I don't think I've ever uttered the phrase "thank god for Jake Spencer" but kept a close eye on him during the JLT and he has learnt a lot from Max. He was consistently winning hit-outs to advantage and at times looked superior to the All-Australian with his tap work. Max is obviously a leader, more mobile, and better around the ground, but I wouldn't be surprised if Jakey announces himself on the big stage and really takes it up to Sandilands. It will be a much more even contest at stoppages than many outside 'experts' are predicting.

1 hour ago, TickleMeTyson said:

I don't think I've ever uttered the phrase "thank god for Jake Spencer" but kept a close eye on him during the JLT and he has learnt a lot from Max. He was consistently winning hit-outs to advantage and at times looked superior to the All-Australian with his tap work. Max is obviously a leader, more mobile, and better around the ground, but I wouldn't be surprised if Jakey announces himself on the big stage and really takes it up to Sandilands. It will be a much more even contest at stoppages than many outside 'experts' are predicting.

It'll take more than just tap work this week

23 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

It'll take more than just tap work this week

Back the kid in ffs.

6 minutes ago, praha said:

Back the kid in ffs.

Seen nothing to excite in all these years

4 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

Seen nothing to excite in all these years

not surprising, your avatar looks like she's wearing a blindfold.  Take it off and you'll find there is a bit of excitement about.

Spencer was great in the JLT, was getting taps taking grabs kicking goals, he will be great and take his chance at being number 1, anyone comparing him to gawn is just silly as they are very different,  I am excited to see what he brings 

1 minute ago, sue said:

not surprising, your avatar looks like she's wearing a blindfold.  Take it off and you'll find there is a bit of excitement about.

Leave Natalie out of this

Teams are in!

Melbourne team: round four

B: Jake Melksham, Tom McDonald, Jayden Hunt

HB: Neville Jetta, Sam Frost, Nathan Jones

C: Bernie Vince, Clayton Oliver, Billy Stretch

HF: Dean Kent, Sam Weideman, James Harmes

F: Jeff Garlett, Jack Watts, Christian Petracca

Foll: Jake Spencer, Dom Tyson, Jack Viney

I/C: Christian Salem, Mitch Hannan, Alex Neal-Bullen, Tom Bugg

Emg: Jack Trengove, Oscar McDonald, Tim Smith

In: Frost, Bugg, Spencer

Out: Max Gawn (hamstring), O.McDonald, T.Smith 

Frost, Bugg, Spencer in for Oscar, Smith and Gawn... Interesting. 

Woah, Oscar and Smith out. Frost and Bugg in.

Go for it.

Well oscar out should please some people 

Weideman is very very very lucky....

Have to confess to being surprised by the Frost inclusion. Not because he's not up to it, I'm a fan, even though he has a long way to go. But he's coming off a long injury lay-off, and has only had, what, ½ and 3/4 of two practise matches at Casey.

Still, presumably the selectors think he's ready.

Smith a bit stiff, given that he wasn't the only forward who under-performed but so be it. With Hogan due back next week, Hannan and Weideman would need to do a bit better this match than last.

But gee its good to have Sam Frost back!

Shows what the coaches think of Oscar so far this year if they're replacing him with Frost who has barely played VFL yet due to injury. Not sure it's a good move to rush players in so quickly if they aren't 100% fit or close to, but I like what Frost brings to the backline. He is so quick for a big guy and if he doesn't try anything to fancy he gives us good drive out of the backline too. 

Good to see Bugg rewarded for great VFL form. Surprised Weid didn't get dropped as he is struggling so far this year. Smith is a bit unlucky to be dropped after one game but that's footy for you! Hogan back next week!

Edited April 13, 20178 yr by Lord Travis

3 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Weideman is very very very lucky....

We drop Weeds and we go in VERY short. He brings the ball down and is at every contest. No Brainer.

1 minute ago, dazzledavey36 said:

But gee its good to have Sam Frost back!

Agree, and yeah Weid is lucky, he needs a big game

Glad to see Frosty back.

1 minute ago, praha said:

We drop Weeds and we go in VERY short. He brings the ball down and is at every contest. No Brainer.

No we do not go in 'very short' because the obvious selection would have been Pedersen.

Oscar out is interesting

Spencer for Gawn is a downgrade.

Frost for O. McDonald is a big upgrade.

Bugg for Smith is just different.

@stevethemanjordan just had his Christmas and birthday all at once with the omission of Oscar.

The changes are fair, though, and reflect a need (Spencer) and good VFL form (Frost and Bugg).  The guys at Casey need to see that their good work is rewarded and the guys in the senior side also need to see that poor form won't be tolerated.

Still nervous about this game, though.  It could be a slog fest.

3 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

No we do not go in 'very short' because the obvious selection would have been Pedersen.

So we bring in Frost AND Pederson, two without game fitness for the year. Clearly it was between Oscar and Weeds. We've proven we can score with an underperformed Weeds.

Edited April 13, 20178 yr by praha

Bugg to Neale?

How did weed stay in?!