Paul Chapman

[Bobby McKenzie 2,385]

Well to go with some young hard nuts as well it could be worth a shot.

The way I see it we've got potential in Garland, Frawley, Dawes, McDonald, Nath Jones, Trengove, Grimes, Mitch Clark etc that if we get the culture right now it might work.

The problem was Neitz, Yze and White weren't really great leaders and that spilt down to Green, Bruce and Robertson and then on to Sylvia, Moloney and Davey. The MFC generation of players lost years may well just carry on if all of a sudden people start saying Nath Jones, Garland, Grimes and Frawley don't really care and are soft and then it will be 2020 and everyone will be saying that Jack Viney is unproffessional and soft as well (not at the ball but in terms of effort).

There's too many list spaces to fill that bringing in 1 more experienced and reliable veteran isn't a bad idea.

Neitz not a leader? Gee, I can't agree with that at all. He was inspirational and led by example with courage personified.

.

[DeeSpencer 25,678]

Neitz not a leader? Gee, I can't agree with that at all. He was inspirational and led by example with courage personified.

.

In his peak yes, but he fizzled on as an average full forward and I don't mean that in a harsh way and captain.

The neitz and Daniher years were great but without legacy. There was no carry over to a Woewodin or a hard and ruthless Jeff White or Stephen Powell or Scotty Thompson or Brock McLean as captain. I suppose James McDonald was the first right man but he ended up captain too late and then was indisposed. Bruce and Green captain was yuck.

Anyway back on topic Chapman (or Cross or both) would be wonderful. Chappy is the better performed on field this year but you have to factor in he missed most of the year and he won't have the same impact if he never makes the field. Tough call by all, especially Geelong

[Redleg 40,895]

In his peak yes, but he fizzled on as an average full forward and I don't mean that in a harsh way and captain.

The neitz and Daniher years were great but without legacy. There was no carry over to a Woewodin or a hard and ruthless Jeff White or Stephen Powell or Scotty Thompson or Brock McLean as captain. I suppose James McDonald was the first right man but he ended up captain too late and then was indisposed. Bruce and Green captain was yuck.

Anyway back on topic Chapman (or Cross or both) would be wonderful. Chappy is the better performed on field this year but you have to factor in he missed most of the year and he won't have the same impact if he never makes the field. Tough call by all, especially Geelong

I think he might get another year at the Cats given his 4 goals friday.

He would then also probably retire as a one club player which I think he and they would like.

The bodies on him and Josh Hunt are frightening, if you are coming the other way.

[dee-luded 2,959]

In his peak yes, but he fizzled on as an average full forward and I don't mean that in a harsh way and captain.

The neitz and Daniher years were great but without legacy. There was no carry over to a Woewodin or a hard and ruthless Jeff White or Stephen Powell or Scotty Thompson or Brock McLean as captain. I suppose James McDonald was the first right man but he ended up captain too late and then was indisposed. Bruce and Green captain was yuck.

Anyway back on topic Chapman (or Cross or both) would be wonderful. Chappy is the better performed on field this year but you have to factor in he missed most of the year and he won't have the same impact if he never makes the field. Tough call by all, especially Geelong

In my mind Chappy would only be recruited for what he can add to our list growth.... not so much what he can do to our ladder position... he'll effect our ladder position with what he passes on to our under 25's.

By contrast daisy would help the side improve ladder position, but wouldn't give us much re cultural reform. the legacy is not there. longterm gain minimal.

a Sewell type or a Bolton or similar, would bring much to those around them. remember we are not shooting for top 4,,, we need to teach those we Have, to become the top tier player we need.

[Nasher 33,613]

Ask yourself the question: if you were Paul Chapman and you thought you were still capable of playing, would *you* leave Geelong to play for Melbourne?

I know Roos has pull, but I doubt he's going to shake loose any elite players from the best sides unless they've got serious question marks, or they're after monster cash. Chapman will retire a one-club player.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Ask yourself the question: if you were Paul Chapman and you thought you were still capable of playing, would *you* leave Geelong to play for Melbourne?

I know Roos has pull, but I doubt he's going to shake loose any elite players from the best sides unless they've got serious question marks, or they're after monster cash. Chapman will retire a one-club player.

I think Chappy's gone public, trying to pull another year from the Cats.

If they seek to go youth as they appear they should.. they are looking collectively shaky. then they may not give Chappy another...

In this scenario, Chappy I think will play elsewhere. I just don't see Chappy bluffing.

[Machsy 2,858]

I'm told Geelong are very unlikely to come to Chappy's 1-more-year party...

[Ted Lasso 19,507]

I wouldn't be upset if we offered him a two year deal, these blokes know exactly what a good culture looks like.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Chappy gets a whack... 1 week.

[cooko 124]

Would LOVE chappy, our players would learn so much from him, but if he leaves I would expect he would go flag chasing

[Vandenberger With The Lot 238]

Would LOVE chappy, our players would learn so much from him, but if he leaves I would expect he would go flag chasing

The guy has 3.

We would need Roos to sell him on leaving a legacy by helping to resurrect a near dead club.

[deeko 952]

Playing midfield coach?

[Dr. Gonzo 24,207]

Would LOVE chappy, our players would learn so much from him, but if he leaves I would expect he would go flag chasing

Well he wouldn't be going to the Hawks you can take that to the bank!

[rjay 24,917]

Well he wouldn't be going to the Hawks you can take that to the bank!

If they don't win this week I wouldn't be surprised if they made an offer.

[Supreme_Demon 3,834]

I'd love to have Paul Chapman at the Demons for a year or two. He would be great in implementing a better culture here at the MFC. He wouldn't cost much. And he could definitely be a playing coach too?

As much as he won't make a massive impact on the field he would help alot of the younger players at the Demons develop a no-nonsense, harder approach.

Whether or not he wants to come to the Demons and Paul Roos actually wants him is another story altogether...

Either way, Paul Chapman would be a great influence on our playing group.

[dazzledavey36 54,861]

Dunny would love it if Chapman joined the Dees.

[nutbean 8,838]

The only question mark is the ability to get on the ground often enough.

[wattsup 470]

Must talk to him player/development coach give him 2 year deal

[Dee Fan 3,247]

I doubt he will leave the Cats and doubt they will delist/trade him.

[Deez 298]

In his peak yes, but he fizzled on as an average full forward and I don't mean that in a harsh way and captain.

The neitz and Daniher years were great but without legacy. There was no carry over to a Woewodin or a hard and ruthless Jeff White or Stephen Powell or Scotty Thompson or Brock McLean as captain. I suppose James McDonald was the first right man but he ended up captain too late and then was indisposed. Bruce and Green captain was yuck.

Anyway back on topic Chapman (or Cross or both) would be wonderful. Chappy is the better performed on field this year but you have to factor in he missed most of the year and he won't have the same impact if he never makes the field. Tough call by all, especially Geelong

I think I'm gonna have to disagree mate. Neitz was a fantastic captain and s brilliant forward. He won the Coleman one year. He wasn't always a forward either. He played down back for quite a while before going to full forward, perhaps that's why you think he wasn't a great forward. I remember games where Neitz kicked 7-8+ goals, I think he may have kicked 11 once. Any way, I think the culture issues are based around the clubs unfair dismissal of the senior players such as white, yze, Wheatley leonceli etc. many players that were club champions didn't get a final farewell game. I think this has strongly contributed to our players attitudes. Why would they wanto play with heart for a club that might just delist them toward the end of their career without a last game thank you. Not very appealing for younger players to stick around

[Machsy 2,858]

I doubt he will leave the Cats and doubt they will delist/trade him.

Trust me.

Won't reveal my sources, but he will not be offered a new contract at Geelong.

Hope we are "balls deep" in discussions with him, but at this stage I doubt it, since he's bent on staying at Geelong til they give him the official tap on the shoulder.

The only way he stays is if Pods goes, and while that's a real chance, even then he's not likely to get a new contract.

Chapman knows this.

[Little Richard 6,262]

Trust me.

Won't reveal my sources, but he will not be offered a new contract at Geelong.

Hope we are "balls deep" in discussions with him, but at this stage I doubt it, since he's bent on staying at Geelong til they give him the official tap on the shoulder.

The only way he stays is if Pods goes, and while that's a real chance, even then he's not likely to get a new contract.

Chapman knows this.

What I've heard is along the same lines, that he'll be squeezed out this year.

Hopefully we are there to scoop him up when he falls from the tree.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Trust me.

Won't reveal my sources, but he will not be offered a new contract at Geelong.

Hope we are "balls deep" in discussions with him, but at this stage I doubt it, since he's bent on staying at Geelong til they give him the official tap on the shoulder.

The only way he stays is if Pods goes, and while that's a real chance, even then he's not likely to get a new contract.

Chapman knows this.

I don't think Pods will go. They need him imo, especially while Hawkins is so sore & so reluctant to play sore. but they have many young mids they could lose if they don't open the opportunities to them.

I know Pods looked blunt the other night, & he looked slow, but the other areas are of more immediate urgency to transition their Mids. they don't want to majke the mistake of making too many changes in every department weakening all areas at once.

I suspect they'll retire 3 of the 4 older guys, starting with Hunt.

there is >

Corey Enright - 32Yrs

Paul Chapman - 31Yrs

Joel Corey - 31Yrs

Josh Hunt - 31Yrs

----------------------

Steve Johnson - 30Yrs

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Trust me.

Won't reveal my sources, but he will not be offered a new contract at Geelong.

Hope we are "balls deep" in discussions with him, but at this stage I doubt it, since he's bent on staying at Geelong til they give him the official tap on the shoulder.

The only way he stays is if Pods goes, and while that's a real chance, even then he's not likely to get a new contract.

Chapman knows this.

Heard him on SEN this afternoon and he doesn't seem all that confident he will get another contract, he wants to be a one club player but said he will look elsewhere if they don't want to re contract him.

Interesting.

[Dockett 32 1,239]

What I've heard is along the same lines, that he'll be squeezed out this year.

Hopefully we are there to scoop him up when he falls from the tree.

Old , injury prone, not huge, not quick , best footy behind him. We could end up with Byrnes, Chapman and Pederson all doing a good job for us at Casey if we are not careful. Lets not jump at every bloke getting cut from a list just yet.

He's been a great player but don't we want an "A" Grader who's going to be with us for a while? Someone like Sloan.

He's in the same boat as Cross IMO and if they had high contribution levels left they will/ would have been kept by their clubs.

Whilst we may need experienced players, how about we raise our sights ,we don't want to become a retirement home.