Casey Scorpions v Collingwood and Debt Demolition Day

[KC from Casey 7,117]

The Scorpions play Collingwood VFL on Saturday.

In addition to what should be an absorbing game, the club is also having a Debt Demolition Day including a luncheon at the club before the game hosted by Aussie Test Cricketer Rodney Hogg.

Debt Demolition Prizes

Weekend escape in a Mercedes Benz Cabriolet.

7 nights at Yorkeys [censored] Apartments in North Queensland

Spring Carnival Package. Helicopter to Caulfield, luncheon & limo home

Many more prizes up for grabs.

Please phone 59961111 to book.

[Deespicable 2,886]

Should the Dees do the dirty on Casey again?

History: For the past four years, Casey has made the finals on the back of some handy Melbourne-listed players, only to find that come the finals, the Dees heirarchy decides that it wants to send most of its eligible VFL players off for a break so that the AFL-listed players can begin pre-season training in early October. The only exceptions to this policy have been players about to be delisted anyway (eg: Bate last year).

Not surprisingly Casey comes up short in September - usually out in straight sets.

This year Casey again looks set to make the finals and its Melbourne-listed contingent (which includes young Jesse Hogan) have been firing.

Given how bad the Dees have been going, players who have been dropped to the VFL get a chance to play in a winning line-up and get some confidence back and play proactive football, rather than the reactive chasing type they get in the AFL.

Casey strength is serving a really good purpose in the current environment and I don't understand why the Dees football administration treats them like s... in September.

My view is that young guys like Hogan, Toumpas, Kent, Gawn, Barry and Blease etc would really benefit from being part of a genuine finals campaign with the added pressure that entails.

If they were to make the VFL Grand Final it would serve as a positive note for the whole club to end its season on - just like it did for Geelong when they won the VFL flag with guys like Ablett, Stevie J and Lonergan one year before they made a quantum leap.

The VFL finals series (and a potential GF at Etihad Stadium) would also give guys like Davis, Spencer, Fitzy, Taggert, Nicho, Tynan, Magner and Couch etc one last chance to show on a biggish stage that they are worthy of being kept on the list.

Whilst I get why Misson and his fitness staff want players to be back early in October, I think the benefits of a successful Casey finals campaign would far outweigh the downside of a later start for the 10-12 guys that would do us proud for Casey.

Am I missing something? I always thought that success was meant to breed success.

[CBDees 3,167]

I thoroughly agree! Let them play together in a Premiership team!

[deeko 952]

I think the great case for this is the 2002 VFL premiership in which a core of superstars got there first taste of success.

Ablett

Bartel

Hunt

Johnson

Kelly

Chapman

Look where these guys ended up...

[Older demon 2,779]

Agree last years VFL premiers Geelong had a number of players who benefited immensely from the finals experience. I think it treats Casey with disrespect to pull all our players out who got the team into the finals.

[deanox 9,989]

You do realise that the players who this applied to went for end of season surgery?

[Gorgoroth 13,017]

Surgery can wait a few more weeks most of the time.

They need to play finals at Casey and hopefully win.

It's disgraceful what we have done.

[Sir Why You Little 37,126]

Let them play out the season. They may hold up a Cup. That can only help.

[nicksaidsoyouknowitstrue 19]

it may be the only cup they get to hold

Edited June 6, 2013 by nicksaidsoyouknowitstrue

[Pates 9,660]

Barring them being in huge amount of pain (in which case why play them anyway) they should definitely play in Caseys finals. Hogan especially, lets face it he's probably going to have to put up with some bad years with Melbourne, let him enjoy some success with Casey.

[Little Richard 6,265]

No harm in playing finals footy

[Cards13 9,117]

Every game that goes into any MFC player at this point should be a bloody blessing and a privilege. Any chance they can work under match pressure and look to improve the deplorable skill level and output should be taken.

[dee-eee 231]

Great post . Our consistent refusal to select a competitive side in the VFL finals discourages our attendance and leaves us even further dispirited . When opposition supporters accuse our current hierachy of lacking a football "soul" it's hard to disagree.

[Nasher 33,617]

No harm in playing finals footy

The harm is delaying post-season surgery, which puts their pre-season training back. I'm not advocating one approach or the other, but let's not pretend that there is no cost involved. It's a decision about what's more important; players playing in finals in a secondary competition, or starting pre-season ASAP?

[rjay 25,088]

The harm is delaying post-season surgery, which puts their pre-season training back. I'm not advocating one approach or the other, but let's not pretend that there is no cost involved. It's a decision about what's more important; players playing in finals in a secondary competition, or starting pre-season ASAP?

Finals for me at this stage 'Nasher'.

[KC from Casey 7,117]

Casey Scorpions vs. Collingwood

Saturday 8th June

Casey Fields at 2:00 PM

Casey Scorpions

Backs Taggert Gillies Davis

Half backs Petropoulos L Tynan Panozza

Centreline Strauss Bail Nicholson

Half forwards Sellar Gawn Gent

Forwards Tapscott Hogan Toumpas

Followers Spencer Couch Magner

Interchange (from) Barry Best Clisby Corry Drew* Hughes Jetta Lindsay Nicholls Pollard Smith Stark J Tynan

Collingwood

Backs Riddle Russell Sinclair

Half backs Seedsman Gault Clarke

Centreline Broomhead Martin Yagmoor

Half forwards Krakouer Paine Hellier

Forwards Mooney Hudson Richmond

Followers Witts J Thomas Oxley

Interchange (from) Allan Boland Collopy Corr Ferguson Gray Grundy Headney-Steart Mangoni* Moloney Sundberg Wallace S Williams

* 23rd player

The Development League team has a bye

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

The harm is delaying post-season surgery, which puts their pre-season training back. I'm not advocating one approach or the other, but let's not pretend that there is no cost involved. It's a decision about what's more important; players playing in finals in a secondary competition, or starting pre-season ASAP?

Sorry Nasher, that theory has really helped us in the past few years. NOT

What about when we were aligned with Sandringham, the played and won several Premierships and didn't affect the seniors, or pre season training

[stuie 7,374]

The harm is delaying post-season surgery, which puts their pre-season training back. I'm not advocating one approach or the other, but let's not pretend that there is no cost involved. It's a decision about what's more important; players playing in finals in a secondary competition, or starting pre-season ASAP?

Even if they're off for surgery the amount of time out is still the same. They may start training later but they're also playing full games of footy later, and we need all the actual footy practise we can get, especially seeing we're apparently the best training team going around...

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

I think most of us want to see our next generation playing finals footy in the VFL

Was there a problem in the past of players not being insured past the end of the home and away games?

And there is the other issue of if Hogan does his knee in the first elimination and then half of us will be questioning why the club didn't put him in cotton wool. After all we knew he could play already

[Mono 455]

Plenty here, including me, agree with you.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

Part of the issue in the past has also been the injury situation. We have often sent players off to have minor surgery rather than play for Casey so that they will be ready to go for pre-season. I think if we can keep our list healthy this should not be an issue this season and it would be a huge benefit to the young group to play together through the finals. Great way to fast track their teamwork and spirit.

[deanox 9,989]

In the Neeld era I think the focus has been on fitness in pre-season training. Remember this FD said we'd need 3 pre sesaons to catch up to other clubs, so if we delay someones preseason start by 4 weeks that's an extra month of fitness they lack.

I can see the reasoning, it doesn't mean I think it's the correct decision, and this year we may see a change in tact given this squad has mostly had a couple of preseasons AND we are now seeing that there could be some serious benefit for a group of them to play together.

Does anyone have a list of matches played at Casey? Who is on track to qualify for finals, who has played to many AFL games? I'm not even sure of the criteria.

[stuie 7,374]

so if we delay someones preseason start by 4 weeks that's an extra month of fitness they lack.

They're still training and playing finals footy during that 4 weeks, they're not playing xbox...

[deanox 9,989]

They're still training and playing finals footy during that 4 weeks, they're not playing xbox...

So maybe you just don't understand football, so I'll explain it.

Fitness gains in pre-season training are significantly different than what someone would do at training during a finals campaign.

During finals they would likely do lighter sessions so they are fresh for the games, same goes for during regular season. Skill sessions and sufficient running and weights to maintain fitness and strength.

Preseason training is full of high intensity sessions, particularly running and sprinting. These sessions are significant longer and at a much higher intensity than during the season. Both running and weights sessions are more frequent because players don't need to recover for the weekend. These sessions are not replicated during the season. The bulk of our hard-core fitness regime was completed pre Christmas this pre-season past, and after Christmas there was a heavier focus on skills and gamelan. Players who are ready to go at the start of October have three months of this intense training, players who don't start until November have only 2 months of this intense training.

When they talk about young players needing to have a few possessions completed prior to having developed tanks, endurance and strength, this is what they are referring to. During the season players don't normally pick fitness up, unless they are resuming from a lay off, and they are often rested or eased through sessions because off the demand of the games which means that fitness gains are not made.

They can play Xbox every day of the week (and probably do), that has no bearing on their training.

[stuie 7,374]

So maybe you just don't understand football, so I'll explain it.

Fitness gains in pre-season training are significantly different than what someone would do at training during a finals campaign.

During finals they would likely do lighter sessions so they are fresh for the games, same goes for during regular season. Skill sessions and sufficient running and weights to maintain fitness and strength.

Preseason training is full of high intensity sessions, particularly running and sprinting. These sessions are significant longer and at a much higher intensity than during the season. Both running and weights sessions are more frequent because players don't need to recover for the weekend. These sessions are not replicated during the season. The bulk of our hard-core fitness regime was completed pre Christmas this pre-season past, and after Christmas there was a heavier focus on skills and gamelan. Players who are ready to go at the start of October have three months of this intense training, players who don't start until November have only 2 months of this intense training.

When they talk about young players needing to have a few possessions completed prior to having developed tanks, endurance and strength, this is what they are referring to. During the season players don't normally pick fitness up, unless they are resuming from a lay off, and they are often rested or eased through sessions because off the demand of the games which means that fitness gains are not made.

They can play Xbox every day of the week (and probably do), that has no bearing on their training.

So you think after watching us this year our young players would benefit more from running the tan a few times than playing finals footy?

Daniel Nicholson is generally our best trainer and runner, what do you think of his footy skills and decision making?

Or maybe YOU just don't understand football...