Jones - clean ball user

Vince - usually more creative

Hogan - consistently hard worker

Watts - creative and versatile

Petracca - brilliant in close

Viney - couldn't break free

Gawn - just a shadow

Oliver - creative ball user

Stretch - excellent 4 quarters

Kent - had little involvement

Newton - took his chances

Garland - better without pressure

Michie - little to enthuse

T. McDonald - kept opponent bereft

O. McDonald - far from convincing 

Hunt - one exciting run

Neal- Bullen - important one percenters

Bugg - 3 great quarters

Kennedy - needed more involvement

Garlett - regularly looked dangerous

Wagner - promising but flakey

Harmes - took his chances

 

 

Kent: improved towards end

Tough on Mitchie - thought he was pretty good.  Wasn't as enthused as you in relation to ANB and Newton.  Thought Watts was OK in the Ruck, but still question marks over his hardness at the contest.

Interesting selection dilemma with Tyson, Jetta and potentilly Dawes to come in.

3 minutes ago, grazman said:

Tough on Mitchie - thought he was pretty good.  Wasn't as enthused as you in relation to ANB and Newton.  Thought Watts was OK in the Ruck, but still question marks over his hardness at the contest.

Interesting selection dilemma with Tyson, Jetta and potentilly Dawes to come in.

Dawes!

I do not see anyone who would keep Jetta out in that backline today.

Tyson no problem if he is well will be playing in AS.

Just now, old dee said:

Dawes!

Happy to keep Watts rucking Old, or bring Pedo back in?

5 minutes ago, grazman said:

Happy to keep Watts rucking Old, or bring Pedo back in?

You are not alone grazman.

Posted 8 minutes ago · 

Hogan - Best on ground

Stretch - best young improver

Kent - seemed very uninterested

Garland - Lucky to play

Michie - A filler in

Gawn - Third time missing

O. McDonald - not best 22 

 

2 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

Posted 8 minutes ago · 

Hogan - Best on ground

Stretch - best young improver

Kent - seemed very uninterested

Garland - Lucky to play

Michie - A filler in

Gawn - Third time missing

O. McDonald - not best 22 

 

Kent - drank own bathwater?

Bugg - So many haters

Garland - Some important efforts

 

34 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

Posted 8 minutes ago agree about Hogan

Hogan - Best on ground

Stretch - best young improver

Kent - seemed very uninterested

Garland - Lucky to play

Michie - A filler in

Gawn - Third time missing

O. McDonald - not best 22 

 

Agree about Hogan, best on ground followed by Stretch and Watts

Edited May 22, 20169 yr by dave

Michie    played his role, created a goal for himself with pressure, couple of good tacklle

RTG did you watch Kent's game

1 hour ago, joeboy said:

O. McDonald - far from convincing

Hell no.  He kept his man to 5 touches and a single point  while racking up 18 disposals himself at 77.8%.  You can't knock that effort from a young defender. 

Michie is doing the role asked of him and will keep his place.

Roos gives new players 2 games minimum to cement place and find consistency.

We have good depth with B+ players next step 1or 2 Agraders and foundation is there

Tyson - Absence was conspicuous 

Billy Stretch was definitely best on for mine.  Ran all day and neat by foot especially. So 3 words for Billy are best on ground or runs all day!

Hogan - tank like Riewoldt 

3 hours ago, RalphiusMaximus said:

Hell no.  He kept his man to 5 touches and a single point  while racking up 18 disposals himself at 77.8%.  You can't knock that effort from a young defender. 

I have a feeling you weren't at the game today.  

Jonathan Freeman kicked a goal on him by the way, after missing 2 easy ones.

 

Edited May 22, 20169 yr by Buzzy

3 hours ago, RalphiusMaximus said:

Hell no.  He kept his man to 5 touches and a single point  while racking up 18 disposals himself at 77.8%.  You can't knock that effort from a young defender. 

Fumbled 3-4 times

Overran the footy twice.

Missed 3 crucial tackles.

Outbodied too easily.

He would be smashed in other games with this ...

1 hour ago, Buzzy said:

I have a feeling you weren't at the game today.  

Jonathan Freeman kicked a goal on him by the way, after missing 2 easy ones.

 

I was indeed at the game.  Oscar had one job - to negate Schache.  He did that as well as you could possibly expect.  Meanwhile his brother was outbodied and outmarked repeatedly, yet nobody seems to be mentioning him at all.  Indeed, the comment from joeboy is "T. McDonald - kept opponent bereft" making me wonder if he doesn't have the two of them mixed up. 

1 hour ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Fumbled 3-4 times

Overran the footy twice.

Missed 3 crucial tackles.

Outbodied too easily.

He would be smashed in other games with this ...

So you're complaining that a kid in his fourth game fumbled a couple of times and was overpowered by older, stronger athletes? 

Hunt - had at least 2 good 'run and carry' runs as I recall. Maybe 3?