Team for Rd 2.

[grazman 7,436]

IN: Wheatley, Rivers, Bizzell, Godfrey

Out: McLean, Holland.

[grazman 7,436]

No match up for Benny, but I wonder how much Kosi's comments will affect the selection.

Personally I'd have Riv in for Holland, Wheaters for Ward and I'd replace Belly with Bizz in the back line and tell Daniel to play a run with role in the midfield (won't happen of course and they'll bring in Godders)

[tess 19]

HAWTHORN

B: Jacobs, Croad, Guerra

HB: Sewell, Gilham, Birchall

C: Ladson, Mitchell, Bateman

HF: Crawford, Franklin, Clarke

F: Williams, Boyle, Young

FOLL: Taylor, Hodge, Lewis

I/C from: Campbell, Ellis, McGlynn, Dixon, Roughead, Osborne, Brown

IN: Dixon, Crawford, Brown

OUT:

MELBOURNE

B: Bartram, Carroll, Whelan

HB: Ward, Rivers, Bell

C: Moloney, McDonald, Green

HF: Bruce, Miller, Robertson

F: Jamar, Neitz, Davey

FOLL: White, Jones, Johnstone

I/C from: Bate, Yze, C.Johnson, Brown, Bizzell, Godfrey, Wheatley

IN: Wheatley, Rivers, Brown, Bizzell, Godfrey

OUT: McLean (foot), Holland

[WonnaJurah 5]

hmm no brown, thats odd

[demon magik 0]

GOD help me if brown gets picked and Godfrey as well haven't we learnt our lesson with these two yet?

[The Chook Factor 0]

godders, brown and wheatly to miss for me

[grazman 7,436]

GOD help me if brown gets picked and Godfrey as well haven't we learnt our lesson with these two yet?

I'll absolutely spew if CJ gets dropped.

[demon magik 0]

I'll absolutely spew if CJ gets dropped.

so will a lot of our supporters mate... CJ does not deserve to get dropped none of the 3 you mentioned deserve a game unless we have a lot of injuries hasn't our coaching staff learnt that we are not going to get anymore from these 3 players ??

just shits me so much!

[Madness 44]

Wheaters to come in to play his 100th and obviously Jaz to come in from injury me thinks...

[Hards 2]

Does anyone want to point out the obivous here.

How can Ben Holland who was our BEST player vs St.Kilda get dropped?

Holland's in better form as a CHF than Miller and he hasn't played there for 12 months.

I'm vexed by this decision.

[demon magik 0]

How can Ben Holland who was our BEST player vs St.Kilda get dropped?

you have a good point there ...

what can you say its Melbourne they are unpredictable!

[Yze_Magic 3]

Holland dropped, Yze safe for the moment

A real slap in the face for Benny

Not good enough, MFC

[Hards 2]

Messers Johnstone, Bruce, Green, Yze and Miller underperform (routinely in some cases) and get saved.

B.Holland has 20-something and 10 marks against an avalanche of ball coming into the forward line and gets dropped.

Je ne comprehende pas.

[Hards 2]

Merged your thread in with this one Graz/Tess.

I take the point about no match up for Holland, but stick him up forward instead of or alongside Miller. At least Holland's actually in form, unlikely abnout 15 of his teammates.

Another defensive decision from the mastercoach.

[Gorgoroth 12,954]

disgrace!

if ward gets a game it will be a disgrace the guy cant hit a target in his own colours, the opponents yes.

yze should be dropped but we all know wont be

and godfrey is a major step backwards ESPECIALLY at the cost of a younger player who will improve

[tess 19]

Geelong showed some balls in dropping Josh Hunt, lets see whats happens at the selection table if (heaven forbid) we lose again.

[Yze_Magic 3]

Bench should be

Bate, Yze, C.Johnson, Wheatley

Emer - Brown, Bizzell, Godfrey

[Lord Travis 10,730]

What the [censored]? Holland dropped? Boy I feel sorry for him. I mean there isnt any obvious match up in defense, but that's a real slap int he face. He was one of, if not our best last week, and to be dropped so easily when someone like Yze has countless chances....just reeks of coaching panel etc playing favorites and not treating players equally and fairly. Bad outs, and probably bad Ins too this week. I feel cheated.

[Madness 44]

Dutchies stat sheet from last week meant nothing, like was said after the game on SEN, the saints just didn't pay him any attention because they didn't need to. Even if he had of got 40 possies, it wouldn't of hurt them at all as he's a terrible clumsy kick. Basically, they'd rather focus on more damaging player and weren't at all phased that he got a bit of it. Besides, I don't really see much of a matchup for him...

[Lord Travis 10,730]

Dutchies stat sheet from last week meant nothing, like was said after the game on SEN, the saints just didn't pay him any attention because they didn't need to. Even if he had of got 40 possies, it wouldn't of hurt them at all as he's a terrible clumsy kick. Basically, they'd rather focus on more damaging player and weren't at all phased that he got a bit of it. Besides, I don't really see much of a matchup for him...

You're right, stats dont mean anything. So, stats aside, he was still one of our best last week and you dont reward players who play well by dropping them, even if there isnt a match up. Just isnt fair on the guy. I mean Carroll was shocking last week, I'd drop him ahead of Holland if we were going by form here. Or talk about form, how about the much talked about Adem Yze, or Brad Miller? Even Bate was poor last week. Infact most of the team were. Regardless of whether the Saints let Holland do as he pleased, he still did it and did it well. To drop him sends out the wrong message to the other players. Play well, and we'll drop you due to match ups, coast along on reputation and youl'll be rewarded. Shouldnt be that way.

I'm off to the pub for the night to drown my sorrows, on a completely unrelated note. But poor Dutchy

[Demon15 0]

Does anyone want to point out the obivous here.

How can Ben Holland who was our BEST player vs St.Kilda get dropped?

Holland's in better form as a CHF than Miller and he hasn't played there for 12 months.

I'm vexed by this decision.

I suspect the view is that Holland has no match up, and in my view (although I wasn't at the game), there have been a few comments that the Saints were happy to allow him to have the ball as the drive from way back in defence dried up.

Maybe ND is looking for a more re-bounding style from half-back which many here have said is needed from last week.?

[Demon15 0]

What the [censored]? Holland dropped? Boy I feel sorry for him. I mean there isnt any obvious match up in defense, but ....

Youv'e just answered you own question.

Except for Yze, maybe ND doesn't award sympathy spots in the team - nor should he!

If Bizzell can get a spot on the bench, his added experience, along with the wonderful Rivers gives us a shot at keeping them to a losing score.

[monoccular 17,431]

hmm no brown, thats odd

What, do you want Ward, Brown and Godfrey in the same team???? U 12Ds do better re delivery precision.

[Redleg 40,926]

Does anyone want to point out the obivous here.

How can Ben Holland who was our BEST player vs St.Kilda get dropped?

Holland's in better form as a CHF than Miller and he hasn't played there for 12 months.

I'm vexed by this decision.

"Holland our best against the Saints". Well I was obviously at the wrong game last week. The bloke I saw get 20 uncontested possessions and turn over nearly every single one of them, our best player. Oh well.

Kosi on the radio said they left Holland alone and allowed him to get cheap possessions as they knew he couldn't dispose of the ball and their plan worked to perfection.

I will now look for the most possessions to pick my best player. I won't worry about how the possessions were obtained or what was done with them.

[Adzman 2,154]

Dropping Ben Holland after a blinder last week is as tasteless as asking a hooker is she would like to do the dishes after she has completed her "carnal duties".

Benny should not be dropped. He was one of the VERY few guys who gave it their all against the saints.

He deserves to play!