If some people on here think that we are not being penalised pretty well every game they have severe visual incapacity..

MFCVM.

Injury List

Christian Petracca

Calf | Available

Some vision of Spargo's test:

1 hour ago, daisycutter said:

speaking of which, how come the mro haven't sanctioned buddy for staging. how come so little discussion on this bad decision (and kozzies) post game in the media

if it was the filth or the tigers they would have kicked up loudly

Exactly.

Big club Coaches would be bleating about the decisions.

There is a clear agenda IMO in the media to highlight certain things and overlook others.

 

Only one thing left to do....wintheflagandgrabthepointyendandstickitwhereitbelongs.

What about the excuse for Ginnivan's chicken wing not being cited. Oh they missed it. Still 6 days before his next game plenty of time to lay a charge.

7 hours ago, sue said:

The rule is interpreted stupidly as well.  If someone is zooming through the protected area and there is no way (short of tearing all his ligaments) to actually turn and affect the player with the ball, then ignore it.   So rather than players and umpires guessing where 15m is, let them guess 'could the player actually affect they player with the ball'.   If a player zooms past but is so close the umpire thinks he could have affected things, ping him.  If not, don''t.

It's a 10 metre protected area and Kozzie was double that away from Reid at all times. Disgraceful decision.

7 minutes ago, loges said:

What about the excuse for Ginnivan's chicken wing not being cited. Oh they missed it. Still 6 days before his next game plenty of time to lay a charge.

That non citing is worth more than all the frees he has missed, as he would have got 2 weeks. 

Oh that's right the MRO is Michael Christian and he played for ...........

Wouldn't be surprised if the AFL told him to ignore it, as it would create more controversy.

Disgraceful act, as even Dermie said, it was done to really hurt Dangerfield. 

Edited September 6, 20223 yr by Redleg

57 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Disgraceful act, as even Dermie said, it was done to really hurt Dangerfield. 

The reason why Danger couldnt remonstrate was because he was already on the ground, wonder if Blondie would’ve done anything if Paddy was upright? Seriously, Ginivan has something coming for him surely. A pity Adams (a tough but fair player) did his groin and not that little worm.

Sam Switkowski got 2 weeks for his chicken wing on Ginnivan earlier this season. On seeing this latest decision, Sam might think he’ll be getting an apology from the MRO. 

22 hours ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

Well ... if you can believe Goody on 360 just now .... Trac is no worries!

BTW ... This is my first post since the Swans debacle - that's how [censored] off iv'e been.

Hope you've recovered Uncle.  I won't ask how the maid is fairing. 

15 hours ago, Future of Aussie Rules said:

Sorry, but I come from the Allen Jakovich generation.

Gee, the similarities up forward from Trac and Jako are evident.

Maybe, this is the right time, especially with our problems with tall forwards, to push Ben Brown up the ground (CHF), and place Trac and Fritsch in the Goal square, with Kozzie/Spargs crumbing.

Or, open up the forward line completely, and let Trac go one on one, aka Jako.

We have not tried it yet.

Not a bad idea FAR but then we have the problem of being a rotation down through the middle.

1 hour ago, Redleg said:

It's a 10 metre protected area and Kozzie was double that away from Reid at all times. Disgraceful decision.

Is there some online vision of this other than trolling through the replay Red?

8 minutes ago, Demon Dynasty said:

Hope you've recovered Uncle.  I won't ask how the maid is fairing. 

Uncle B will duck down into the cellar and choose a dusty bottle (circa 1960 but the label is deteriorated)

And we know he'll settle down,... and invite the maid (Meredith is the Tuesday girl) to provide some comfort.

 

3 minutes ago, Hardley Benial said:

Uncle B will duck down into the cellar and choose a dusty bottle (circa 1960 but the label is deteriorated)

And we know he'll settle down,... and invite the maid (Meredith is the Tuesday girl) to provide some comfort.

 

Haha you seem to know an awful lot about BBO’s habits Handley. Is there something you want to tell us?

2 hours ago, Redleg said:

It's a 10 metre protected area and Kozzie was double that away from Reid at all times. Disgraceful decision.

The maggots knew what they were doing and carefully compounded and concocted three or four together  killer decisions to covertly bring our opposition back into the game.After the first one the smiles started coming back.and they pressed harder knowing that those maggots were about to let things roll.

The mark whistle started as well. In other words all they had to do Reid in particular was put the ball in both hands and the maggot had his whistle in his mouth that quick that he nearly swallowed it.

5 hours ago, Redleg said:

It was absolutely incorrect.

It was incorrect. Kozzie was miles away, eyes fixed elsewhere, accelerating forward. 

If Petracca moving about freely is an issue we could just play him out of the goal square 

Brisbane don't flood back like a lot of other teams (unless they change their tactics against us this time around)

In our 2 previous encounters against them this season our forward line has not been crowded and as a result, our forward line has functioned very well both times

So Petracca playing deep forward (up to a flank) would be a dangerous proposition for them.  And a potential match-winner for us

We've got enough quality in the midfield to cover for Christian (that might be a different story if we advance to an encounter against the Cats)

1 hour ago, Demon Dynasty said:

Is there some online vision of this other than trolling through the replay Red?

I have it but it won’t load on DL.

Get him a couple in the square.

7 hours ago, Dees_In_October said:

Some vision of Spargo's test:

Testing 

9 minutes ago, jimbo1982 said:

Great reference!