23 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Go back and look at the the VFL/AFL was like when zones were in place, it was a disaster.

There is a reason we have a draft and salary cap, they are the two most important aspects to the competition which is why the COLA and academies are the two biggest blights on the current system.

 

Your missing the point CB, the national draft still exists.  But the first few top kids get to stay local.

Its not like the old zone recruitment area, with no draft.  I agree, it was lousy & unbalanced,  but in today's schools environment, & the effort parents, teachers,, & clubs put into teaching kids its all very different.

It just helps keep up to 3 top kids at home,  per year,  per club.   This would also bring back the interstate clubs academy's back to the field, as they would also be restricted to just 3 free picks,  before any bidding started for other academy kids.

Edited September 19, 20169 yr by DV8

45 minutes ago, Mickey said:

 

While I agree with the majority of this post, brown and mcbean were in AFL environments and still didn't kick on. The club would need to decide of they think either of the Casey boys will kick on when in an AFL program

Hibberd and Barlow came from the VFL, so it's certainly a reasonable pathway, but I think it's definitely harder for key position players.

Keilty has a better chance than McInerney, but I wouldn't back on either making it. 

On 19 September 2016 at 1:23 PM, DV8 said:

Your missing the point CB, the national draft still exists.  But the first few top kids get to stay local.

Its not like the old zone recruitment area, with no draft.  I agree, it was lousy & unbalanced,  but in today's schools environment, & the effort parents, teachers,, & clubs put into teaching kids its all very different.

It just helps keep up to 3 top kids at home,  per year,  per club.   This would also bring back the interstate clubs academy's back to the field, as they would also be restricted to just 3 free picks,  before any bidding started for other academy kids.

You can't be half-pregnant, you either have a hard salary cap and draft or nothing, there's no point otherwise.

Just now, Clint Bizkit said:

You can't be half-pregnant, you wither have a hard salary cap and draft or nothing, there's no point otherwise.

Well that's wrong.  We already have father sons, as well & academy's,. so the draft on its own doesn't work, because you get clubs 'list management' going on, to get a preferred player.

Will be rookied next year. Most likely with us.

i wonder if we looked at the various areas that each club now controls and go back over say the last 5 years at what each area produced I wonder how balanced or evenly spread the talent would be, and who would have gone where..

 

On 9/19/2016 at 1:23 PM, DV8 said:

Your missing the point CB, the national draft still exists.  But the first few top kids get to stay local.

Its not like the old zone recruitment area, with no draft.  I agree, it was lousy & unbalanced,  but in today's schools environment, & the effort parents, teachers,, & clubs put into teaching kids its all very different.

It just helps keep up to 3 top kids at home,  per year,  per club.   This would also bring back the interstate clubs academy's back to the field, as they would also be restricted to just 3 free picks,  before any bidding started for other academy kids.

It's a nice idea but I just wonder if the game hasn't got so big that you'd get clubs giving out scholarships to schools in their zones etc. Those three pre-draft choices would be like gold and probably very soon exploited. Which club is in the private school belt and can offer a scholarship to Xavier, Carey etc.

6 hours ago, GawnWithTheWind said:

Will be rookied next year. Most likely with us.

This is your opinion, or something else?

3 hours ago, deespicable me said:

It's a nice idea but I just wonder if the game hasn't got so big that you'd get clubs giving out scholarships to schools in their zones etc. Those three pre-draft choices would be like gold and probably very soon exploited. Which club is in the private school belt and can offer a scholarship to Xavier, Carey etc.

We would just pay the fees for the kids education whilst on that list.  as long as the kid is holding his part of the contract, it carries on till draft time.

Each club would have 3 pre-draft picks from they're own academies, including any father/sons.  All other academy kids, or father sons not in the [3],  would be able for other clubs to bid on, for the draft.

 

With Dunn now gone I think we are a little light on for key backs. Does this bode well for a rookie spot for Dec?

 

With Dunn now gone I think we are a little light on for key backs. Does this bode well for a rookie spot for Dec?

He can bring his mate Tim Smith with him!

Declan had an interview with the Mebourne staff today about his draft prospects 

5 hours ago, Drunkn167 said:

Declan had an interview with the Mebourne staff today about his draft prospects 

And what was the upshot?

I believe Keilty started as a forward.   Given his athletic ability I wonder if we are considering developing him into the swingman that we we're hoping Frost would be? 

Declan was quite impressive early in the VFL season with his stints in the ruck, up forward and primarily as a tall defender.

But he had a relatively poor finals campaign for Casey, which has meant he is no longer talked about as someone who will attract the sort of interest that would make see him taken in the normal draft - and the rookie draft now seems a more likely spot for him and us.

It may come down to a choice between him and Jack Hannath - who we were keen on four years ago before Freo nabbed him before us.

I'm hoping we go for Declan because it will also send a signal to Casey players that if you play well, then it is a potential road into Melbourne.

I'd also be happy if we took Footscray's Ben Long who is a pacey, medium forward from Darwin - yes indigenous - Rioli's cousin.

I always think we should be supporting NT players now that we have a relationship with the state and he is obviously one that we missed and the Dogs now have the jump on him. But I imagine if he's still around when it comes to pick 69 then he'd be perfect outside pace that we need to punt on - Dogs may take him at pick 50 though.

 

 

 

5 hours ago, Deespicable said:

Declan was quite impressive early in the VFL season with his stints in the ruck, up forward and primarily as a tall defender.

But he had a relatively poor finals campaign for Casey, which has meant he is no longer talked about as someone who will attract the sort of interest that would make see him taken in the normal draft - and the rookie draft now seems a more likely spot for him and us.

It may come down to a choice between him and Jack Hannath - who we were keen on four years ago before Freo nabbed him before us.

I'm hoping we go for Declan because it will also send a signal to Casey players that if you play well, then it is a potential road into Melbourne.

I'd also be happy if we took Footscray's Ben Long who is a pacey, medium forward from Darwin - yes indigenous - Rioli's cousin.

I always think we should be supporting NT players now that we have a relationship with the state and he is obviously one that we missed and the Dogs now have the jump on him. But I imagine if he's still around when it comes to pick 69 then he'd be perfect outside pace that we need to punt on - Dogs may take him at pick 50 though.

 

 

 

 So who do we have in mind at 47?

Edited November 9, 20169 yr by CBDees
Punctuation

On 09/11/2016 at 11:30 AM, Deespicable said:

Declan was quite impressive early in the VFL season with his stints in the ruck, up forward and primarily as a tall defender.

But he had a relatively poor finals campaign for Casey, which has meant he is no longer talked about as someone who will attract the sort of interest that would make see him taken in the normal draft - and the rookie draft now seems a more likely spot for him and us.

It may come down to a choice between him and Jack Hannath - who we were keen on four years ago before Freo nabbed him before us.

I'm hoping we go for Declan because it will also send a signal to Casey players that if you play well, then it is a potential road into Melbourne.

I'd also be happy if we took Footscray's Ben Long who is a pacey, medium forward from Darwin - yes indigenous - Rioli's cousin.

I always think we should be supporting NT players now that we have a relationship with the state and he is obviously one that we missed and the Dogs now have the jump on him. But I imagine if he's still around when it comes to pick 69 then he'd be perfect outside pace that we need to punt on - Dogs may take him at pick 50 though.

 

I thought he was good in the prelim thrown forward to do a job. Then the Dogs forwards probably didn't suit him in the grand final but he wasn't terrible. Rookie draft seems more likely all the way as not many mature players get drafted in the national draft unless they are dominating state leagues. I don't think the finals series would've made a huge difference to his draft stocks.

On 10/21/2016 at 0:45 PM, Demon Disciple said:

He can bring his mate Tim Smith with him!

Sooner have Norm.

Declan drafted as a rookie to join Tim Smith - we know him well also!!!

A big day for Scorpions recruits as Oscar McInerney was also taken by Brisbane.

Excellent again.

Two players from Casey who finished on top of the ladder and played in a Grand Final.

Do Melbourne really need a stand-alone VFL team?

On 22/09/2016 at 5:29 PM, GawnWithTheWind said:

Will be rookied next year. Most likely with us.

Good get

1 hour ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Excellent again.

Two players from Casey who finished on top of the ladder and played in a Grand Final.

Do Melbourne really need a stand-alone VFL team?

Its great isn't it? Plapp must be stoked as both likely to be with Casey most of the year so they don't lose the talent or the synergy and history they have with their Casey team mates. But will have the advantage of AFL level training, development and training. 

A win for both young men and both clubs. A very smart move.

Stoked for Dec and his family. He comes from great stock! Cant wait to see him in a Melbourne jumper. 

1 hour ago, Whispering_Jack said:

Declan drafted as a rookie to join Tim Smith - we know him well also!!!

A big day for Scorpions recruits as Oscar McInerney was also taken by Brisbane.

Makes sense. No point taking him at Melbourne as the O Mac nickname has already been taken.

I assume he will be training as a defender?

Very happy for him.