Just discussing on another thread how I once thought (do i really have to admit to it again) that "you could build a side around Matthew Bate". So thought it might be worth a thread where you can confess your worst player predictions. Come on - fess up. You'll feel better.

Brad Miller 'the next Garry Lyon'.

Cale Morton will be a similar if not better player than Goddard (shudders while writing)

I have nothing.

I just really loved the thread title.

*like*

(actually, i called Troy Davis an All Aust C.H.B after seeing 1 training session)

I think that qualifies.

Brent Grgic was a footballer.

I win .... or lose.

I believe in Tom

Said I'd prefer Miller over Jonathan Brown back when Miller was marking everything and Browny was always getting suspended.

Wasn't drunk, stoned or being tortured.

I remember when I said Juice could hold down FF for a decade... I vomited a little bit in my mouth after I wrote that.

Edited October 19, 201213 yr by the passenger

I said Ross Funcke, would be a 10 year player for the dees!!!!

Edited October 19, 201213 yr by Triple Jack

I was pretty Prendaghast at my prediction that "Brock McLean will win a Brownlow one day."

I said Powelly was the best recruit we had signed for a decade when he [censored]-slapped Hodge in the Punt Rd end goalsquare!

That Jurrah and Wonaeamirri would lead us to a premiership.

I once said the Bay City Rollers would be as big as the Beatles.

I thought that Colin Sylvia would have a break out year in 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013?

That Matty Bate would thrive as a mid fielder

I can't go on there are too many and I'm starting to cry

I once said the Bay City Rollers would be as big as the Beatles.

I thought that Colin Sylvia would have a break out year in 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013?

That Matty Bate would thrive as a mid fielder

I can't go on there are too many and I'm starting to cry

I second the Sylvia one

I just read the thread title again and I take back what I said. No matter what I did it could never be as bad as a Prendergast.

During Bates first year I stated he could become a similar type and quality a player as Ryan O'Keefe!

I once said the Bay City Rollers would be as big as the Beatles.

I thought that Colin Sylvia would have a break out year in 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013?

That Matty Bate would thrive as a mid fielder

I can't go on there are too many and I'm starting to cry

You really have no idea Rob.......

I rated Grgic. I thought after watching first hand, his big game against Colinwood, that we had a star on our hands.

*blush*

Was such a Cale fan in his first two years. where did he go?

The Cockatoo Collins twins come to mind.

I feel vomit rising....

I bagged Jone mercilessly 2 years ago. Got that severely wrong.

The Cookie Monster.

That Jack Watts will be the most dominant FF since Neitz

Tom Scully

Morton, Miller when he was CHB, and Bate.

I was convinced Nick Smith (who?) was going to be a dominant power forward after serving his apprenticeship...