On 10/10/2018 at 22:41, Jaded said:

I've never wanted him to go, while I thought he was committed to the club. 

Now it is clear that he is not committed, so I want him gone. 

There is no point holding onto even the best players, if they are not firmly embedded in what you are trying to achieve.

If Hogan signs a 4 year extension and stays, and doesn't umms and errs about his future every year, I would be thrilled. But he has never done that, and we now have a chance to trade him to significantly better our list. It's time to go. 

Could not agree more  Jaded

This has been an ongoing sore ever since We got Hoges

Best to finish and move on. By the way team balance is better without him 

Hope Freo can make him happy and get him to lose the poor attitude and bad body language

I for one would rather he go

Freo trading pick 6 to Port for one of 10/11 and a pick in the 20s.

 

Damn you @DavidNeitz9 and your quick clicking.

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:17, DavidNeitz9 said:

 

Ok, now we are cooking.

Sam McLure thinks pick 10 is enough for Jesse. [censored].

It's cooking now!

Praying for 10/11 and the pick that Freo get from Brisbane for Neale.

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:17, johndemonic said:

 

Assuming this goes down and then we do the Hogan deal which pick are we using to get May?

a) Freo's pick 5 or 6

b) Freo's pick 10 or 11?

Obviously b is much better because then we can use pick 5/6 on a top draft pick

Is this goodbye . Pick 9 and 10 seems fair

  On 10/10/2018 at 19:58, Petraccattack said:

Jesus, I thought trade period ended tomorrow.   This garbage goes for another week.

Only Gillon’s AFL could have a trade week that lasts two weeks, and a goal square that is an absurdly long rectangle.

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:21, Dirts said:

Is this goodbye

So long, farewell, auf wiedersehen, goodbye

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:21, Dirts said:

Is this goodbye . Pick 9 and 10 seems fair

Freo aren't getting both, it's one of 9 or 10 and a pick in the 20's. 

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:20, Clintosaurus said:

Sam McLure thinks pick 10 is enough for Jesse. [censored].

His value seems to diminish by the day.

He is an absolute muppet.

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:20, Clintosaurus said:

Sam McLure thinks pick 10 is enough for Jesse. [censored].

I wish Dal would slap him

Should be two 1 rounds or nothing. 

9 and 10 is good

9 and 20 with future 2 Nd rounder ok

Neale to brisbane for 5

hogan to freo 5, 10

Kent to saints for pick 39

Tyson, 10, + 39 - for may and KK

 

 

 

Edited October 10, 20186 yr by red and blue forever
new information

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:26, DSP said:

His value seems to diminish by the day.

He is an absolute muppet.

Colin Sylvia back and pick 100

done

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:20, Clintosaurus said:

Sam McLure thinks pick 10 is enough for Jesse. [censored].

I won't listen to trade radio when he is on.

Mind you I've pretty much stopped listening to all of them.

Bartel is really the only one I don't mind listening to.

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:17, johndemonic said:

 

5&10 for hogan 

22 for lobb

everyone wins. 

Edited October 10, 20186 yr by Patches O’houlihan

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:29, Patches O’houlihan said:

5&10 for hogan 

22 for lobb

everyone wins. 

Agreed as long as 10 can be used for May.

 

 

The more I listen to or read what Sam McClure has to say the more I'm convinced he was intentionally dropped on his head as a baby.

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:09, Axis of Bob said:

No, you're now saying that instead of a Porsche I would get a Malvern Star.

I would want more than just pick 5, and we'll get more. It's the amount not that we differ on.

You originally wanted 3 low picks or no deal. I thought we'd get a low first rounder plus a later first rounder/equivalent player.

The main thing you are missing in these negotiations is opportunity cost. Are you willing to spend it on upgrading the second pick we get for Hogan, or are you willing to spend it on potential deals that may happen later in the trade period?

I think I said I would ask for 2 low picks and a player or another pick or whatever, but that was the opening price. Obviously that would then be negotiated down. 

I have since posted  recently, about an hour ago,  that I actually don't care what the deal is, as long as we ended up with May, KK and pick 5.

We could then do what we wanted with pick 5.

What I would be upset about, is a May for Hogan deal with nothing else. 

Of course I would be happy to upgrade our position. I am just not as in a hurry to fold and accept a poor offer as others on here.

There is still time to do deals and I think the FD have it in hand atm.

If we are at wednesday afternoon and nothing has happened, then that is a different scenario, which I am confident we would have prepared for with contingency plans.

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:20, Clintosaurus said:

Sam McLure thinks pick 10 is enough for Jesse. [censored].

If Hogan was a Carlton player McLure would be demanding two top 5 picks and a gun young player in return.

  On 10/10/2018 at 23:26, DSP said:

His value seems to diminish by the day.

He is an absolute muppet.

 

DONE DEAL | Fremantle has traded its Rd 1 (6), and its Future Round Three Selection to Port Adelaide for its Rd 1 (11), Rd 2 (23), Rd 2 (30), Rd 3 (49)