WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - HARLEY BENNELL

[Demon Dynasty 17,135]

2 hours ago, Engorged Onion said:

Whatever gets him over the line I say...

I suggest that will be a fair chunk of what we were planning to spend on Elliot....performance loaded of course!

[Redleg 42,039]

4 hours ago, hemingway said:

We simply do not need another player with a history of chronic injury. A waste of time and resources trying to get another player fit to play with the high risk that he will breakdown again. 

Chronic hamstring injury is something that never goes away. Footy is stop start and requires sudden acceleration like a sprinter coming out of the blocks time and time again. 

A no for me. 

Wrong injury Ernie, he had calf problems.

[DeeSpencer 26,478]

I'd still rather see him train with us and get picked up as a supplemental rookie after a period of training than race in with a list spot before we even know if he can run.

If other clubs are willing to give him a list spot straight up then we have a more difficult decision to make.

[Redleg 42,039]

2 hours ago, chookrat said:

If Bennell passes the medical I'd be very happy that we take him in the PSD. He fits our need for a skillful outside mid and is much better proven in this role compared to Jack Martin, who by comparison will cost at least $400k more. In reality he'd probably cost us $200k per annum on a two year deal at the expense of one of JKH, Stretch or KK as a list spot. This is an opportunity that is worth the risk. 

Don't need the PSD, he just declares his club and that is it.

[old dee 24,028]

1 minute ago, DeeSpencer said:

I'd still rather see him train with us and get picked up as a supplemental rookie after a period of training than race in with a list spot before we even know if he can run.

If other clubs are willing to give him a list spot straight up then we have a more difficult decision to make.

Why have Freo given up? 

[Redleg 42,039]

1 hour ago, Tony Tea said:

As I hear it, his ankle / Achilles / calf region is cactus. Won't play again.

Would love him fit and firing at Demonland. Exactly what we need.

Can't see it, tho.

Who you hearing IT from? Calf is his problem not ankle/achilles.

[Demon Dynasty 17,135]

2 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Wrong injury Ernie, he had calf problems.

??

[old dee 24,028]

We have a bevy of new medical gurus so I guess we have to trust them to make the right call.

But to be honest I don't have a good feeling about his ability both physical and mental to cut it at AFL level.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,457]

Can we get the Richmond doctor to check him out?

[ding 5,126]

Even if we dont end up taking the chance with Bennell, im really pleased that our club, which has a reputation for being ultra conservative, is at least taking the time to give him the once-over.

The supporters have been craving some risk-taking, and this is just another example of how our club has changed. (Trading up to pick 8 this year and risking the loss of a very high pick to North next year being another)

From the outside it COULD look like desperation, but from where i sit, this seems more like a club just willing to back itself, and its people, to identify risky choices that could have huge rewards.

Go for it Dees.

Edited October 29, 2019 by ding

[Redleg 42,039]

6 minutes ago, old dee said:

Why have Freo given up? 

Why did GWS give up on the bloke who played with us and then Patton?

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,525]

16 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

I'd still rather see him train with us and get picked up as a supplemental rookie after a period of training than race in with a list spot before we even know if he can run.

If other clubs are willing to give him a list spot straight up then we have a more difficult decision to make.

Yep- but as you’ve alluded to, there are big risks involved with that.  Would hate to see him carve up the track with is Dec-Jan only to see Hawthorn descend from on high to offer a contract that trumps ours.  If he joins a team for preseason, you can bet every club will be watching him very closely.

Have to back in our medical team.  If they think the can get him up and playing... I’m all for taking the risk.

[Ron Burgundy 8,588]

24 minutes ago, TRIGON said:

It could figuratively supercharge AND turbocharge our trade period!

And that's exactly what I'm looking for here.

Literally.

 

[Redleg 42,039]

You have to look at Bennell as the last pick in the draft, on a low contract and who you would ordinarily expect to play some games with Casey and then be delisted.

Anything better than that is a win.

[old dee 24,028]

8 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Why did GWS give up on the bloke who played with us and then Patton?

(A) they were paying too much for average talent

(B) chance of them regaining full fitness was uncertain.

 

[Go the Biff 3,473]

22 minutes ago, old dee said:

We have a bevy of new medical gurus so I guess we have to trust them to make the right call.

But to be honest I don't have a good feeling about his ability both physical and mental to cut it at AFL level.

I'm surprised his name alone doesn't give you the horrors old dee.

Your series of Jamie Bennell posts were classics !

[Redleg 42,039]

15 minutes ago, old dee said:

(A) they were paying too much for average talent

(B) chance of them regaining full fitness was uncertain.

 

In the case of the one who played for us, did you say average talent or average character?

[old dee 24,028]

34 minutes ago, Go the Biff said:

I'm surprised his name alone doesn't give you the horrors old dee.

Your series of Jamie Bennell posts were classics !

This one actually had the talent but sadly it was way to briefly shown and I doubt will be seen again.

[old dee 24,028]

27 minutes ago, Redleg said:

In the case of the one who played for us, did you say average talent or average character?

Take your pick.

[chook fowler 19,734]

4 hours ago, binman said:

I remember him destroying us a the G early in his career. Moved beautifully, got a tonne of possessions and from memory he might have kicked a few goals too. I remember thinking how much i would love for him to be be at the dees. 

If we can get him i'll be thrilled. One because of his talent, but as important if we do select him it means that the club has dome their homework and decided he  is ready to contribute physically and mentally ie they are not going to take a punt on him if they think he is a risk from a cultural perceptive 

 i remember that game. He and Ablett put on a master class. Unfortunately a lot has happened since then and i doubt his ability to return to that sort of form.

[Lucifers Hero 40,553]

A good update Harley Bennell

Reading between the lines Sydney are red hot, Geelong lukewarm and Demons don't get much of a mention. 

Thought this was interesting:  As a delisted free agent, Bennell is able to begin training with multiple clubs as of Friday, but if he does so he'll need to nominate for the draft.  If not, the 27-year-old can begin paid training with only one club from December 3, where he will join that club on a trial basis and will be eligible for practice and pre-season games. The club will then have the option of picking him up in the supplementary selection period.

We may get an early indication from Friday of his intentions.

[dieter 3,325]

No doubt Bennell can play. But so could Balic, Mitch Clarke, Kolodjashnij, Templeton, Owen, Vardy, Carman, Ellis and a host of other 'stars' we imported so we could park them on our injured list.

NO THANK YOU.

[Carn dees 108]

11 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

A good update Harley Bennell

Reading between the lines Sydney are red hot, Geelong lukewarm and Demons don't get much of a mention. 

Thought this was interesting:  As a delisted free agent, Bennell is able to begin training with multiple clubs as of Friday, but if he does so he'll need to nominate for the draft.  If not, the 27-year-old can begin paid training with only one club from December 3, where he will join that club on a trial basis and will be eligible for practice and pre-season games. The club will then have the option of picking him up in the supplementary selection period.

We may get an early indication from Friday of his intentions.

so does this mean he gets to nominate which club he wants to train with?

And basically if he goes into the national draft any club can draft him with any given draft selection?

[defuture15 902]

Have the best people in our medical/conditioning department now. I would be concerned for him if they decline.

[Lucifers Hero 40,553]

3 minutes ago, Carn dees said:

so does this mean he gets to nominate which club he wants to train with?

And basically if he goes into the national draft any club can draft him with any given draft selection?

That is how I read it.

As a DFA he can avoid the draft it he trains with just one club from this week.  I read it as he goes into the draft only if he trains with multiple clubs.  Could be wrong.