2024 Phantom Drafts

[Diamond_Jim 12,642]

15 minutes ago, demoncat said:

They have us taking Langford and Armstrong

Interestingly they have FOS slipping to the Saints, with Jagga being taken by Carlton 

Yep... usually the top 4 or 5 are agreed with perhaps some discussion over the order (usually number 1 is obvious) but the whole top 10 this year is up in the air.

Strange year... could make for a big spreadsheet for the recruiters as to the changing scenarios on draft night

[Dee Boys 727]

25 minutes ago, adonski said:

Could someone do the honours

 

Also says that Adelaide will pick Smith if he gets to them. With the same intel in the Herald Sun this morning it looks like Jagga may end up being out of reach for us sadly.

[adonski 12,610]

1 minute ago, Dee Boys said:

Also says that Adelaide will pick Smith if he gets to them. With the same intel in the Herald Sun this morning it looks like Jagga may end up being out of reach for us sadly.

I'd settle for Langford!

[DistrACTION Jackson 9,604]

1 hour ago, DeeSpencer said:

Might want to look to who the Saints recruiting manager is (it’s not Sos)

Fair enough.... just making a joke as I really cbf looking up who each teams recruiting manager is

[old55 23,800]

30 minutes ago, adonski said:

I'd settle for Langford!

Apparently his floor is the Bont and his ceiling is Cripps, or is that the other way around 😉

[Axis of Bob 11,875]

8 minutes ago, old55 said:

Apparently his floor is the Bont and his ceiling is Cripps, or is that the other way around 😉

It's odd that nobody ever mentions Neil Erasmus, Brodie Kemp, Paddy Dow, Will Setterfield, Will Brodie or Jackson Hateley. 

[Roddog 89]

49 minutes ago, Dee Boys said:

Also says that Adelaide will pick Smith if he gets to them. With the same intel in the Herald Sun this morning it looks like Jagga may end up being out of reach for us sadly.

This would mean with pick 5 we’d be picking between 2 of Langford/FOS/Draper, wouldn’t it? Assuming norf take Tauru of course 

[BC_1718_DC 1,478]

5 minutes ago, Axis of Bob said:

It's odd that nobody ever mentions Neil Erasmus, Brodie Kemp, Paddy Dow, Will Setterfield, Will Brodie or Jackson Hateley. 

We don’t mention those names because Jason Taylor didn’t draft them and clearly there’s a reason for that 😂

[DubDee 26,191]

21 minutes ago, old55 said:

Apparently his floor is the Bont and his ceiling is Cripps, or is that the other way around 😉

Not much headroom in that house!

[FTB 278]

5 minutes ago, Roddog said:

This would mean with pick 5 we’d be picking between 2 of Langford/FOS/Draper, wouldn’t it? Assuming norf take Tauru of course 

Draper won’t get past Adelaide.

One of Langford, Smith or FOS for us.

[Lord Travis 10,763]

Sounds like FOS may slide to our pick. I haven't bothered looking at him properly due to assuming he'd be pick 1-2. He was awesome last year, but was limited by playing injured this year. Anyone got an opinion of if he'd be the best option at 5 for us should he be available?

He smashed testing at the combine, so looks a great athlete as well as being a renowned impactful ball user...

[spirit of norm smith 16,596]

2 hours ago, Lord Travis said:

Sounds like FOS may slide to our pick. I haven't bothered looking at him properly due to assuming he'd be pick 1-2. He was awesome last year, but was limited by playing injured this year. Anyone got an opinion of if he'd be the best option at 5 for us should he be available?

He smashed testing at the combine, so looks a great athlete as well as being a renowned impactful ball user...

O’Sullivan could go at 1 or anywhere down to 6.  He’s a star though. Lots of AFL qualities.

If it’s a choice of Smith, O’Sullivan or Langford. 

it’s like choosing between a BMW, a Porsche and a Mercedes. 

Any choice would be excellent !!! 

[Dee Boys 727]

FROM THE HERALD SUN

Adelaide may be forced to give up a future second-round pick to move two spots up this year’s draft order as part of a bold play for Victorian midfielder Jagga Smith.

The Crows currently hold pick 4 in next Wednesday’s national draft but have held discussions with North Melbourne about the possibility of trading up to pick 2.

It is believed that the player in Adelaide’s sights is Smith, a prolific ball-winning midfielder who captained Vic Metro at the under-18 national championships.

Rival clubs believe the Crows are fearful that Carlton would select Smith at pick 3 if Adelaide remains at pick 4.

Smith has been arguably the best-performed underage footballer in the country this year, with recruiters describing him as a “bankable” high-end prospect and future AFL captain.

The 18-year-old would add a different dynamic to the Crows’ midfield with his speed and agility.

He averaged 33.3 disposals, 7.9 clearances and 154 ranking points from 12 games for the Oakleigh Chargers in the Coates Talent League this year.

It is understood that Adelaide recently offered North Melbourne pick 4 and two future third-round selections in exchange for pick 2, but the offer was knocked back.

The Kangaroos are believed to be eyeing pick 4 and a future second-round selection to get the deal done.

The pre-draft pick swap window closed last Friday, but clubs are still able to make live trades during the draft.

Richmond is still expected to take midfielder-forward Sam Lalor with the No.1 pick.

North Melbourne has been linked to midfielder Finn O’Sullivan in recent days if it holds on to pick 2, despite long being favoured to select exciting 193cm utility Alix Tauru.

If Adelaide was to beat Carlton to Smith, the Blues could nab South Australian Sid Draper.

Carlton coach Michael Voss and list manager Nick Austin flew to Adelaide in the past week to meet with the explosive midfielder.

If North Melbourne was to overlook Tauru at pick 2, he would not be expected to get past Melbourne at pick 5 given the Demons are big fans of the Gippsland Power high-flyer.

Richmond looks almost certain to select big-bodied midfielder Josh Smillie with pick 6, while Brisbane Lions father-son prospect Levi Ashcroft is also expected to receive a bid within the first six picks.

Edited November 15, 2024 by Dee Boys

[adonski 12,610]

Might need to give footy a miss next year if we take a key back

[Dee Boys 727]

As much as Tauru has huge potential it's going to take a fair bit of time for him to realise it. Think I'd feel a bit flat if we ended up with him at 5 rather than the premium mid I'd been thinking we'd take. Getting him at 9 would be a different story, would be stoked with that.

[Davos 923]

3 minutes ago, Dee Boys said:

FROM THE HERALD SUN

Adelaide may be forced to give up a future second-round pick to move two spots up this year’s draft order as part of a bold play for Victorian midfielder Jagga Smith.

The Crows currently hold pick 4 in next Wednesday’s national draft but have held discussions with North Melbourne about the possibility of trading up to pick 2.

It is believed that the player in Adelaide’s sights is Smith, a prolific ball-winning midfielder who captained Vic Metro at the under-18 national championships.

Rival clubs believe the Crows are fearful that Carlton would select Smith at pick 3 if Adelaide remains at pick 4.

Smith has been arguably the best-performed underage footballer in the country this year, with recruiters describing him as a “bankable” high-end prospect and future AFL captain.

The 18-year-old would add a different dynamic to the Crows’ midfield with his speed and agility.

He averaged 33.3 disposals, 7.9 clearances and 154 ranking points from 12 games for the Oakleigh Chargers in the Coates Talent League this year.

It is understood that Adelaide recently offered North Melbourne pick 4 and two future third-round selections in exchange for pick 2, but the offer was knocked back.

The Kangaroos are believed to be eyeing pick 4 and a future second-round selection to get the deal done.

The pre-draft pick swap window closed last Friday, but clubs are still able to make live trades during the draft.

Richmond is still expected to take midfielder-forward Sam Lalor with the No.1 pick.

North Melbourne has been linked to midfielder Finn O’Sullivan in recent days if it holds on to pick 2, despite long being favoured to select exciting 193cm utility Alix Tauru.

If Adelaide was to beat Carlton to Smith, the Blues could nab South Australian Sid Draper.

Carlton coach Michael Voss and list manager Nick Austin flew to Adelaide in the past week to meet with the explosive midfielder.

If North Melbourne was to overlook Tauru at pick 2, he would not be expected to get past Melbourne at pick 5 given the Demons are big fans of the Gippsland Power high-flyer.

Richmond looks almost certain to select big-bodied midfielder Josh Smillie with pick 6, while Brisbane Lions father-son prospect Levi Ashcroft is also expected to receive a bid within the first six picks.

Oh hell yeah - flying Viking come on down. 

[spirit of norm smith 16,596]

2 hours ago, Davos said:

Oh hell yeah - flying Viking come on down. 

 

Tauru. Prefer to get him at 9 (like an elite midfielder at 5) 

Marketing team would love Tauru

“here comes the Demons on the G”… Viking horns roaring !!! Tauruuuuuuuuu

[Mike 329]

10 minutes ago, adonski said:

Might need to give footy a miss next year if we take a key back

I think I'll need a holiday after all this. I'm a nervous wreck. And picking Tauru at 5 might tip me over the edge

[Mouseymoo 368]

13 minutes ago, Dee Boys said:

FROM THE HERALD SUN

Adelaide may be forced to give up a future second-round pick to move two spots up this year’s draft order as part of a bold play for Victorian midfielder Jagga Smith.

The Crows currently hold pick 4 in next Wednesday’s national draft but have held discussions with North Melbourne about the possibility of trading up to pick 2.

It is believed that the player in Adelaide’s sights is Smith, a prolific ball-winning midfielder who captained Vic Metro at the under-18 national championships.

Rival clubs believe the Crows are fearful that Carlton would select Smith at pick 3 if Adelaide remains at pick 4.

Smith has been arguably the best-performed underage footballer in the country this year, with recruiters describing him as a “bankable” high-end prospect and future AFL captain.

The 18-year-old would add a different dynamic to the Crows’ midfield with his speed and agility.

He averaged 33.3 disposals, 7.9 clearances and 154 ranking points from 12 games for the Oakleigh Chargers in the Coates Talent League this year.

It is understood that Adelaide recently offered North Melbourne pick 4 and two future third-round selections in exchange for pick 2, but the offer was knocked back.

The Kangaroos are believed to be eyeing pick 4 and a future second-round selection to get the deal done.

The pre-draft pick swap window closed last Friday, but clubs are still able to make live trades during the draft.

Richmond is still expected to take midfielder-forward Sam Lalor with the No.1 pick.

North Melbourne has been linked to midfielder Finn O’Sullivan in recent days if it holds on to pick 2, despite long being favoured to select exciting 193cm utility Alix Tauru.

If Adelaide was to beat Carlton to Smith, the Blues could nab South Australian Sid Draper.

Carlton coach Michael Voss and list manager Nick Austin flew to Adelaide in the past week to meet with the explosive midfielder.

If North Melbourne was to overlook Tauru at pick 2, he would not be expected to get past Melbourne at pick 5 given the Demons are big fans of the Gippsland Power high-flyer.

Richmond looks almost certain to select big-bodied midfielder Josh Smillie with pick 6, while Brisbane Lions father-son prospect Levi Ashcroft is also expected to receive a bid within the first six picks.

Adelaide trading up for Smith? Who what where now? This has red herring all over it. The games afoot. 

Seems like now Lawlor is the only lock at 1. There's no way Adelaide trade up for a player that that from all reports could very well be available with their original pick. 

Also I just CAN'T see them passing on Draper. 

Anywho I'll now wait for Cal's phantom.

[BC_1718_DC 1,478]

2 minutes ago, Mike said:

I think I'll need a holiday after all this. I'm a nervous wreck. And picking Tauru at 5 might tip me over the edge

Tauru isn’t just a key back. Can play forward and most recruiters think he’ll eventually be a midfield option. 

[layzie 34,147]

41 minutes ago, Lord Travis said:

Sounds like FOS may slide to our pick. I haven't bothered looking at him properly due to assuming he'd be pick 1-2. He was awesome last year, but was limited by playing injured this year. Anyone got an opinion of if he'd be the best option at 5 for us should he be available?

He smashed testing at the combine, so looks a great athlete as well as being a renowned impactful ball user...

Seems like your typical strong bodied power mid with a lot to offer around the ground. 

I was the same in not bothering to look at him but these types of players aren't going out of fashion anytime soon. 

[adonski 12,610]

6 minutes ago, 12345_54321 said:

Tauru isn’t just a key back. Can play forward and most recruiters think he’ll eventually be a midfield option. 

This is going to be Jackson vs Serong, Young, Green, ect all over again 🤮🤮🤮🤮

[BC_1718_DC 1,478]

13 minutes ago, adonski said:

This is going to be Jackson vs Serong, Young, Green, ect all over again 🤮🤮🤮🤮

Jackson worked out well for the flag, and we turned him into Windsor and hopefully another gun in Jeffo. Just the way it goes. Don't think anyone argues with our decision when they have a medal round their neck. 

[drdrake 3,187]

I still think we may off load 9, maybe to fremantle for 14 and 30.  Freo jumps up to get Allen and I think there is still enough quality at both 14 and 30

[DeeSpencer 26,091]

26 minutes ago, 12345_54321 said:

Tauru isn’t just a key back. Can play forward and most recruiters think he’ll eventually be a midfield option. 

Spot on. I reckon North have played this beautifully if they get an F2 out of Adelaide and pick him at 4.