On 8/1/2018 at 8:24 PM, layzie said:

Yeah it’s pretty strange, he even did an interview on The Sunday Footy show and we were none the wiser. 

who can be bothered watching that show???

2 minutes ago, DV8 said:

who can be bothered watching that show???

It wasn’t by choice trust me. 

1 hour ago, layzie said:

It wasn’t by choice trust me. 

LoL I only commented as I tried to watch it the last week & it is just more of the same old garbbb.   billy and the crew.   the boys bickering first thing and ego's galore...

 

figjam show. its reemerging at 9 again.  

judd now,  on Footy class...  is another  figjam.

 

 

 

No wonder C@rtoon are struggling.   Ego Central

                                                                                                                                                                                   

I wonder If Fitzy will get Gill'  to give them a Priority Pick, even in Comm Fitszy's absence.

Edited August 7, 20186 yr by DV8

1 hour ago, DV8 said:

LoL I only commented as I tried to watch it the last week & it is just more of the same old garbbb.   billy and the crew.   the boys bickering first thing and ego's galore...

 

figjam show. its reemerging at 9 again.  

judd now,  on Footy class...  is another  figjam.

 

 

 

No wonder C@rtoon are struggling.   Ego Central

                                                                                                                                                                                   

I wonder If Fitzy will get Gill'  to give them a Priority Pick, even in Comm Fitszy's absence.

Pretty much. It’s been the same for a long long time. 

On 8/5/2018 at 7:52 PM, ding said:

I feel so bad for Joel Smith. Before the injury, he was playing probably his best game for the club, and his attack on the contest was bloody great.

Balls the size of watermelons that kid.

Hope you make it back next year Joel, i rate you.

If he's able to play with this affliction, I'm surprised he even noticed the pain from the broken collarbone.

It’s rising up unfortunately week by week

Stretch. Lever. Maynard all gone for the season

Joel Smith and Baker virtually gone as well

Jack Viney is increasingly unlikely for the year

Balic retired 

thats 7 unavailable out of the 44 listed

Vince????

Hibberd and Melksham back round 22

from my best 22, missing 4 players (Lever Viney Hibberd Melksham)

 

40 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

It’s rising up unfortunately week by week

Stretch. Lever. Maynard all gone for the season

Joel Smith and Baker virtually gone as well

Jack Viney is increasingly unlikely for the year

Balic retired 

thats 7 unavailable out of the 44 listed

Vince????

Hibberd and Melksham back round 22

from my best 22, missing 4 players (Lever Viney Hibberd Melksham)

 

Vince out for the year AC joint.

15 minutes ago, trout said:

Vince out for the year AC joint.

What, is this confirmed ?

I see... http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2018-08-11/vince-to-miss-rest-of-the-season

Horrible luck for Vince who came to the club at its lowest ebb and helped lead our young brigade.

I still saw a place for him in the team, really feel for him.

Poor Bern, he spoke so many times about what it would mean to play finals for the MFC...

16 minutes ago, sisso said:

Poor Bern, he spoke so many times about what it would mean to play finals for the MFC...

Fuc&)n cursed

Very gutted about that. Just hope he's not running around in stupid GC colours 'mentoring' next year.

Update:

out for season   - Lever Hogan Stretch Maynard Vince

likely out for season - Viney Baker 

Out 1-2weeks J smith

out 2-4 weeks Hunt

retired Balic

10 men down, but really 3 out of my best 22 (Viney Lever Hogan) so still hope

jetta. Omcd. Hibberd 

salem. Frost. Lewis

harmes. Jones. Brayshaw 

petracca tmcd anb

garlett Weideman Fritsch 

gawn Tyson oliver 

Melksham jkh Kent Vandenburg 

Outs Spargo Hunt Pedersen Hogan 

ins  Weideman Kent Hibberd Melksham 

If l hear anyone on this forum say that we are not doctors and we should back the clubs sports science and medical teams l will throw up. Hogan clearly had a significant injury during the game,  why bring him back on if you don’t know how serious it is? “We feel we have got it quite early”. More rubbish from Misson

35 minutes ago, Demons1858 said:

If l hear anyone on this forum say that we are not doctors and we should back the clubs sports science and medical teams l will throw up. Hogan clearly had a significant injury during the game,  why bring him back on if you don’t know how serious it is? “We feel we have got it quite early”. More rubbish from Misson

Stretch, Viney and Hogan all played out games with sore feet. Not good and mind boggling considering previous foot injuries 

4 hours ago, Demons1858 said:

If l hear anyone on this forum say that we are not doctors and we should back the clubs sports science and medical teams l will throw up. Hogan clearly had a significant injury during the game,  why bring him back on if you don’t know how serious it is? “We feel we have got it quite early”. More rubbish from Misson

You don’t know that you’re not a doctor! ?

Nah it is pretty frustrating. We have the right to at least ask the questions. 

FWIW. James Hird missed all but two games of the 1999 season with a serious navicular injury. Came back to captain a premiership team in 2000. Won subsequent B & F's and AA selections.There is hope for Jesse with an injury that appears a lot less serious and apparently caught earlier. 

5 hours ago, Demons1858 said:

If l hear anyone on this forum say that we are not doctors and we should back the clubs sports science and medical teams l will throw up. Hogan clearly had a significant injury during the game,  why bring him back on if you don’t know how serious it is? “We feel we have got it quite early”. More rubbish from Misson

Stress fractures don't "happen" they "develop". So what you wrote didn't happen. 

13 hours ago, Demons1858 said:

If l hear anyone on this forum say that we are not doctors and we should back the clubs sports science and medical teams l will throw up. Hogan clearly had a significant injury during the game,  why bring him back on if you don’t know how serious it is? “We feel we have got it quite early”. More rubbish from Misson

You have literally zero ability to say he "clearly had a significant injury during the game" unless you are Hogan, and you told the club "guys I have a significant injury" but the club said "lol no you don't get back out there", or you're a doctor and you're able to explain how Hogan reporting mild foot soreness equates to "significant injury during the game".

Melbourne injury list: round 22

Michael Hibberd (quadriceps) – available
Jake Melksham (hamstring) – available
Joel Smith (collarbone) – 1-2 weeks
Jayden Hunt (ankle) – 2-4 weeks  
Jack Viney (toe) – 3 weeks
Billy Stretch (toe) – season
Oskar Baker (hamstring) – 6 weeks
Bernie Vince (AC joint) – 6 weeks
Jesse Hogan (foot) – season
Jake Lever (knee) – season
Corey Maynard (hip) – season

8 minutes ago, Chelly said:

Melbourne injury list: round 22

Michael Hibberd (quadriceps) – available
Jake Melksham (hamstring) – available
Joel Smith (collarbone) – 1-2 weeks
Jayden Hunt (ankle) – 2-4 weeks  
Jack Viney (toe) – 3 weeks
Billy Stretch (toe) – season
Oskar Baker (hamstring) – 6 weeks
Bernie Vince (AC joint) – 6 weeks
Jesse Hogan (foot) – season
Jake Lever (knee) – season
Corey Maynard (hip) – season

I wonder how much this is going to hurt Casey they are starting to play players from the bottom of the barrell, wouldn't surprise me if we lost to Box Hill this week.

On 8/15/2018 at 9:00 PM, WERRIDEE said:

I wonder how much this is going to hurt Casey they are starting to play players from the bottom of the barrell, wouldn't surprise me if we lost to Box Hill this week.

You were right WERRIDEE and the run of injuries continues. Lochie Filipovic broke his hand in that game and is out for 426.

Jayden Hunt and Joel Smith will be tested later in the week and Jack Viney is working towards a return in the finals. It wouldn’t surprise me if he was given a run in the VFL finals game during the AFL bye week to get some match fitness.

Melbourne injury list: round 23
 
Michael Hibberd (corked hamstring) – available
Jayden Hunt (ankle) – test
Joel Smith (collarbone) – test
Jack Viney (toe) – 2 weeks
Oskar Baker (hamstring) – 4 weeks
Lochie Filipovic (hand) – 4-6 weeks
Bernie Vince (AC joint) – 4-6 weeks
Jesse Hogan (foot) – season
Jake Lever (knee) – season
Corey Maynard (hip) – season
Billy Stretch (toe) – season
Harley Balic (retired)

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2018-08-21/hibberd-set-to-play-duo-to-face-tests

Good news with Hibberd to play vs GWS, and Joel Smith ahead of schedule undergoing a fitness test this week . Thats great news after it looked like he might be done for the season when he got hurt.  And on top of that, Bernie is still a chance to return if we advance past week 1 of finals.

The more players available in September the better.

 

Another 2 down today. Injury list is about 12 deep now. 

Hope Viney and Hunt get back for week 1 if finals. 

2 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Another 2 down today. Injury list is about 12 deep now. 

Hope Viney and Hunt get back for week 1 if finals. 

Hunt and Smith should both be available, but it’s pretty hard to see where they fit. Viney is apparently a lock.