•  

• Report post
•  
•  #1

Posted 17 hours ago

Jones - 6

Viney - 7

Jetta - 6 

O.McDonald - 6

Smith - 5

Lewis - 6

Frost - 8 

Salem - 7

Stretch - 7 

Oliver - 10 

Gawn - 9

Fritch - 7

Melksham - 6

T. McDonald - 7

Spargo - 4

Hogan - 7

Neal-Bullen - 6

Garlett - 6

Hibberd - 7 

Brayshaw - 7 

Harmes - 7

Petracca - 7

Harsh on Spargo he was good. Smith was our worst player.

Good thread keep it up fence.

Gee . . . a 10 on your first outing Fence. I remember the controversy when Teaser (that wonderful Collingwood and Richmond champion) was given the first 10 by The Sun in '77. Here you are, 40 years later, blowing the whole thing to the shisen hausen. Freak'in me out Bro. 

Fritsch and Salem both underrated here mate.

Petracca also tbh

the rest I think is good.

You've shown another side to yourself here Picket. I was expecting a series of 2s and 3s. 

In fact, I think you were too gentle on some. Melksham a point for each effective disposal? 

...works beautifully Fence....

Demonland has now reduced football reporting to 1 number and 3 words.....I like it!

Edited July 8, 20187 yr by george_on_the_outer

5 hours ago, picket fence said:

•  

• Report post
•  
•  #1

Posted 17 hours ago

Jones - 6

Viney - 7

Jetta - 6 

O.McDonald - 6

Smith - 5

Lewis - 6

Frost - 8 

Salem - 7

Stretch - 7 

Oliver - 10 

Gawn - 9

Fritch - 7

Melksham - 6

T. McDonald - 7

Spargo - 4

Hogan - 7

Neal-Bullen - 6

Garlett - 6

Hibberd - 7 

Brayshaw - 7 

Harmes - 7

Petracca - 7

ANB- 6 are you on drugs?

Soft on melksham 

good fun though . Full season 19 major prize a wedgewood spitoon and 6l of mcguigan merlot

Fair effort, Frost was good but an 8 equates as the third best player on the field. There were 5 or 6 better than Frost imo.

8 hours ago, Dee Zephyr said:

Fair effort, Frost was good but an 8 equates as the third best player on the field. There were 5 or 6 better than Frost imo.

Yeah just liked his spoils, a bit of run and carry and pace, just liked him back in the team. A bit generous maybe but...

Meh. Next time just use the joeboy thread. 

Picket, stop being an attention queen.

Theres only one joeboy.

Edited July 9, 20187 yr by Petraccattack

Well done, provides another view / feeling of the players!

 

1 hour ago, Nasher said:

Meh. Next time just use the joeboy thread. 

Don't listen to him Picket. Fencescore deserves it's own thread.

You are a legend Picket?

You are becoming very negative Nasher what has happened to you?

A bit of me time for @picket fence... like

Only a 7 for 20 contested posessions and a pb for petracca. Harsh. At least a 7.5 I'd have thought.

O mac was hardly sighted - 3 max

11 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

Don't listen to him Picket. Fencescore deserves it's own thread.

You are a legend Picket?

You are becoming very negative Nasher what has happened to you?

Mate, I’ve been grumpy about people starting new threads when the existing ones would do since day one!

3 hours ago, Nasher said:

Mate, I’ve been grumpy about people starting new threads when the existing ones would do since day one!

I seem to recall a few people should say he should have his own thread for it.

Maybe you could block creation of new threads without your moderation.

 

1 hour ago, timbo said:

I seem to recall a few people should say he should have his own thread for it.

Maybe you could block creation of new threads without your moderation.

 

Gents happy to keep the peace and tag this along with Joeboy's thread if u like. 

I just rather liked the way Sunscore worked in the seventies and eighties and provides a number value out of 10 for performance taking into consideration players form. I spose a 5 is considered a satisfactory game but would think at this level a 6 is what you would be at least aiming for. 7 A good game, 8 Very good game, 9 Excellent and 10 Outstanding. You don't want to be at 4 or under!

3 hours ago, picket fence said:

Gents happy to keep the peace and tag this along with Joeboy's thread if u like. 

I just rather liked the way Sunscore worked in the seventies and eighties and provides a number value out of 10 for performance taking into consideration players form. I spose a 5 is considered a satisfactory game but would think at this level a 6 is what you would be at least aiming for. 7 A good game, 8 Very good game, 9 Excellent and 10 Outstanding. You don't want to be at 4 or under!

Fencescore doesn't work with Joeboy's thread it's not 3 words. Keep your own thread Picket

Keep it up Picket. As a maths teacher (retired) I'm good with numbers, but me grammer is lousy. I struggle with Joeboy's posts.