PREGAME: Rd 19 vs Adelaide

[Diamond_Jim 12,628]

15 minutes ago, YearOfTheDees said:

I don't like our run home. If we are not switched I can one or more of these sides causing an upset. That said we should win all six. 

The next six gives us time to get a lot right if we are to challenge in finals.

Adelaide seem to play a less skilled version of the Collingwood gameplan so that will be a good place to start

Ideally we need the Cats to lose one more. Having them 1.5 games behind us is a little worrying especially if we drop a game

[DeeSpencer 26,083]

1 hour ago, A F said:

Chandler needs to play forward of ball as a pressure forward IMO. If Kozzy is playing higher, which I think is potentially less likely in a final, we need Chandler's pressure. Probably at the expense of Spargo.

I think our forwardline mix against Brisbane was off. Great offensively, but too vulnerable on counter, hence the 4 of 5 goals from defensive half chains in the 3rd quarter for the Lions.

Chandler has a bit more physical pressure in tight, but Spargo is one of if not our most organised in getting the zone set. They bring different attributes defensively. 

We won’t get much from BBB and Melk, but I wonder how much defensive cohesion can improve as those guys as well as Tracc, Sparrow and Woey settle in together 

We’re also one paced in the middle with Gus and JJ both full time mids. We miss Clarry’s defensive speed.

[leave it to deever 17,518]

Gawn in post lions interview, was pretty adamant that the Gawndy experiment is going to continue.

If it does , it's evident Max has to ruck most of the game. Is it possible for Grundy to play in defence instead of fwd? 

We could swing Petty fwd?

Just wondering since Brodie is not a great mark.

 

[leave it to deever 17,518]

Gawn in post lions interview, was pretty adamant that the Gawndy experiment is going to continue.

If it does , it's evident Max has to ruck most of the game. Is it possible for Grundy to play in defence instead of fwd? 

We could swing Petty fwd?

Just wondering since Brodie is not a great mark.

 

[goodwindees 2,537]

Out Petty & Spargo. 
In Tomlinson & Hibberd.

Play Bowey forward instead of Spargo 

[praha 11,240]

Anyone know of the best way to watch in Singapore? Assuming I won't be able to get out to watch it.

I have Foxtel but guessing the app won't work there.

[Demonland 73,163]

 

[Demonland 73,163]

6 minutes ago, praha said:

Anyone know of the best way to watch in Singapore? Assuming I won't be able to get out to watch it.

I have Foxtel but guessing the app won't work there.

You can try using a VPN or take out a Watch AFL subscription for either a week or a month depending on how long you are going to be away for.

[Tolstoys Nudge 1,734]

25 minutes ago, praha said:

Anyone know of the best way to watch in Singapore? Assuming I won't be able to get out to watch it.

I have Foxtel but guessing the app won't work there.

VPN to Australia then use Foxtel 

[Fromgotowoewodin 1,606]

48 minutes ago, praha said:

Anyone know of the best way to watch in Singapore? Assuming I won't be able to get out to watch it.

I have Foxtel but guessing the app won't work there.

Used to be (circa mid-2010s) and google tells me there still is, an Aussie bar called Boomerang Bistro. Eating there is probably a waste of your calorie intake given everything else you can eat in Singas but will have the footy on.

https://maps.app.goo.gl/GnCYwKGM3tAroLYD6?g_st=ic

My take on team selection:

Petty out for Tomlinson, surely has a week off at least after getting subbed twice with injury. Would expect given past experience that Petty comes back in when fit (hopefully not before).

Spargo v Chandler - can see this going each way, you’d think on pure form Chandler gets a go (good vfl praccy apparently, Spargo not doing much) but Spargo is clearly marked best 22 so I can see them giving him another week or two to get back into form.

McVee/Rivers into mids, Bowey fwd? Don’t see any of these happening, I think the FD is pretty settled on the back half and won’t be moving the pieces around too much barring Hibberd coming back and someone making way.

Mids - one of Sparrow/Jordan will have to make way for Clarry at some point but probably not this week. Sparrow might become a permanent fwd and Spargo/Chin both miss when that happens. Jordan is vulnerable to going back to sub though given past history, they probably do that. Edit: Forgot my namesake- Taj might be the obvious miss and the other two stay, this got more complicated than I expected when I started..

Fwds - I think apart from the Spargo/Chin shootout the rest stays the same, bar Grundy maybe coming in for JVR (vulnerable due to still learning, BBB still ahead of him in smarts and impact imo). I don’t think all 3 fit in one fwd line or that we can go Gawndy without clogging the fwd 50 too much. 

Edited July 16, 2023 by Fromgotowoewodin

[bing181 9,328]

2 hours ago, praha said:

Anyone know of the best way to watch in Singapore? Assuming I won't be able to get out to watch it.

I have Foxtel but guessing the app won't work there.

https://www.watchafl.com.au

[bing181 9,328]

Rachele out, 2 weeks.

[chook fowler 19,551]

2 hours ago, praha said:

Anyone know of the best way to watch in Singapore? Assuming I won't be able to get out to watch it.

I have Foxtel but guessing the app won't work there.

With satay in one hand and a Tiger beer in the other.

[DEE fence 5,039]

I thought Tommo was very stiff to get dropped (after KB game) as was Smith. On merit, ability and match - ups though I would like to see Smith as starting 22, with and I know it is unusual, Tommo as sub, our defence is our foundation, all of the unexpected losses have nearly always revolved around a key defender injury early in the game. We have plenty of flexibility in the midfield and with the forwards (while I would love a dominant KPF that is in the wishes/fishes category). But a settled back six with the big defenders in place makes us a fierce beast. Having a utility as sub who can't play that KD role hurts more than in other positions. So I think Smith has the right to some continuity, and I would love to have Tommo in the pocket. If needed Smith could go forward during the game and Tommo take the defence position Smith starts in. 

Otherwise wouldn't mind Chandler over Spargo, I felt like Chin after a great start was trying to do much and should stick to his role which hopefully a spell has taught him. Spargo is confusing to me the difference between his best and worst regularly happens back to back within game. 

If Hibberd right to play then he has a role with the smart Adelaide small forwards and I could live with Bowey going forward as an experiment in either the spargo/chin role. 

[Young Angus 802]

On 7/14/2023 at 11:21 PM, dee-tox said:

Get Petty properly right FFS!

What on earth were they thinking they knew he was carrying that and they still put him in over a fully healthy player..why is that allowed to happen when players like Smith and Tomlinson are fit and healthy??  Genuinely want to know how that decision happens

[COOLX 209]

The Dees had there mini slump by being 9 w 6 L . I did say prior to playing Brisbane we will not lose another match . We have Oliver , Fritta and a renewed and improved Grundy coming back. 

[beelzebub 23,383]

53 minutes ago, bing181 said:

Rachele out, 2 weeks.

🤔🤔Shame.... such a shame..🤣🤣🤣

[beelzebub 23,383]

3 hours ago, praha said:

Anyone know of the best way to watch in Singapore? Assuming I won't be able to get out to watch it.

I have Foxtel but guessing the app won't work there.

Dunno...   all a bit of a raffle...  

[bobby1554 1,263]

8 minutes ago, COOLX said:

The Dees had there mini slump by being 9 w 6 L . I did say prior to playing Brisbane we will not lose another match . We have Oliver , Fritta and a renewed and improved Grundy coming back. 

And throw TMac into the mix

[gOLLy 401]

Tomo for Petty

Mc Vee maybe a rest before finals for Hibbo

Smith must be a starter in the 22

[Watson11 2,243]

On 7/15/2023 at 7:11 AM, dazzledavey36 said:

Spargo for me, he has to go. Has been a liability for the past 2 weeks.

Gave them all the momentum when he coughed it up so easy in that 2nd quarter. After that, Brisbane went on a complete run on.

I thought that Spargo play was more about everything wrong with our forward line coaching. The tv view showed that entire end of the ground.  Spargo is our best inside 50 kick but can’t kick reliably over more than 35m. He has it 75m out, plays on quickly, and no Melbourne player is leading and everyone seems to be running toward a long kick to a pack 20m out.  Maybe he should have done that but it’s pretty ridiculous his only option beside dumping it long is a 45m pass over a brisbane players head to Langdon 50m out in the pocket.  

[Young Angus 802]

Love Smith as sub.  

So long as Milkshake stays in and doesn't get replaced by Fritsch even when he's fit I'll be happy, Milkshake has the x-factor and not many others have it.  Fritsch is great, but he just hasn't had that "fire" for ages now.

I just don't want to see Milkshake lose his spot no matter who else is fit and healthy he deserves to stay in as starter.

[samcantstandya 1,058]

7 hours ago, P-man said:

Yeah okay you lot have swung me. I like what Spargs brings to the table when in form, but at this point in time Chandler has more to offer in offence and defence.

Chandler needs to excel at Casey b4 he comes back in. He was poor his last 1/2 dozen games for us.

[Great Northern Summer 708]

The side I probably see us going with in the finals, if we are at full strength:

B:          McVee          May                  Lever

HB:       Rivers           Petty                 Salem

C:          Hunter         Viney                 Langdon

HF:        Pickett         Van Rooyen      Neal-Bullen

F:          Melksham    Brown               Fritsch

R:          Gawn           Oliver                Petracca

I:           Sparrow       Bowey              Brayshaw            Chandler

S:         Smith

E:         Grundy         Hibbard            Tomlinson            Dunstan

[Jaded No More 68,974]

I really rate Adelaide. They have a good list and are building nicely. They move the ball very quickly and have a plethora of excellent forwards. 
They will come out breathing fire as they’re under the pump to win to keep their finals hopes alive. 
They also have Burgess who knows a thing or two about us.