Hogan - one man forward

Viney - gave his all

Gawn - light around ground

Jones - solid limited support

Vince - was he unwell?

Kennedy - time for Casey

Bugg - ahead of himself

Petracca - showed glimpses nervous

Tyson - showed some more

Watts - ying yang game

TMAC - Asleep at wheel

Wagner - inexperience showed today

Lumumba - one trick pony

Dunn - couldn't plug holes

Harmes - probably gets dropped

Garlett - rabbitless magicians hat

Salem - hopefully concussion forgetsgame

Kent - Not enough Kent

Frost - has gone backwards

Hunt - lacks composure outclassed

Jetta - no support ok

So many absent players.

You did well to restrain youself.

Why were thye talking about playing finals during the week. They werent even in the eight.

Lets be confident but lets not get too far ahead either

We win 2 in a row like any good side should and then put on this crap.

Looks like they over trained.......they were cooked on toast.

Someone trying to steal Joeboy's thunder.  This should be interesting...

1 minute ago, Wiseblood said:

Someone trying to steal Joeboy's thunder.  This should be interesting...

Poor form I think...

 

2 minutes ago, KrazyJay said:

Poor form I think...

 

At least Joeboy gets all the players...

Pedo was average but to be left out totally is amateurish 

Petracca - Give him time

 

The result - was totally expected 

7 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Someone trying to steal Joeboy's thunder.  This should be interesting...

oh there's a regular who does this? sorry didn't realise, thought i'ld have a go this week. 

Petracca showed some really good glimpses today, which is all you can ask of a debutant.

I will actually get angry if people start questioning him based on today's performance.

Hogan - Only Consistent Performer 

Viney - Best and Fairest

Gawn - Serviceable yet Flat

Jones - Standard Jones Game

Vince - Not Bernie's Best

Kennedy - Far From Influential

Bugg - Never Got Involved

Petracca - Signs Of Promise

Tyson - In and Out

Watts - Lacked real involvement

TMAC - Shocking peripheral vision

Wagner - beaten all over

Lumumba - Dear Oh Dear

Dunn - Slow and Dumb

Harmes - Did he play?

Garlett - Missed his influence

Salem - VFL quality performance

Kent - Must Offer More

Frost - Paul Johnson 2.0

Hunt - Confident Yet Outclassed

Jetta - Among Our Best

Edited April 30, 20169 yr by praha

Just now, 3Dee said:

oh there's a regular who does this? sorry didn't realise, thought i'ld have a go this week. 

You're okay mate, Joeboy does one every week and generally everyone has a crack once that thread is up.  No harm done!

We beat tiggers and bipyes doesn't make us worldbeaters.   What a classic seeing 5 coaches in the box not knowing what to do after the first goal by saints in 3rd qtr.   

Height maybe frost in the back line at that time.  I don't know .....

Roos - poor gameday coach

Lumumba - Chook without head

 

Adzman - really hates stkilda

Next week- some changes made

Wagner - hit bum note

Frost - Not this year

Wagner - less than composed

Jones - always the warrior

Hogan - our only winner

Gawn - failed to dominate

Viney - never left wondering

Vince - was rarely sighted

Kennedy - looked painfully slow

Bugg - selection defies logic

Petracca - some sublime touches

Tyson - consistently wrong options

Watts - continued impressive form

McDonald - disappears when beaten

Wagner - played amateur football

Lumumba - was embarrassingly bad

Dunn - inhibited by fatness

Harmes - a poor game

Garlett - couldn't find ball

Salem - poor before injury

Kent - probably wasn't playing

Frost - not of standard

Pedersen - see Dunn above

Hunt - out of depth

Jetta - slow and loose

Dunn - Very funny comment

Agree with most besides Jetta. He was easily our best defender IMO.

Harmes - looked for frees

Frost - yuck x 3

Dunn - Agree with above

TMac - Timid, tired play

Gawn - met his match

MFC - ahead of themselves 

tmac - was he playing

T MAC ... F****** dumb footballer

HARMES  Ego denting game

FROST  N Q R 

PETRACCA Looked Painfully overawed.

OLIVER   POOR NON SELECTION