Post Match Discussion - Round 4

[dieter 3,325]

I'll just throw this amongst the pidgeons who are flucking off:

MATT Burgan looks at the stories, stats and surprises in his weekly column.

Summary
Yep, Sunday was a shocker, no question. But let’s not throw the toys out of the cot. It was far from the end of the world – or the season for that matter. Remember, Melbourne wasn’t playing an average team. It came up against an opponent that has made the finals all but twice since 2006. It’s also worth noting that a certain side that went down to St Kilda by 67 points in round 16 last year – the same margin Melbourne lost to against the Hawks on Sunday – ended up winning the flag. And for the record, Richmond was smashed by the Crows to the tune of 76 points in round six last year.

[beelzebub 23,313]

We were given a training drill by the walking wounded fcs !!

[DemonOX 8,783]

30 minutes ago, dieter said:

I'll just throw this amongst the pidgeons who are flucking off:

MATT Burgan looks at the stories, stats and surprises in his weekly column.

Summary
Yep, Sunday was a shocker, no question. But let’s not throw the toys out of the cot. It was far from the end of the world – or the season for that matter. Remember, Melbourne wasn’t playing an average team. It came up against an opponent that has made the finals all but twice since 2006. It’s also worth noting that a certain side that went down to St Kilda by 67 points in round 16 last year – the same margin Melbourne lost to against the Hawks on Sunday – ended up winning the flag. And for the record, Richmond was smashed by the Crows to the tune of 76 points in round six last year.

And there in lies the problem “excuses”. 

How long have we been doing this for, 12 seasons now! I think it’s safe to say that the toys are well and truely out of the cot by now  

My god it seem like our team will never change their habits. 

[Wiseblood 24,637]

1 hour ago, Big Carl said:

Goodwin said in his post match press conference that "Hawthorn were structurally set up better".

Isn't that part of the coaches role?

Staggering!!

Clearly the quote is in reference to the fact that the Hawks held their structures far better than we did on the day.  The manner of the loss is proof of that.  As soon as the Hawks turned up the heat and we wasted a few chances we dropped our bundle a bit, didn't set up our structures as normal, and got the hiding we deserved for it.

[beelzebub 23,313]

3 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Clearly the quote is in reference to the fact that the Hawks held their structures far better than we did on the day.  The manner of the loss is proof of that.  As soon as the Hawks turned up the heat and we wasted a few chances we dropped our bundle a bit, didn't set up our structures as normal, and got the hiding we deserved for it.

Held structure...or simply had a better one ?

[Demons11 6,915]

F@#k me, talk about an overreaction on here.  Granted it was a horrible loss but it’s 1 game for gods sake.  

Bulldogs, Collingwood and  Essendon have had horrible losses but have shown that it can be turned around a week later.  I also recall Tigers losing by 80 pts to Adelaide last year and they still went on to win a flag. 

Keep things in perspective people and stop being influenced by the media who are just looking to make a headline. 

 

Edited April 16, 2018 by Demons11

[monoccular 17,413]

On 15/04/2018 at 6:03 PM, Watts the matter said:

Could barely watch the 2nd half as the international streaming service wouldn't work.

Pathetic prior to that. Too many dumb footballers, grab the ball when they should tap it, tap it to the wrong side, and our backline will never be able to compete with a quick small forward (hint, hint, next week).

Slow defenders: McDonald, Jetta, Wagner, Vince, Lever, Lewis.

Forwards and midfield lack class and smarts.

As always too many players jumping for marks, no one staying down. 

Bugg has to go, kills the momentum to often. Thought he was crap last week even when he kicked the goals, got away with multiple fumbles in that game. This week decided to add the handball to a player under more pressure. By the end of the game he was too scared to even kick for goal and hand balling to Harmes under more pressure on his wrong side.

Lever, it continues. Look forward to hearing from his fanboys. 

Tough to find a player who won their position.

 

 

On 15/04/2018 at 6:14 PM, fired up said:

Rebook the camp for the bye week, and if anyone sooks up, delist them.

Need to weed out the mentally week players.

The Hawks managed that pretty well actually.

On 15/04/2018 at 6:25 PM, DV8 said:

........

This has been going on at Melbourne for decades now Under game pressure

 

We do not handle our own supporters negativity on game day.

 

The players try harder and harder, until they end up trying so hard, they lose objectivity...  and they become harassed within their own minds.

 

From that point, the game is as good as gone.

 

---------------------------------------------------------

 

we our our own worst enemies on gamedays.

.

lets take it out on the opposition,,,,, instead of our own players.

.

Leave the venom and critique for during the week days Melbourne..

 

.

And they don't handle the supporters positivity too well in the lead up to critical games like C'wood last year, and Hawks Sunday.

Just get so far ahead of themselves.

I reckon at quarter time they were counting their winning margin, at least in their minds.

On 15/04/2018 at 6:37 PM, martin said:

In pre season previews the much maligned Mark Robinson left us out of the 8 because we cant be trusted. Dont like him but its hard to argue after this insipid performance.

Cannot tolerate the man, but he is spot on on that one. 

They lost my trust yet again round 23 2017,  and any minimum trust they may have started to regain has completely vanished after Sunday.

22 hours ago, DeeZee said:

Teams like Richmond can make a commitment at the start of the year to be mentally stronger and give 100% of tough strong Footy for four quarters.

So did Bulldogs the previous year.

So why can’t we?

Talent alone never does it.

We are soft and mentally weak.

Mentally strong .... what is that???

Edited April 16, 2018 by monoccular

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

Robbo on AFL 360 thinks we're [censored].... phew I'm not so worried anymore.

But on a serious note, I am not going to Panic until Round 10. We should be 6 - 4, maybe 5 & 5 or it could be worse and season over.....

But if we manage to be 6 and 4, get Viney and T Mac back I won't be too upset

Truth sadly is we struggle without No.7. Our kids haven't stepped up just yet.

[leave it to deever 17,511]

7 hours ago, Mazer Rackham said:

What, they're only grappling with that now?

They need to have "that" discussion pre engagement.

Some of us dealt it a long time since. Still the only DEMONS fan in this household.

A prenuptial perhaps.

What have I done to my poor son? 

Why should I suffer alone. 

[picket fence 17,041]

22 hours ago, DeeZee said:

Teams like Richmond can make a commitment at the start of the year to be mentally stronger and give 100% of tough strong Footy for four quarters.

So did Bulldogs the previous year.

So why can’t we?

Talent alone never does it.

We are soft and mentally weak.

And have been for a million years ex of 87 which was just sheer bad luck and incapacity of Umpire Howlett to hear a siren!

Yep Mentally very weak 

Would Not, Could not commit to a training camp!! 

Well Goody as Alice Cooper once sang!

"No more Mr Nice Guy"

Either he becomes like Barrassi or he will be confined to the mediocrity of so many coaches we have had since Norm Smith 

( Apologies to John Northey who was ahead of his time in people management!)

Well Simon???

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

2 minutes ago, picket fence said:

And have been for a million years ex of 87 which was just sheer bad luck and incapacity of Umpire Howlett to hear a siren!

Yep Mentally very weak 

Would Not, Could not commit to a training camp!! 

Well Goody as Alice Cooper once sang!

"No more Mr Nice Guy"

Either he becomes like Barrassi or he will be confined to the mediocrity of so many coaches we have had since Norm Smith 

( Apologies to John Northey who was ahead of his time in people management!)

Well Simon???

Simon doesn't care what you think @picket fence

 

[Pates 9,659]

So I've avoided D-land for the day, that was just a shocking performance that left me bewildered as to how a team that had prided itself on being hard at the footy and exciting at times could put in such a shocker.

I'm hoping that that's what it was, a shocker that will hopefully wake us up. We were so uncompetitive and completely rolled over for a half of footy, and that isn't the team I feel we've been watching for the last couple of years (even back to Roos).

The good thing about this happening at this time of year is that redemption can only be a week away. They've got to hit the track hard this week and atone for that non-effort.

[jackaub 1,402]

2 hours ago, Big Carl said:

Goodwin said in his post match press conference that "Hawthorn were structurally set up better".

Isn't that part of the coaches role?

Staggering!!

The man looks completely lost on game day

I really am concerned about his IWQ when he speaks in interview 

A dud methinks

 

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

58 minutes ago, DemonOX said:

And there in lies the problem “excuses”. 

How long have we been doing this for, 12 seasons now! I think it’s safe to say that the toys are well and truely out of the cot by now  

My god it seem like our team will never change their habits. 

I agree,

Rather then the boring post game analysis I want this....

Love pop.... Goody make it happen. Also pop sums up our day pretty accurately 

 

Edited April 16, 2018 by Unleash Hell

[Sir Why You Little 36,963]

3 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Viney?

Edit: I see his name has already been suggested. Either way, he’s the exact player we are missing right now. Funnily enough it were Viney and McDonald who dragged us over the line against West Coast last season. Brute force is exactly what Viney possessed in that game. 

He did. The night he got injured

The curse

[John Crow Batty 8,861]

Well the apologists say this a just a horrible loss but this is the second in the last five rounds we played and are 2/3 for this mini horror run. And aside from squandering a long overdue finals berth. Yep rising with a bullet we are.

Edited April 16, 2018 by america de cali

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

56 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

F@#k me, talk about an overreaction on here.  Granted it was a horrible loss but it’s 1 game for gods sake.  

Bulldogs, Collingwood and  Essendon have had horrible losses but have shown that it can be turned around a week later.  I also recall Tigers losing by 80 pts to Adelaide last year and they still went on to win a flag. 

Keep things in perspective people and stop being influenced by the media who are just looking to make a headline. 

 

Yes, some strange results can occur.

Of those teams you mentioned ... Dogs Pies Dons Tigs ... are any of them renowned for not having a dip?

Are any of them renowned for dropping games they should win? Not one off but repeatedly?

Are any of them renowned for being soft and folding every time the heat is on?

 

We are at a major crossroads. Next game is season defining and if it all goes wrong, may be the one we look back on as the coach killer.

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

2 minutes ago, america de cali said:

Well the apologists say this a just a horrible loss but this is the second in the last five rounds we played and are 2/3 for this mini horror run. Aside from squandering a finals berth. Yep rising with a bullet we are.

'No one plays finals in rd 5

[John Crow Batty 8,861]

Just now, Unleash Hell said:

'No one plays finals in rd 5

5 rounds ago we did.

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

Just now, america de cali said:

5 rounds ago we did.

And that affected this game how?

[Demons11 6,915]

2 minutes ago, Mazer Rackham said:

Yes, some strange results can occur.

Of those teams you mentioned ... Dogs Pies Dons Tigs ... are any of them renowned for not having a dip?

Are any of them renowned for dropping games they should win? Not one off but repeatedly?

Are any of them renowned for being soft and folding every time the heat is on?

 

We are at a major crossroads. Next game is season defining and if it all goes wrong, may be the one we look back on as the coach killer.

In answer to your questions, the answer is yes to all. 

[Hot as Hell 466]

59 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

F@#k me, talk about an overreaction on here.  Granted it was a horrible loss but it’s 1 game for gods sake.  

Bulldogs, Collingwood and  Essendon have had horrible losses but have shown that it can be turned around a week later.  I also recall Tigers losing by 80 pts to Adelaide last year and they still went on to win a flag. 

Keep things in perspective people and stop being influenced by the media who are just looking to make a headline. 

 

Demoms11, you must have missed round 1. 

The Dees lost to an injury plagued Geelong who played with a couple of debutantes that collectively put us away. 

That makes 2 losses and 2 unconvincing wins against bottom 4 sides. 

Goody' "silver tongue" will find a way to take this year as a positive. Regrettably, very few will buy it. 

No more excuses. Our game day narrow visioned game plan has been exposed and exploited. We are looking like mugs when teams go over the top of our defenceless forward press. 

Roos will be livid that his years of teaching players to defend has been tossed out. 

Please go back to coaching school Goody, we need a new plan that the players can execute. 

 

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

3 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

In answer to your questions, the answer is yes to all. 

I'm watching Australian Rules Football, AFL comp. What are you watching?

[Demons11 6,915]

9 minutes ago, Hot as Hell said:

Demoms11, you must have missed round 1. 

The Dees lost to an injury plagued Geelong who played with a couple of debutantes that collectively put us away. 

That makes 2 losses and 2 unconvincing wins against bottom 4 sides. 

Goody' "silver tongue" will find a way to take this year as a positive. Regrettably, very few will buy it. 

No more excuses. Our game day narrow visioned game plan has been exposed and exploited. We are looking like mugs when teams go over the top of our defenceless forward press. 

Roos will be livid that his years of teaching players to defend has been tossed out. 

Please go back to coaching school Goody, we need a new plan that the players can execute. 

 

Injury plaqued Geelong?? 

We lost by 3 pts. 

Turn it up mate 

[picket fence 17,041]

So many apologists on this site!!

Do I need to remind you all that we have had 54 years 54 without premiership success?

MFC ??HEARTLESS, SOULESS AND unfortunately I cannot get away!

I feel like that Dr. Who Episode " Mawrdryn Undead"