Just now, Redleg said:

Gee I thought Gawn would bolt in, he carried us all year.

Bluey just like the Brownlow Redleg, a midfielders award

The club B&F is always interesting given it's based on what the coaches want from the players which is often quite different from what the outside public wants/ thinks is a quality game,

I personally think any  of the top 5 would have been a deserving winner this year.

Just now, cooko said:

Yep, and people on here were calling for his head saying he should be stripped of his captaincy and dropped to the VFL! Just the sort of culture we want to be known for...

 

Well done Jonesy!!

Same with Tyson ("we mucked another draft/trade up etc."), but he had a phenomenal second half of the year!

I'm shocked Gawn is not streets ahead, interesting voting system to say the least.

Just now, Redleg said:

Gee I thought Gawn would bolt in, he carried us all year.

He had a few games he was beaten, fair enough, true of all players. He certainly has as many big games as any others. 

I think he's been marked harshly for games where he beat up on bad rucks without huge influence around the ground. Seems stiff.

3 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Dom Tyson will storm home and either win it or come 2nd.

On the maths, suggesting that Tyson will win is a bit like when you've gotta kick 6 goals to none in the last quarter to win, when you've only kicked 4 in the whole game up to that point.  It might happen, but it probably won't.

1 minute ago, DeeSpencer said:

He had a few games he was beaten, fair enough, true of all players. He certainly has as many big games as any others. 

I think he's been marked harshly for games where he beat up on bad rucks without huge influence around the ground. Seems stiff.

He was clearly our most valuable player all year and the best Ruck in the AFL. Can't understand why he didn't poll more votes.

3 minutes ago, Nasher said:

On the maths, suggesting that Tyson will win is a bit like when you've gotta kick 6 goals in the last quarter when you've only kicked 4 in the whole game.  It might happen, but it probably won't.

Tyson's disposal was abysmal in the Cat's game.

2 minutes ago, Redleg said:

He was clearly our most valuable player all year and the best Ruck in the AFL. Can't understand why he didn't poll more votes.

Sharing the love around. All Australian. Same as Hunt winning best young player ahead of rising star listed players. 

Edited September 6, 20169 yr by Maybe next year

1 minute ago, Redleg said:

Tyson's disposal was abysmal in the Cat's game.

Wasn't on his Pat Malone.

7 minutes ago, Maybe next year said:

Viney was hardly seen against Carlton and Jones was injured against Geelong. That's where I see Dom catching them. However it is a big gap.

Viney was even more garbage against Geelong.

His last 2 games were putrid by his standards and may cost him the Bluey. Actually he was also average against Port as well. 

Hoping Tyson somehow gets it. He seems to be tonight's sentimental favourite.

Edited September 6, 20169 yr by Bring-Back-Powell

Just now, McQueen said:

Wasn't on his Pat Malone.

Doesn't matter whether he was on his Pat Malone or not in context of the B&F.

Tyson won't win guys, he's way too far behind.  Get your calculators out.

What's the count at?

And now to the real serious stuff:  Is the Johnnie Walker Blue stand there again tonight?

Even if Jones doesn't win, well done to the just 2 people out of 170 who picked him in the poll. True believers ?

Edited September 6, 20169 yr by Crystal Dees

1 minute ago, Crystal Dees said:

Even if Jones doesn't win, well done to the just 2 people out of 179 who picked him in the poll. True believers ?

Is that a pat on the back Crystal?

1 minute ago, Demon Disciple said:

Is that a pat on the back Crystal?

If you did, absolutely!

I've closed the poll now so you cheating buggers can't add/change your votes when the result is pretty close to over.  Enjoy! :D

Just now, Nasher said:

I've closed the poll now so you cheating buggers can't add/change your votes when the result is pretty close to over.  Enjoy! :D

Too late!

 

Just now, SaberFang said:

Too late!

 

*annuls SaberFang's vote*

(Not really, but only because the software won't let me )

1 minute ago, Crystal Dees said:

If you did, absolutely!

Nah i wasn't one of the 2, went with Big Maxy.

I wonder who the other in the poll would be. I would have guessed Jetta. In my opinion he was bette than Tom Mac

Where does Hogan rank?

5 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Where does Hogan rank?

7th.  251.