It was a shame to see a champion of the game end his career in the way it happened. What better person could we choose to nurture, mentor and teach our young midfielders. Let's show him there is life after football. He was a Melbourne supporter as a child so he will have a soft spot for us so let's strike now.

It was a shame to see a champion of the game end his career in the way it happened. What better person could we choose to nurture, mentor and teach our young midfielders. Let's show him there is life after football. He was a Melbourne supporter as a child so he will have a soft spot for us so let's strike now.

I think he is more interested in running businesses than coaching.

Maybe next year.

I'm sure we can find a role for him even if part time (eg. Mentor)

Maybe next year.

Why are you whispering, Jack?

Must be me...yep crap way to bow out perhaps. He's be remunerated to the hilt. He's set up. He talked SHlT years back.

He can lump it, care factor ....nil

Next

Had his chance to help us

Chose the paper bag....

Had his chance to help us

Chose the paper bag....

Yup, stuff him and stuff Richard Pratt

Only if he brings Bec dressed in a devil outfit for our new mascot.

Edited June 6, 201510 yr by Emerald

Only if he brings Bec dressed in a devil outfit for our new mascot.

To hell with that, Vote 1 Pia Miller!

He'll have a highly paid job at Visy lined up as part of the whole deal

Had his chance to help us

Chose the paper bag....

Even though it didn't work out that well for Carlton I still rate this as one of the most disappointing moments in my time as a Melbourne fan. Judd's welcome to do what he likes and chasing money is understandable but it would have been incredible to have a player of his calibre wear the Red and Blue.

Why are you whispering, Jack?

I'm whispering that while it's very sad for Judd to cop an injury like this one, I would prefer not to see him at the club. I don't really like him and I don't like the way he conducted himself when he came across from West Coast to Victoria. He treated our club with disdain with the way in which he deigned to give the club an audience as one of his four preferred clubs when in fact, it appeared that he had already made his decision. Moreover, I don't believe his personality is suited to a role at a young club like ours.

I'm whispering that while it's very sad for Judd to cop an injury like this one, I would prefer not to see him at the club. I don't really like him and I don't like the way he conducted himself when he came across from West Coast to Victoria. He treated our club with disdain with the way in which he deigned to give the club an audience as one of his four preferred clubs when in fact, it appeared that he had already made his decision. Moreover, I don't believe his personality is suited to a role at a young club like ours.

You my vote WJ

Judd also wasn't a great leader. Not sure he would be the greatest coach either.

Judd also wasn't a great leader. Not sure he would be the greatest coach either.

Prefer to find the next Judd.

Judd has said he isnt interested in coaching. But maybe he will revert back to his childhood and come and watch us as a supporter.

Anyone who has enough sour grapes to not want Judd at our club because he went to Carlton doesn't deserve to see Melbourne be successful.

Turn it up Chook. How would you think the Eagles might respond?

Yup, stuff him and stuff Richard Pratt

I reckon Pratt might be too far past the taxidermist treatment.

Turn it up Chook. How would you think the Eagles might respond?

"Thanks for the Premierships. Can you help us win another one? No? Ok then, see ya later. Oh, wait. You can help us win another one? Ok, welcome aboard."

Edited June 6, 201510 yr by Chook

That's an old one ,Carlton thought that.

Who honestly could give 2 !&$@'s about Judd. I don't .

Who honestly could give 2 !&$@'s about Judd. I don't .

I would his missus.