play while injured” attitude.  It’s [censored] up and has derailed way too many of our players and way too many of the last 8 seasons.

And the pile onto Tracc continues to be shameful.  This is a player who has played finals with a broken leg. Not to mention the only Norm Smith medalist we have ever had. Show some respect and empathy.

End rant.  Not aimed at you @BoBo

 

Nah all good re: it being aimed at me.

I can’t speak to much of that as it is hypothetical/speculative but what I will say on a personal note: 

In 2020 I got sick and had to go to Hospital. I was in extreme pain and was given morphine to treat it until they couldn’t give me any more pain killers. I went through 5-6 hours straight of 10/10 pain. Sounds weird but I didn’t know pain could be that bad.

Point is, it was absolutely horrific and it changed me as a person and probably took me a good couple years to fully get over.  

So I agree that people are being too harsh on him. 

Does that mean he is incapable of doing wrong? Nope. 

But maybe 2 or so months after being in ICU, he is probably not going to have a proportional response to what he normally would emotionally.

 

 

Hopefully the club publishes the full presser because this is heavily edited

Edited August 19, 2024Aug 19 by At the break of Gawn

4 minutes ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Hopefully the club publishes the full presser because this is heavily edited

"Only fuelling speculation". Really? I think meeting with the playing group is a sign he's open to mending things. 

Just now, Flowergirl said:

"Only fuelling speculation". Really? I think meeting with the playing group is a sign he's open to mending things. 

My sources tell me he met with the playing group to hand back the coriander Kade Chandler gave him 

 

Edited August 19, 2024Aug 19 by Jaded No More

3 minutes ago, Flowergirl said:

"Only fuelling speculation". Really? I think meeting with the playing group is a sign he's open to mending things. 

They’re just grabbing on the fact Petracca hasn’t spoken yet publicly 

11 hours ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

Thanks for posting that. Surely there’s more to it that? A professional sporting organisation in turmoil over communication issues, I’m not buying it.

Monday 26th ...but a week away.  Whatever is going on, whatever is to happen will surely start taking shape then. 

Something is odd, something is wrong...

Can't help but feel we're watching a scripted pantomine.

I too am very confused about all this .

Collingwood players essentially caused both Traccs  and the Brayshaw problems😳

If Tracc were to amazingly end up at Collingwood, l would find it quite bizzare.

Should the  football club ever consider going down this road, many supporters would surely be devastated  and feel very badly let down.